Embracing the Age of Authenticity

by | Sep 18, 2025

“But it’s how we’ve always done it!”
“We don’t have enough volunteers.”
“How can we grow our membership to minimize our deficit?”

How often have you heard these laments in your parish? Or voiced them yourself during times of turbulence, when the path forward feels daunting or unclear? You are not alone; and, this is all a part of a larger evolution. This article looks at how changes in the church reflect a broader cultural shift in the United States from the Age of Association to the Age of Authenticity.

 

The Age of Association

From European colonization through the late 1700s, church, politics, and education were closely linked and funded by local taxes. After these connections loosened, American society saw a rise in voluntary, member-funded organizations—country clubs, labor unions, bowling leagues and yes, churches—that gave people meaning, purpose, and belonging. This era lasted until the late 1960s.1

That time period is called the Age of Association. It was marked by a surge in voluntary groups and organizations that shaped communities and civic life. These associations brought people together for shared purposes but also had limitations: leadership tended to remain in the hands of a few, structures often became rigid over time, and their success depended heavily on members’ steady participation and financial stability in the broader economy.

We see echoes of these same patterns in our churches today. Leadership often falls to a small circle of long-standing members, leaving little room for new leaders to develop. Long-loved traditions can sometimes become barriers to needed change. And sustaining ministry still depends on the time, energy, and resources of congregants—commitments that are increasingly difficult as people juggle demanding schedules, shifting priorities, and economic uncertainty.

 

Facing a Shift

We are now living through a major cultural shift from the Age of Association to the Age of Authenticity. The Age of Authenticity emphasizes self-discovery and the construction of identity through individual choices, often at the expense of trust in and reliance on institutions. “Institutions may have some instrumental value, but [current] relationships to them are fluid, changeable, and loose.”2

People increasingly seek meaning and community individually while distrusting traditional structures. And many church leaders—rather than considering how they can adapt, support, and uplift the spiritual life of the congregation in this new age—instead feel stuck spending all their time keeping up with the management of an institution born in the age of association.

 

What does this mean for churches?

This is a big challenge for our churches. But it’s also a huge opportunity. People are starving for connection. We are facing increasing mental health issues, political polarization, and societal injustices. Our parishes are surrounded by people seeking to make meaning of the current landscape. They are seeking a place to ground themselves in what is true. They are looking to build relationships to help them through the hard times. They are not looking for a place to be a “pledging unit” or a “butt in the pew.”

This is our time to reinstill the core beliefs of our parish—in Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection, the movement of the Holy Spirit, and how God is already at work in the world around us.

This is our time to capitalize on the core practices of our faith—scripture study, forgiveness, prayer, worship, and hospitality.

This is our time to identify the core values of our community—love of neighbor, discernment, grace, and faith.


So what do we do?

As Karl Vaters writes, “Discipleship fixes everything.”3 Here are some practical ideas for how to begin this shift toward embracing the Age of Authenticity.

There is a host of people outside your church doors just waiting for you to experiment, extend invitations, and have conversations.

In the words of Dwight Zscheile and Blair Pogue, “The church is made for times like this…”4

If you want to have a conversation about how this shift is impacting your parish, don’t hesitate to reach out to the Rev. Canon Anne-Marie Jeffery or the Rev. Emily Labrecque.


1Zscheile, Dwight. “From the Age of Association to Authenticity”, Faith + Lead blog
2Dwight J. Zscheile and Blair A. Pogue, Embracing the Mixed Ecology: Inherited and New Forms of Christian Community Flourishing Together (New York: Church Publishing, June 3, 2025), p. 9.
3Karl Vaters, De-Sizing Church: How Church Became a Science, Then an Obsession, and What’s Next (Moody Publishers, April 2, 2024), p. 159.
4Zcheile and Pogue, pp. 12-13