What We’ve Learned About Building A Faith Community: The Well’s Style of Evangelism

by | Nov 18, 2025

The Rev. Rondesia Jarrett-Schell and Wendy Pohlhaus chat with locals about The Well Faith Community at the 2025 Bowie Wine and Food Festival.

The Rev. Rondesia Jarrett-Schell and Wendy Pohlhaus chat with locals about The Well Faith Community at the 2025 Bowie Wine and Food Festival.

“Nothing beats a failure but a try.” Those are the words of wisdom my mother would share when I was a kid and didn’t see progress in my work, needed encouragement, or was left with the sole option of doing the unexpected. I’ve leaned on that wisdom a lot in working to establish The Well, the diocese’s new faith community in Bowie, Maryland. Church planting is a journey filled with ups and downs, trial and error, and little miracles. I’ve learned so much in the past three years—and I’d like to share a few key lessons from my experience so that you, too, can try, try and try again for the greater glory of God.

 

At the Core, an Invitation

The first obstacle—and biggest learning curve—the earliest members of The Well faced lay in discovering an authentic way of evangelizing. Evangelism can be problematic. It has a history with colonialism. It’s long been used to impose faith onto others. Our search for a redeeming quality in this foundational part of church planting was a challenge—until we understood that, at its core, evangelism is an invitation. The question then became not whether to do evangelism, but how do we invite others? What language do we use? What do we want to share about our gatherings for those who know nothing about us? And—taking it one step deeper—what is our invitation style?

 

Making the Invitation Easy to Extend

With our reservations about evangelism front of mind, we focused on that core piece—the invitation. We asked, “What activities do I ask my friends to attend?” We are accustomed to inviting people to a party, a game, to dinner or lunch. We decided the invitation must be as simple as that. “I enjoy those things, so I invite my friends to the things I enjoy.”

Our invitation started to sound like this: “I enjoy the Well. We have great discussions and we eat some amazing food. We meet on Saturdays. Want to come?” Or, springing up in casual conversations, like: “You know, we were talking about that at The Well. I got to hear so many different perspectives, it was honest and spirit led. You should come to the next one. We meet on Saturday.” Once we practiced our language and style, I encouraged members to invite three people in their circle to The Well. They all reported back that it was incredibly easy.

 

Not That Method, But This

As we have continued our experiments with evangelism and invitation, we’ve learned that going door to door is not the best way to reach the wider Bowie community. Not only does this generation not respond to that approach very well, it is way out of our comfort zone. Instead, we focus on community presence. What does that look like? It’s introducing yourself to local businesses. I stop inside just to say hello and offer prayer or a friendly smile. It’s building relationships with regulars in the neighborhood. I build relationships with regulars at the coffee shops, community centers, and local farmers markets. I offer prayer but only if they request prayer. I create opportunities for others to learn more about The Well, but more importantly, these are opportunities for me to learn more about the hopes, dreams, struggles, and needs of those in the neighborhood. It’s building trust. So if the moment comes, a tragedy or loss, they know The Well is available to help.

 

Digital Evangelism

Lastly, we learned that, these days, evangelism begins with an online search—and an up to date Internet presence cannot be skipped. It’s the Yellow Pages of our day. People will visit your website, Youtube channel, or social media before they walk into your church or faith community. It’s where people find friends, local activities, and social communities. A large number of visitors to The Well say they found us online first.

 

Nothing Beats a Failure But a Try

Even with these good practices to draw on, the work of evangelism can be challenging. I’ve met people who didn’t want to know anything about our faith community—and even more who didn’t want an invitation.

But there are people looking for a community or a friendly face. People who hunger for an invitation to something more. So—even if at first these actions may not turn out the way you want—I encourage you to find your invitation style, get to know your neighbors and visit local businesses, and build your community presence.

Because nothing beats a failure but a try.

The Rev. Rondesia Jarrett-Schell
Bowie Church Planter
The Well, Bowie