My young adult children recently confessed that they don’t really know what I do at work, especially since my role expanded to include being the “Diocesan Transition Minister”. I explained it the way I usually do in congregations: I work with congregations who are looking for priests and priests who are looking for congregations. “So you’re like a church yenta!” they said. Always big Fiddler on the Roof fans, they pegged me as the character who matches the villagers in marriage.
Here’s a little peek behind the scenes of the work of your church yenta:
When a Congregation Enters “Transition”
When a rector or priest-in-charge leaves a congregation, the congregation enters what we call “transition.” I or one of my colleagues on diocesan staff pops up the Sunday after the good-bye, or shortly thereafter. We share Eucharist and hold a town hall meeting with the congregation to talk about what happens next.
Congregations have some work to do to prepare to call a new priest. Congregational leaders make plans to cover worship and pastoral needs during the transition. They assess their financial stability to determine a sustainable compensation package that fits their budget, resources and anticipated income. The whole congregation weighs in, assessing the church’s strengths and growing edges, using the Vital Signs of Parish Health. The vestry develops a parish profile to post on the Episcopal Church Vocation Hub and a job description to advertise their rector position.
When the preparatory work is done, EDOW posts the position on Vocation Hub, and the congregation posts it on their own website, the EDOW website Job Openings page, and the Episcopal News Service Jobs & Calls page.
What Goes Into Making a Good Match
I review all the applications that are submitted and walk closely with the wardens of the congregation as they work with their vestry to identify good candidates and design an interview process to get to know them. When congregations consider candidates from outside our diocese, I check with the Transitions Ministers in those other dioceses to make sure that we exchange relevant information about good standing and disciplinary history.
I also proactively seek out candidates who I believe might be a good fit for the congregation in question. When clergy in EDOW are looking for new positions, I work with them to identify opportunities inside and outside the diocese and offer guidance about how to approach the process so their strengths shine through all the paperwork and interviews.
One thing that has changed in EDOW in recent years is that we no longer encourage the formation of a separate rector search committee. The vestry undertakes the search, reference checks, and interviews directly. This allows for a more streamlined process and better enables congregations to make timely offers before their chosen candidates accept other positions.
But Are There Enough Priests?
I get a lot of questions about whether there are enough priests to fill open positions. The answer is a little complicated:
When EDOW congregations list full-time positions with compensation that corresponds to our diocesan scale, they generally get multiple strong candidates. Congregations need to have about $135,000 at minimum available annually in their budgets to offer a full time position. That doesn’t mean that the priest earns all that in cash. You have to add about 25% to cash salary to cover pension contributions and employment tax reimbursements, and health insurance for two people costs another $24,000.
The hard part of the priest job market comes from the fact that many congregations (about 40% in EDOW, 60% nationally) cannot offer full-time positions. That makes the full-time positions that do come around very competitive, which can be frustrating for priests who are looking for a change or an increase in responsibility. Most non-retired priests need to work full time to support their living expenses, so part-time jobs are much less attractive and often receive few if any applications. At the diocesan level, we are actively working with congregations to restructure part-time positions to allow priests to combine positions and to consider collaborating with neighboring churches to create full-time positions that serve more than one congregation.
My Favorite Part
My favorite part of the church yenta role is working with the amazing wardens and vestries in EDOW. Shepherding a congregation through transition is a heavy lift for the lay leadership. It is my honor and joy to walk alongside these brave leaders and share in the ups and downs that inevitably come with the process. I encourage them to breathe, pray, laugh and keep perspective. They inspire me with their commitment to the present and future of EDOW’s diverse congregations.
If your congregation is or has ever been in transition… take good care of your leaders! Thank them. Be patient and loving and kind. They are working harder than you can imagine.
The Rev. Anna B. Olson
Canon for Faith, Leadership and Collaboration — and your friendly diocesan transitions church yenta
