One of the most misunderstood topics in parish administration and finance is our Church’s Canonical Audit requirement. I am asked about it weekly from congregations across the Diocese, and it is understandable why there is confusion. Some churches use outside accounting firms while others rely on volunteers. Some people understand and have used Committee Audits. Many have utilized the Agreed-Upon Procedures option. The one thing that I’d like to ensure every person in church leadership understands is that every Episcopal congregation is required to have its financial accounts audited annually, and there are many ways to satisfy this requirement.
Our Manual of Business Methods in Church Affairs is the best resource for understanding the requirements of church audits, and it states clearly that annual audits are required by the Canons of The Episcopal Church for all parishes, missions, and other institutions.
But, an annual audit does not necessarily mean an expensive CPA audit. This is where understanding the various options becomes important. The canonical requirement does not mean every congregation must pay for a traditional outside CPA audit every year.
In the Diocese of Washington, congregations have several ways to meet the annual requirement:
-
- A traditional audit by an independent CPA or Public Accountant. This provides the highest level of outside assurance and may be appropriate or required in certain circumstances.
- An Agreed-Upon Procedures (AUP) engagement with an independent CPA. EDOW’s Finance Committee has approved AUP engagements as a canonical alternative. Rather than issuing the formal opinion associated with a traditional audit, the CPA performs an agreed set of procedures and reports the findings. EDOW’s experience with AUPs has been that they can provide useful attention to a congregation’s financial practices and internal controls at a lower cost than a traditional audit.
- A Committee Audit. EDOW also permits congregations to conduct an audit using the procedures in the Manual of Business Methods in Church Affairs. The people conducting the examination should be independent of the congregation’s financial decision-making and recordkeeping functions, and the committee should include financial expertise.
A Committee Audit is not simply asking someone to “look over the books.” The Manual provides detailed procedures covering receipts, expenditures, bank accounts, investments, restricted funds, loans, property, payroll, insurance, discretionary funds, and internal controls. And all church accounts are subject to audit, including restricted and endowment funds and accounts of affiliated organizations.
One important distinction: a CPA review or compilation is not an audit and, by itself, does not satisfy the canonical requirement.
When is an Outside Audit Necessary?
There are times when a congregation will need a professional outside audit rather than one of the less costly alternatives. In EDOW, financial reviews are an established part of the transition process when a congregation is preparing to call a new rector. It is best to have an outside audit during a transition. A bank considering a mortgage, a foundation considering a significant grant, or others may require independently audited financial statements. That is another reason for keeping financial records and internal controls in good order every year.
Whose Responsibility is It?
The responsibility for arranging the annual audit rests with the congregation and its leadership. The diocesan office does not approach this primarily as an enforcement exercise or routinely pursue congregations simply because an audit is overdue. But the responsibility remains, and completed audits should be received by the Vestry and submitted to the Diocese. Audits should be filed with the Diocese within 30 days of completion and no later than September 1 for the preceding year.
Ultimately, an audit is about more than compliance. It is part of our faithful financial practices. A healthy parish utilizes financial best practices such as audits. Healthy finances are part of a faithful conversation, understood as Christian stewardship and formation and audits help protect our treasurers, clergy, vestries, volunteers, and the resources entrusted to our congregations.
Annual audits are due 30 days after they are completed and no later than September 1. Still have questions? Reach out to me at tsinclair@edow.org.
The Rev. Thom Sinclair
Chief Operating Officer
