To Believe in the Risen Jesus

To Believe in the Risen Jesus

Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, Mary Magdalene came to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the tomb. So she ran and went to Simon Peter and the other disciple, the one whom Jesus loved, and said to them, “They have taken the Lord out of the tomb, and we do not know where they have laid him.” Then Peter and the other disciple set out and went toward the tomb. The two were running together, but the other disciple outran Peter and reached the tomb first. He bent down to look in and saw the linen wrappings lying there, but he did not go in. Then Simon Peter came, following him, and went into the tomb. He saw the linen wrappings lying there, and the cloth that had been on Jesus’ head, not lying with the linen wrappings but rolled up in a place by itself. Then the other disciple, who reached the tomb first, also went in, and he saw and believed; for as yet they did not understand the scripture, that he must rise from the dead. Then the disciples returned to their homes. But Mary stood weeping outside the tomb. As she wept, she bent over to look into the tomb; and she saw two angels in white, sitting where the body of Jesus had been lying, one at the head and the other at the feet. They said to her, “Woman, why are you weeping?” She said to them, “They have taken away my Lord, and I do not know where they have laid him.” When she had said this, she turned around and saw Jesus standing there, but she did not know that it was Jesus. Jesus said to her, “Woman, why are you weeping? Whom are you looking for?” Supposing him to be the gardener, she said to him, “Sir, if you have carried him away, tell me where you have laid him, and I will take him away.” Jesus said to her, “Mary!” She turned and said to him in Hebrew, “Rabbouni!” (which means Teacher). Jesus said to her, “Do not hold on to me, because I have not yet ascended to the Father. But go to my brothers and say to them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’”Mary Magdalene went and announced to the disciples, “I have seen the Lord”; and she told them that he had said these things to her.
John 20:1-18

A good Easter morning to you. Thank you for being part of this wondrous celebration of the mystery of faith—that Christ has died, yet Christ is risen, and Christ will come again.

Should you be among those struggling with what it means to be a person of faith, rest assured that you are in good company. The first witnesses to the resurrection did not have an easy time of it, either.

If today were Christmas, we would likely have a pageant, telling the story of Jesus’ birth by combining two biblical versions into one narrative, with children taking the primary roles of a great cast of characters proclaiming peace on earth, good will to all. But today is Easter and there is no pageant. If there were, the composite rendition of the first Easter morning would be one of chaos, fueled by grief and a serious lack of sleep.

Of the four biblical accounts, the Gospel of John’s (our text for today) is the most chaotic. There is lots of confusion and running back and forth. Mary Magdalene is the first to arrive. Finding the tomb empty, she runs to find two of Jesus’ male disciples. Together they run to the tomb. One arrives first but doesn’t go in. The other races past the first and enters. The other follows, and by going in, he believes, the text tells us, though it’s not clear what that means.

Then, inexplicably, the two men go home—exit stage left, leaving Mary alone again, or so it seems. After weeping for a time outside the tomb, she goes in again, only to encounter two angels, who weren’t there before. They ask her why she’s crying.

Why is she crying? By now she must be frantic. Can someone please tell me what has happened to his body? She turns around and sees someone whom she assumes is the gardener, until she hears him say her name. When Mary realizes that Jesus is standing before her, she rushes to embrace him, but he tells her, no. “Do not hold onto me. But go and tell the others.” So she goes. And so does he.

The curtain falls. End of Scene One.

There is more to come, because the resurrection is not revealed to Mary or the others as a one-time event. It’s more like an awakening, a stunning realization that confronts them over and over again.

In all the resurrection stories of the New Testament, Jesus appears to his disciples. He shows up, and it’s a surprise every time. He doesn’t seem to stay long. In some stories, it’s clear that his appearance is mystical (that is, had there been a film crew there, they may not have been able to record it). But in others, his physicality is front and center. He insists that they can touch him; he sits down with them to eat. In one story, he cooks breakfast, and then gives Simon Peter a chance to redeem his denial of Jesus before he died, as if to say, Peter, you don’t have to live with the guilt anymore.

One thing all these stories have in common: as soon as the disciples recognize Jesus for who he is, he disappears. The fact that he disappears doesn’t seem to surprise anyone.

May I suggest to you that the resurrection stories are not accounts of life as we know it.

No, these are stories to describe what it feels like to glimpse another dimension of life beyond this world. Their power isn’t in the details of the stories themselves, but what they are attempting to convey, and that is the lived experience and hope that lies at the heart of Christian faith.

“To believe in the risen Jesus,” writes Rowan Williams, former Archbishop of Canterbury, “is to trust that the generative power of God is active in the human world.”1

To believe in the risen Jesus is to trust that the generative power of God is active in the human world.

Several weeks ago I was interviewed by a team of television journalists from the Netherlands. I’ve been interviewed quite a lot lately by the European press. For all the reasons you can imagine, Europeans are fascinated with American politics now, and in particular, with the role of Christianity in our public life. I do my best to answer their questions, although it’s hard for me to fully understand the role of Christianity in our public life, particularly when there are different understandings of what it means to be a Christian, and what it means for Christians to be involved in public life—which has always been true, by the way. But all that aside.

As we were coming to the end of this particular interview, one of the journalists said, “We will air this program on Easter morning. So I wonder if you might look directly at the camera and speak to the Dutch people about the meaning of Easter.”

Okay. As often happens when I’m put on the spot like that, my mind went blank. I couldn’t tell you what I said, and I was certain that I wouldn’t be able to repeat it. And wouldn’t you know, as soon as I finished, the one behind the camera looked up and said, “Oh, that was lovely, but unfortunately, I forgot to turn the camera back on. Would you mind saying that again?”

So I had two anxiety-producing moments, on camera, attempting to give an account, as Scripture says, for the hope that lies within me.

I’ve had a bit more time since then to prepare my thoughts. What I’d like to share with you now is an extended version of what I hope I said to the people of the Netherlands.

Resurrection is, at heart, about life after death, which is not a uniquely Christian concept. Nearly all spiritual traditions through which human beings have sought to find meaning share a sense that there is more to life than what we know; that there is, indeed, another realm.

Whenever we try to get too specific about life beyond this world, we invariably get it wrong (although we can’t know for certain on this side of things). I remember sitting around my father-in-law’s hospital bed as he was dying. After giving one son last instructions about tools in the basement and asking his nephew about the stock market, he wanted to talk to me about heaven. He was a man of faith, but he was struggling with the images of heaven in his head—angels in the clouds, singing all those hymns. “It doesn’t sound very appealing, Mariann.” “I hear you, Ed,” I said. “But I think it’s more than we can possibly imagine.”

I believe in that other realm—not that I have proof, but I’ve come to trust it as real. Whenever I think of those I love who have crossed over, and especially those I struggled to love, my sense is that they’re all right, and quite likely, on to other things now. And when I consider the countless human beings whose lives are snuffed out in the cruelest possible ways, for which other human beings are responsible, there is some consolation in knowing that no more harm can come to them. It doesn’t take away the outrage of such death, yet alongside the grief, there is a gratitude for what lies beyond what we know.

But resurrection is not only about what happens when we die. It is also the lived experience of humankind. On this side of death, Jesus’ resurrection is an icon of assurance that God is with us in and through the worst that can happen, and that we do to one another, and in God, that the worst is never the end.

Whenever we imagine Christianity as a faith of prosperity and triumph, I fear that we aren’t reading our gospels carefully. For they tell of a God who suffers alongside us through whatever we must endure, not in triumph but in quiet amazement that life can go on after something or someone precious has been lost.

The mercy of Christ meets us in the crucible of real life, where real things happen, not all of them easy. And from the ashes of what dies, resurrection is the assurance that a new life is possible. Not the old life and not necessarily the life we want, but life nonetheless.

And resurrection is not a one-time event for us. It’s a series of awakenings throughout our lives, each one a surprise.

In some schools of Christian thought, the whole point of Jesus’ life was to come and die for us, as a necessary sacrifice for our sin, so that we might gain eternal life that would otherwise be denied us, provided that we believe in him. I came to faith in Jesus in that Christian worldview, and I’m grateful for it. I will go to my grave believing that Jesus died for my sins, and not for mine only but for yours, and for the sins of the whole world. But I no longer believe that Jesus came to give us a transactional and fear-based faith, for his way is the way of love. I don’t believe that God’s is transactional, or conditional. And perfect love casts out fear.

Yes, Jesus died for us. But he also lived for us. He came to show us how to live and how to love. “He went around doing good,” Scripture tells us, healing, teaching, and assuring the poor and the outcast of God’s love. “He did so with such single mindedness and effectiveness,” writes world religion scholar Huston Smith, “that those who were with him found themselves thinking that if divine goodness were to manifest itself in human form, this is how it would behave.”2

Of course his followers were devastated when he died—executed in the most gruesome manner reserved for insurrectionists and escaped slaves—not only because they loved him, but because he seemed so much more than a man. “We had hoped,” one of the disciples says in a different Easter narrative, “We had hoped that he would be the one to redeem Israel.”

In the normal course of things that would have been the end of his story. But then came Easter morning, and their experience of the risen Jesus, whom death could not destroy, whose love they were now to carry forward. What’s more, he promised to be with them to the end of age.

And he promises to be with us, as we live the mystery of the faith.

In closing, let me say a brief word about the ways we Christians differ in our understandings of so many things, some quite consequential now, visible for all the world to see. That we differ is not new. Christians have disagreed on the fundamentals of faith since the Council of Jerusalem that is recorded in the Book of Acts. Let me suggest that how we disagree is what should concern us. We do well to remember the one thing upon which all our lives, both now and at the hour of our death, depend is forgiveness.

Jesus lived to show us how to love. He died to forgive us for the ways we fail to love. He is risen to assure us that there is life after death, and to be with us always. His is not a passive presence, but an active one. He is here to inspire, to guide, to forgive, and empower us to love as he loves and forgive as he forgives.

To believe in the risen Jesus is to trust that the generative power of God is active in our world.

If God has not given up on us, we need not give up on ourselves and each other, and our hope for a better day for all God’s children and for this world.

Amen.

1Rowan Williams Resurrection: Interpreting the Easter Gospel. Kindle Edition, 2014. Location 830
2Huston Smith, The Soul of Christianity: Restoring the Great Tradition (HarperSanFrancisco, 2005), 48.

The Still Days: Entering the Mystery of Holy Week

The Still Days: Entering the Mystery of Holy Week

To believe in the risen Jesus is to trust that the generative power of God is active in the human world; that it can be experienced as transformation and recreation and empowerment in the present; and that its availability and relevance extends to every human situation.
Rowan Williams, Resurrection: Interpreting the Easter Gospel

We join with Christians around the world in the observance of Holy Week, culminating with our celebration on Easter morning. These are what our spiritual forebears called “the still days,” inviting us, amid all that our lives demand of us, to take this time to ponder the way of the cross and the hope of resurrection. Another word used to describe this week is “passion,” evoking the depth and intensity of Jesus’ love, in the fullness of his humanity and at the same time, revealing to us what divine love in human form looks like.

Never am I more proud to serve this diocese than as our clergy and lay leaders prepare for Holy Week and Easter. Whether for a small gathering or a full sanctuary, they give their all so that others may know the transforming power of Jesus’ love. Please join me in praying that the Spirit give them (or you, if you are among them) inspiration and a sense of joy in this work.

This year I’ve noticed the care with which many of our leaders are teaching those new to The Episcopal Church about the foundational observances of our faith. Though hardly a new Christian, I find in their words fresh understandings about ancient practices and they deepen my faith in the risen Jesus and desire to follow in his ways.

As one example, I share with you what the Rev. Robert Bunker, rector of St. Philip’s, Laurel, wrote to his congregation in answer to the question,

What is the Triduum?

The Triduum (“three days” in Latin) is one service over three days, a profound journey compressed into three days that is at the heart of the Christian liturgical year. It’s a time that strips away the noise of everyday life and pulls you into the raw, transformative mystery of Christ’s passion, death, and resurrection. Intentionally taking the time to reflect on it feels like standing at the edge of something vast, where words strain to capture the weight.

Holy Thursday hits with a quiet intensity. The washing of feet, and the institution of the Eucharist. It is all about service and sacrifice. I’m struck by how Jesus, knowing what’s coming, chooses to kneel and wash his disciples’ feet. It’s a radical act of humility, a call to love in the face of betrayal. The Eucharist, too, feels like a gift that keeps unfolding. Yet, there is a shadow over it, because Judas leaves and the garden awaits. It is a reminder that love doesn’t flinch from suffering.

Good Friday is stark, and heavy. The cross looms large, and there’s no sugarcoating it. Jesus’ agony, his cry of abandonment, pierces through any romanticized notions of redemption. Reflecting on it forces me to confront my own complicity, my sins, and my indifferences that all add to that weight. But there is also this paradox: the cross is both a scandal and a triumph. The cross is where despair meets hope, where God’s love refuses to be extinguished. Sitting with that tension, I feel both broken and strangely held.

The Easter Vigil is like a deep exhale after holding your breath. It is a journey that begins in a swirl of darkness, the first flames of fire, and the Exsultet (the Easter proclamation). It is a shift from mourning to joy that feels almost disorienting. The readings trace salvation’s arc, from creation to resurrection, and it is as if time collapses, pulling us into God’s story. The empty tomb isn’t just an event; it’s a promise that death does not get the last word. I am left with this sense of awe, but also a challenge: to live as if the resurrection matters, to carry that light into a world that often feels shadowed.

The Triduum does not let you stay comfortable. It’s a pilgrimage that demands you walk through betrayal, suffering, and loss to reach hope. Each year it reshapes me a little by exposing my weaknesses, while also deepening my trust in a God who enters the mess and makes it holy. It is not just a remembrance; it is an invitation to die and rise, again and again.

Thank you, Robert, and all who invite us to join the universal Christian pilgrimage from death to life.

A blessed Holy Week and Easter to all.

Moving From Darkness To Light

Moving From Darkness To Light

On this most Holy Night, in which our Lord Jesus passed over from death to live, the Church invites her members, dispersed throughout the world, to gather in vigil and prayer.
Easter Vigil Liturgy, Book of Common Prayer

When the sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome bought spices, so that they might go and anoint him. And very early on the first day of the week, when the sun had risen, they went to the tomb. They had been saying to one another, “Who will roll away the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” When they looked up, they saw that the stone, which was very large, had already been rolled back. As they entered the tomb, they saw a young man, dressed in a white robe, sitting on the right side; and they were alarmed. But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed; you are looking for Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has been raised; he is not here. Look, there is the place they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you.” So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.
Mark 16:1-8

Resurrection is the mysterious process of life rising out of death. It always begins small. In the darkest hour, a seed of life begins to stir, and we rise. Before we know what’s happening, we’re moving toward what lies on a far horizon. To anyone watching us, we’re just going about our day, and we are. But something has changed and we know it.

Faith in the resurrection doesn’t require us to cast a blind eye to all that is not or has yet to be redeemed. For starters, we needn’t pretend that the world isn’t on fire. We know that as we gather here in relative safety, others are huddled in fear for their lives, and we can hold their grief, and ours, with us now. Nor do we have to surrender our perplexity or skepticism in the face of all we don’t understand.

Recently I spoke by telephone with an old friend, someone I’ve known and loved for over 30 years. She and her family were active in the congregation I served in Toledo, Ohio for the first five years of my ordained ministry. She is our younger son’s godmother.

After catching up on family and other things, I asked her if she had plans for Easter. (By the way, she and her family had stopped attending a long time ago.) She said, “Well, this wasn’t the conversation I wasn’t planning on having with my friend the bishop, but since you asked, I need to tell you that of all Christian holidays, Easter is the one I struggle with most. I don’t know how to make sense of the idea that Jesus died for our sins. It doesn’t bother me to be around people for whom it does make sense, but it’s a real stumbling block for me, and I’ve been thinking about it since we spoke.

I was in my car while we were having this conversation, and all I was really asking was where she was going to have dinner. So I wasn’t sure where to begin. Finally I said, light-heartedly, “You know, you are the very first person I know who has struggled with this.” She laughed, which was good. Then I assured her that Jesus dying for our sins has been a subject of intense debate among Christians throughout the ages, and thus there are many ways to think about it.

I was already thinking about a few articles and essays on the resurrection that I wanted to send her. “Before we talk in earnest about this,” I said, “it would help me to know what you mean when you say ‘Jesus died for our sins.’ It can mean very different things to different people.” I was thinking of all the times when people say to me that they don’t believe in God and I ask them to describe the God they don’t believe in, because chances are good that I don’t believe in that God, either.

By then I had reached my destination and we had to stop. But I’ve been thinking about our conversation since then, and it occurred to me that there was one story in particular that I wanted to share with her, because that best expresses my understanding of what the phrase ‘Jesus died for our sins’ means. It doesn’t speak to me intellectually, but poetically. It doesn’t answer all the questions I have, but it resonates in my heart.

So let me close by telling this story to you. In doing so, I honor a dear friend who shared it with me years ago and who died last summer. It’s not my story, but it feels like mine—that’s how deeply it speaks to me of forgiveness and love and what Jesus makes possible for us.

This is for you, Perry Epes.

The story is found in a trilogy, The Seed and the Sower, written by the South African author, Laurens van der Post. It begins with the haunting confession of a young British soldier:

“I had a brother once and I betrayed him.”

He goes on, “The betrayal in itself was so slight that most people would find ‘betrayal’ too exaggerated a word. Yet as one recognizes the nature of the seed from the tree, and the tree by its fruit, and the fruit by the taste on the tongue, so I know the betrayal from its consequences and the tyrannical flavor it left behind in my emotions…

So this is a tale of shame, the shame that this young man, who was blessed with physical beauty and intelligence, felt about his younger brother, who was, in contrast, slightly deformed, quiet and self-conscious. His brother’s only gift, it seemed, was that of song, hardly anything in comparison to the other’s many talents. Few noticed this gift, and it was a source of curiosity among other boys. The young man felt his brother’s deformity as a threat to his own identity, and while he was on the surface protective and affectionate, inside he felt embarrassed and resentful.

The time came for his brother to join him at boarding school, and when the hazing rituals began—a humiliating experience for any boy—his brother was particularly humiliated and scorned. He felt that he ought to say something, but he did nothing but watch from a distance, avoiding his brother’s increasingly desperate eyes that searched for him in the mocking crowds. Afterwards he made light of his brother’s pain and they never spoke of it again. Nor did his brother ever sing again.

Years past and during World War II, the older brother found himself in Palestine as a soldier in the British Army. There he met an old priest who became his friend. The priest told him that every year at Easter, he walked the seven mile walk between Jerusalem and Emmaus, to remember Jesus’ encounter with the two disciples on the road. “I walk only at night,” the priest told him, “to remind myself of all the ways I fail to recognize Jesus in the daylight of my life.” That Easter night the soldier joined him. It was an unremarkable experience, but shortly afterwards he became quite ill with a recurring bout of malaria.

Fevered and hallucinating, he dreamed of the Resurrected One on the road. “Where is Judas?” Jesus asked in the dream. “We can’t go on without him.” The soldier listened as the other disciples explained to Jesus that Judas was dead, that he hanged himself in shame. Jesus responded by looking up to heaven in prayer. “This cannot be! If I fail in this, I fail in all else besides. His deed, too, must be redeemed.”

Then the man in his dream stepped forward. “I am Judas.” Jesus smiled. “Good. Now we can both be free.” “But I am not free,” the man confessed. “I had a brother once, and I betrayed him.” Jesus nodded slowly, in understanding kindness. “Then you must go to your brother and make our peace with him, even as I have had to do with my need of you.”

On his next furlough, the man traveled back to South Africa, found his brother on their family farm and acknowledged his guilt. “You came all the way here simply to say this to me?” the brother marveled. When the soldier left to return to his military post, he heard his brother singing.

What I love about this story, and why it speaks to me of Jesus’ dying for our sins, isn’t that it ends in such a satisfying reconciliation. That almost never happens for me. What I love is Jesus’ question: “Where is Judas?” and his insistence to God, “We can’t go on without him.”

I love that the accomplished brother carried in his soul the secret of his guilt, and it was there, in that dark place with no one save the priest who heard his confession, that Jesus met him and set him free. I love that forgiveness came with a path of restitution, a way of making things as right as we can and to join with Jesus in helping others to rise, too.

So yes, I believe that Jesus died for our sins, not as a substituting sacrifice, but as an expression of sacrificial love that will not let us go, no matter who we are, what we have done, or what has been done to us.

To be a person of faith in this world is a daily discipline of taking small steps each day toward life, even if it isn’t the life we wanted or imagined, even when the worst thing possible has happened. It is a grace that meets us where we are, but does not leave us there.

Resurrection asks us to stake our life on hope when hope feels small. The poet Gwendolyn Brooks, the first African American to win the Pulitzer Prize, once wrote, “Say to the down-keepers, the sun-slappers, the self-soilers, the harmony-hushers, ‘even if you are not ready for day, it cannot always be night.’”

It cannot always be night. Even though it’s still dark, the light of Christ is calling us, asking us to be the ones to move out in faith. Who knows what will be lost if we don’t? And what might happen when we do?

Read Bishop Mariann’s full Easter Vigil sermon here

Moving From Darkness To Light – Easter Vigil Sermon

Moving From Darkness To Light – Easter Vigil Sermon

On this most Holy Night, in which our Lord Jesus passed over from death to live, the Church invites her members, dispersed throughout the world, to gather in vigil and prayer.
Easter Vigil Liturgy, Book of Common Prayer

When the sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome bought spices, so that they might go and anoint him. And very early on the first day of the week, when the sun had risen, they went to the tomb. They had been saying to one another, “Who will roll away the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” When they looked up, they saw that the stone, which was very large, had already been rolled back. As they entered the tomb, they saw a young man, dressed in a white robe, sitting on the right side; and they were alarmed. But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed; you are looking for Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has been raised; he is not here. Look, there is the place they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you.” So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.
Mark 16:1-8

Sometimes we have to move toward the light while it is still dark.

Sometimes we have to move toward love even when we don’t feel it.

Sometimes we have to move toward life even when we’re just going through the motions, and not really living anymore.

Moving toward light when it’s still dark is awkward, and it’s tentative. But there are times when we simply need to move.

Early on the first Easter morning, it was the women of Jesus’ inner circle who moved. They went first, not that they had any idea that that was what they were doing. They rose that night from the stupor of grief, fully expecting to anoint a dead body.

That’s how resurrection works. Someone gets up in the middle of the night, gets up and moves, and in the movement something happens, and dawn breaks.

Notice, too, that resurrection is a collective experience, with implications for many people, but someone has to go first and make a path so others can follow. That’s what the women did. What they experienced was beyond credulity. So “they said nothing to anyone of what they heard and saw because they were afraid.” (Mk 16:8)

Well, so says that text. But eventually they did tell somebody, despite their fear, no doubt, struggling to believe what the young man at the tomb had told them as much as those first listening to that bizarre story.

There’s another version of the story (there are lots of versions, by the way) in which the young man at the tomb becomes an angel. In another Jesus himself appears in the garden, rather telling them to go to Galilee to meet him there. There’s another version in which the men eventually show up at the tomb after the women (just saying), and in another, the men gather in fear in the same room where they had shared their final meal with Jesus. In yet another, two of the men were so bereft they simply had to get out of town and they started walking toward another town named Emmaus. There’s one more in which the disciples all go back to Galilee to resume their previous lives as fishermen.

For all the variations on the earliest accounts of Jesus’ resurrection, there is a common thread. Jesus appears to the disciples in ways that are at once other-worldly, in that he wasn’t simply resuscitated, He is alive, but not as before and they know it. At the same time, his appearances are also strikingly mundane. He simply showed up as they were going through the motions of life, which made it all rather frightening and wonderful, and strangely normal.

I cannot speak to you from personal experience about what happened on that first Easter, or of what happens to us on the other side of our physical death.

But this I know: on this side of our final crossing over, while the context of resurrection is death, it takes place in the midst of daily life. Something or someone dies, and with that something or someone, a part of us dies, too. For a while—sometimes for a very long time—we live as though dead ourselves. If the loss is deep enough, that’s just fine with us.

Resurrection is the mysterious process of life rising out of that death. It always begins small. In the darkest hour, a seed of life begins to stir, and we rise. Before we know what’s happening, we’re moving toward what lies on a far horizon. To anyone watching us, we’re just going about our day, and we are. But something has changed and we know it.

Faith in the resurrection doesn’t require us to cast a blind eye to all that is not or has yet to be redeemed. For starters, we needn’t pretend that the world isn’t on fire. We know that as we gather here in relative safety, others are huddled in fear for their lives, and we can hold their grief, and ours, with us now. Nor do we have to surrender our perplexity or skepticism in the face of all we don’t understand.

Recently I spoke by telephone with an old friend, someone I’ve known and loved for over 30 years. She and her family were active in the congregation I served in Toledo, Ohio for the first five years of my ordained ministry. She is our younger son’s godmother.

After catching up on family and other things, I asked her if she had plans for Easter. (By the way, she and her family had stopped attending a long time ago.) She said, “Well, this wasn’t the conversation I wasn’t planning on having with my friend the bishop, but since you asked, I need to tell you that of all Christian holidays, Easter is the one I struggle with most. I don’t know how to make sense of the idea that Jesus died for our sins. It doesn’t bother me to be around people for whom it does make sense, but it’s a real stumbling block for me, and I’ve been thinking about it since we spoke.

I was in my car while we were having this conversation, and all I was really asking was where she was going to have dinner. So I wasn’t sure where to begin. Finally I said, light-heartedly, “You know, you are the very first person I know who has struggled with this.” She laughed, which was good. Then I assured her that Jesus dying for our sins has been a subject of intense debate among Christians throughout the ages, and thus there are many ways to think about it.

I was already thinking about a few articles and essays on the resurrection that I wanted to send her. “Before we talk in earnest about this,” I said, “it would help me to know what you mean when you say ‘Jesus died for our sins.’ It can mean very different things to different people.” I was thinking of all the times when people say to me that they don’t believe in God and I ask them to describe the God they don’t believe in, because chances are good that I don’t believe in that God, either.

By then I had reached my destination and we had to stop. But I’ve been thinking about our conversation since then, and it occurred to me that there was one story in particular that I wanted to share with her, because that best expresses my understanding of what the phrase ‘Jesus died for our sins’ means. It doesn’t speak to me intellectually, but poetically. It doesn’t answer all the questions I have, but it resonates in my heart.

So let me close by telling this story to you. In doing so, I honor a dear friend who shared it with me years ago and who died last summer. It’s not my story, but it feels like mine—that’s how deeply it speaks to me of forgiveness and love and what Jesus makes possible for us.

This is for you, Perry Epes.

The story is found in a trilogy, The Seed and the Sower, written by the South African author, Laurens van der Post. It begins with the haunting confession of a young British soldier:

“I had a brother once and I betrayed him.”

He goes on, “The betrayal in itself was so slight that most people would find ‘betrayal’ too exaggerated a word. Yet as one recognizes the nature of the seed from the tree, and the tree by its fruit, and the fruit by the taste on the tongue, so I know the betrayal from its consequences and the tyrannical flavor it left behind in my emotions…

So this is a tale of shame, the shame that this young man, who was blessed with physical beauty and intelligence, felt about his younger brother, who was, in contrast, slightly deformed, quiet and self-conscious. His brother’s only gift, it seemed, was that of song, hardly anything in comparison to the other’s many talents. Few noticed this gift, and it was a source of curiosity among other boys. The young man felt his brother’s deformity as a threat to his own identity, and while he was on the surface protective and affectionate, inside he felt embarrassed and resentful.

The time came for his brother to join him at boarding school, and when the hazing rituals began—a humiliating experience for any boy—his brother was particularly humiliated and scorned. He felt that he ought to say something, but he did nothing but watch from a distance, avoiding his brother’s increasingly desperate eyes that searched for him in the mocking crowds. Afterwards he made light of his brother’s pain and they never spoke of it again. Nor did his brother ever sing again.

Years past and during World War II, the older brother found himself in Palestine as a soldier in the British Army. There he met an old priest who became his friend. The priest told him that every year at Easter, he walked the seven mile walk between Jerusalem and Emmaus, to remember Jesus’ encounter with the two disciples on the road. “I walk only at night,” the priest told him, “to remind myself of all the ways I fail to recognize Jesus in the daylight of my life.” That Easter night the soldier joined him. It was an unremarkable experience, but shortly afterwards he became quite ill with a recurring bout of malaria.

Fevered and hallucinating, he dreamed of the Resurrected One on the road. “Where is Judas?” Jesus asked in the dream. “We can’t go on without him.” The soldier listened as the other disciples explained to Jesus that Judas was dead, that he hanged himself in shame. Jesus responded by looking up to heaven in prayer. “This cannot be! If I fail in this, I fail in all else besides. His deed, too, must be redeemed.”

Then the man in his dream stepped forward. “I am Judas.” Jesus smiled. “Good. Now we can both be free.” “But I am not free,” the man confessed. “I had a brother once, and I betrayed him.” Jesus nodded slowly, in understanding kindness. “Then you must go to your brother and make our peace with him, even as I have had to do with my need of you.”

On his next furlough, the man traveled back to South Africa, found his brother on their family farm and acknowledged his guilt. “You came all the way here simply to say this to me?” the brother marveled. When the soldier left to return to his military post, he heard his brother singing.

What I love about this story, and why it speaks to me of Jesus’ dying for our sins, isn’t that it ends in such a satisfying reconciliation. That almost never happens for me. What I love is Jesus’ question: “Where is Judas?” and his insistence to God, “We can’t go on without him.”

I love that the accomplished brother carried in his soul the secret of his guilt, and it was there, in that dark place with no one save the priest who heard his confession, that Jesus met him and set him free. I love that forgiveness came with a path of restitution, a way of making things as right as we can and to join with Jesus in helping others to rise, too.

So yes, I believe that Jesus died for our sins, not as a substituting sacrifice, but as an expression of sacrificial love that will not let us go, no matter who we are, what we have done, or what has been done to us.

To be a person of faith in this world is a daily discipline of taking small steps each day toward life, even if it isn’t the life we wanted or imagined, even when the worst thing possible has happened. It is a grace that meets us where we are, but does not leave us there.

Resurrection asks us to stake our life on hope when hope feels small. The poet Gwendolyn Brooks, the first African American to win the Pulitzer Prize, once wrote, “Say to the down-keepers, the sun-slappers, the self-soilers, the harmony-hushers, ‘even if you are not ready for day, it cannot always be night.’”

It cannot always be night. Even though it’s still dark, the light of Christ is calling us, asking us to be the ones to move out in faith. Who knows what will be lost if we don’t? And what might happen when we do?

The Great Vigil of Easter

The Great Vigil of Easter

Journey from darkness to light, from death to life, as we bear witness to the Paschal Mystery through powerful music, the retelling of the salvation story and welcoming new believers in Baptism. Incense is used at this service. All are welcome to bring bells. Livestream available.