“What do you think? A man had two sons; he went to the first and said, ‘Son, go and work in the vineyard today.’ He answered, ‘I will not’; but later he changed his mind and went. The father went to the second and said the same; and he answered, ‘I go, sir’; but he did not go. Which of the two did the will of his father?” They said, “The first.” Jesus said to them, “Truly I tell you, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are going into the kingdom of God ahead of you. For John came to you in the way of righteousness and you did not believe him, but the tax collectors and the prostitutes believed him; and even after you saw it, you did not change your minds and believe him.
Matthew 21:23-32
Let me begin by saying how happy I am to be with you this morning, and offering thanks to God for the faithful members of Our Saviour, Brookland, for your vestry, led so faithfully by Ms. Sherrone Ivy. A warm welcome to our guests in worship, including my sister Christine, who came all the way from Texas to worship with us.
I hope you know that the ministry of Our Saviour’s this past summer was one of the most impactful and inspiring in all our diocese. Thank you for hosting the English learning summer camp, El Veranito, so that children living in hotels after their long, traumatic journeys from their homelands could have, with their families, an experience of loving community, learning, and fun. Collaborative endeavors such as this between Our Saviour, St. Thomas’ Episcopal in Dupont Circle, and others across the diocese helped us all see that when inspired by a holy vision, and working collaboratively toward its realization, God can do amazing things through us.
I’ve been your bishop for 12 years now. A big part of my job is to make Sunday rounds among the 86 congregations of our diocese, which, you may know, includes all of Washington, DC and four Maryland counties. In these 12 years, I’ve been with Our Saviour on four previous Sundays, the most recent via Zoom during the height of the pandemic in 2020. I will never forget my first visit to Our Saviour–the Easter Vigil of 2012, when the now Rev. Dr. Gayle Fisher-Stewart, whom Our Saviour sponsored for ordination, invited me to be with you. I’ve also met with your leaders throughout the years, and worked alongside the clergy who have served here in multiple capacities.
Reading through my Our Saviour file this week–documenting the visits, communications, clergy contracts, exploration of neighborhood engagement, and thank you notes written for your support of the wider diocese–I was reminded how much can happen in 12 years. People come and go, children grow up and move on. Some have children of their own; some come back to live in the homes where they were raised. Beloved elders are called home and are now in that place beyond the Jordan that awaits us all. Neighborhoods change; the world changes. And through it all, we, as church, do our best to live a Jesus-focused life, and be true to what we know and have inherited.
I came into my work as bishop with a deep sense of call to do whatever I could to help our church as a whole and the individual congregations of this diocese find their place in a changing societal and religious landscape, to lean into the adaptive process that allows not only the human species, but expressions of human community–like Our Saviour, Brookland–to evolve and thrive in the changing contexts in which find ourselves. In faithfulness to Jesus’ call to share the good news of His love for all, I felt it was also important for us to foster and encourage new expressions of Christian community, so that through The Episcopal Church’s particular way of living the Christian experience might help others to know the love of God, as revealed to us in Jesus.
In the beginning, I had ideas and opinions about how to go about that adaptive work, and I’ve made it my lifelong habit to study examples of thriving congregations–both within and outside The Episcopal Church. And we’ve tried, and continue to try a lot of things, in a spirit of experimentation and learning. In some places we’ve experienced fruitfulness from our efforts; in others, we haven’t. As is often the case in life, I’ve learned as much from failure as success, and what hasn’t borne fruit.
One of the most important lessons from failure is humility. Another is persistence.
And still another–the most surprising of all: You never can tell how things will turn out.
You Never Can Tell.
That’s the first working title of this sermon, and surely one of the points Jesus was driving home with the story we just heard about the man who had two sons: one who told his father that yes, of course, he would go into the field and work, but in the end, for whatever reason, decided not to; and the other who said at first, absolutely not, but later had a change of heart and went.
You never can tell.
I’m not the first bishop to come to this realization. Years ago another Episcopal bishop was asked if he had a motto in life–words of wisdom that he lived by. He hadn’t thought about it before he was asked the question, but in that moment, he realized that, in fact, he did have a motto. Can you guess what it was?
You never can tell.
“When I was a parish priest,” he said, “I presided over dozens of weddings. Some of those marriages ended in divorce. But if I had predicted at the wedding which marriage would make it and which wouldn’t, at least 50% of the time, I would have been wrong. For some of the couples that seemed doomed from the start, went on to have long and fruitful marriages, while others whose match seemed made in heaven didn’t last five years.”
You never can tell.
“As bishop, I’ve presided over dozens of ordinations. Some of the priests that I thought the best and the brightest are now in jail, while others that I considered mediocre in their potential have turned out to be among the most fruitful and inspired clergy I’ve known.”
You never can tell.
So I have learned, and am learning still, that I simply cannot predict which congregations are not only going to survive, but find the grace to do good and brave things, and as the Apostle Paul wrote in his gorgeous letter to the Philippians–which, as an aside is one of the most uplifting and encouraging in all the Bible–like Jesus, empty themselves, give of themselves, for the sake of love.
Nor can I predict with complete accuracy who will emerge as leaders, the ones who gain the trust of their community and encourage our people to dream of what could be, and then actually follow through living those dreams into reality.
I’ve given up trying to predict which of the many seeds planted through our collective endeavors will bear fruit. I simply don’t know, and if I were to guess, at least 50 percent of the time, I’d be wrong.
You never can tell.
Now, the second working title of this sermon is, “Is That Your Final Answer?”
You may remember that it was the question that host Regis Philbin would ask contestants on the television game show, Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Contestants would be given more than one chance to answer whatever question was before them.
Moving into more personal territory now, following Jesus’ lead in the story of the two sons, I wonder which son do you most identify with.
Are you the kind of person that is more likely to say yes too soon and then realize that you can’t, or don’t want, to follow through with what you said you would do?
Or are you more likely to first think of all the reasons why you can’t do what is being asked of you, or invited to consider, but then, over time, realize that perhaps you can?
Perhaps it depends on the circumstance for you.
I’m more of a yes-too-soon person. I almost always say yes first, and then realize that I’m over-extended, or I’ve double-booked myself, or I hadn’t taken into account how much work was involved in what was being asked and how others in my life would be affected.
What is that about? There are admirable qualities to being a “Yes I will go” person. I’ve experienced amazing things in my life. People experience me, when I’m in Yes, of course mode, as a supportive and helpful person. But there are vulnerabilities. I wind up saying, “Well, actually, no, I can’t,” more than I care to admit. People then experience me as unreliable. In some instances, I have made promises to people–really big ones–that I could not keep, and the pain of that runs deep. And then I swing too far the other way for a while and say no to everything.
What about those of you who fall on the no-first end of the spectrum? What’s that like for you inside? I live alongside a number of no first people, and while it’s tempting to assume I know the reasons why, I’m not sure that I do. I know that I say no first when I’m depleted, or overwhelmed, when I don’t want to be disappointed, or disappoint others, or as the result of having disappointed or being disappointed in the past.
There are at least two important lessons for us here:
The first is that, like in the game show, our initial response may not be, and need not be our final answer. We can sit with the question, or the invitation, or the possibility for a while before deciding what we can, or cannot do. A good word of counsel for all those inclined to decide quickly about something is to give it a day or two before saying yes or no, and to consult other people who have perspectives and insights that can inform your own.
When I’m in that space of considering and pondering something, especially when I’m thinking I can’t possibly say yes, even though I want to, I’m always amazed when one of my more reliable no-first people say to me, “I really think you should do it,” because it’s out of character for them. At the same time, when they are leaning predictably toward no, when I’m leaning toward yes, or vice-versa, sitting in that space together can be helpful in coming to a decision that feels more settled. In the end, no matter what I decide, the decision feels grounded in deeper reflection, which allows me to live in peace no matter how things turn out.
Because, of course, you never can tell.
One final thought:
In Jesus’ telling of the story, the man who had two sons? Who do you think he represents?
In another story Jesus tells about a man who had two sons, the one we know as the Prodigal Son, the father represents God.
What if, in Jesus’ telling of this story, the same is true?
What if he wants us to consider how we answer when God asks us to do something?
Here a wider lens is helpful, because in all of Scripture, whenever people have the sense that God is asking them to do something, their first answer is almost always no.
-
- How can I go to Pharaoh and tell him to let my people go? Moses protested when God chose him to be the liberator of Israel. I stutter when I speak.
- How can I speak your truth, the young Jeremiah protested when God called him to be a prophet, for I am only a boy?
- How can I go into the King’s inner chamber? Esther protested. Anyone who enters uninvited will be killed.
- Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, Simon Peter said to Jesus when he asked him to follow him.
- Jesus himself, in the Garden of Gethsemane, asks for the cup of death to pass him by.
In the end each one whose first answer was no, found the strength, courage, and grace to say yes, and do what they knew in their bones God was asking them to do. But here’s the thing: none of them could do what was being asked of them on their own. It was God at work in them, accomplishing far more than they could ask for or imagine.
Even their failure–think of Jesus on the cross–was, in God’s hands, the raw material from which life and love would grow.
You never can tell.
Jesus is well aware that when it’s God doing the asking, our first response is almost always no, or a yes when we have no idea what’s being asked of us. Jesus knows that.
He doesn’t really care what our first answer is. He’s waiting for the final one–the one we make with our actions and our lives.
Will you trust me? He asks. Will you trust me and say yes to what feels impossible, and know that I will be with you to see it through?
Let’s pray:
Lord, there is so much we don’t know even when we think we do, and we simply don’t know in advance of anything we do how things will turn out. Give us the grace to celebrate the often unforeseen goodness of our endeavors. Help us take failures, not as a sign of our worth, but as opportunities to learn and grow and try again, and not to judge ourselves and one another too quickly. For we never can tell, really, what you are up to in our midst.
There are times, Lord, when we have to make decisions about what to do, where to go, how to spend our time and energies and resources. Give us your wisdom. Help us to hear your voice amid the many voices in our heads, so that we can say either yes or no with greater confidence. Lord, whenever you sense the invitation, the call, the request is from you, listen to our concerns and our fears, and then give the will to say yes, and the power to follow where your lead.
In Jesus’ name, we pray. Amen.
