Thoughts on Reparations from a White Southerner

by | Nov 21, 2024

Several years ago I concluded that our nation must take on the very difficult work of coming to terms with slavery and the subsequent century of Jim Crow segregation. Growing up in North Carolina in the 1950s and 1960s, I experienced the results from this horrible legacy. My small hometown was completely segregated, including the schools that I attended. As a child I was able to see visibly the poor quality of the housing for the Black members of my community, and the low-paying jobs that Black people were forced to take, due to racial discrimination. While I was never explicitly taught in school, in church, or at home that segregation was wrong, I was taught a lesson of kindness and treating others as we would want them to treat us. This pattern of ethical thinking eventually translated for me when I was a college student into concluding that segregation and all racial discrimination was wrong and must end. This decision led to my working for the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) in the deep South during the civil rights movement. I absorbed the fervor of that era, and to this day singing the movement songs brings me to tears.

I grew up knowing that my ancestors had lived in the South beginning in the 18th century and that some of them served in the Civil War on the side of the Confederacy. More recently, I learned that I have Black cousins (through a fourth great-grandfather who fathered a child with the woman he enslaved). Around the same time, I became aware of the reparations process in Germany for those who suffered under the Nazi government. These types of awareness, repentance, and reparations seemed to me to be very necessary in the United States, so that our nation can experience healing from the devastating consequences of slavery and Jim Crow policies. Ultimately this may help us face the future as a more compassionate and less divided nation. While money is not always the solution to every problem, when harm can be traced, a transfer of financial assets from those who benefited (even if generations later) to those who suffered from those policies seems essential to me. On a small scale, I have contributed to the college fund for the daughter of my distant relative, as a form of personal reparations within my family.

Though it may come far in the future, ideally at some point we will create a national-level reparations policy. Until such time, we can demonstrate how such policies can be developed and implemented at a local level. If we can do this within the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, and disseminate our results widely, we can help to build momentum for similar work by other faith communities, other political jurisdictions, and—God willing—ultimately for reparations at the national level.

Embry Howell
Senior Warden, All Souls Episcopal Church
Member, Committee on Diocesan Reparations