We Can Be Brave: On Moral Courage in a Time in Need of Grace

by | May 3, 2025

We speak of what we know and we testify to what we have seen.
John 3:11

As Christians, our greatest contribution to the world is, by God’s grace, to be who we are.
Robert Bellah, American Sociologist of Religion

Thank you, dear friends in Christ, for your warm welcome and the invitation to join you in this extraordinary gathering of Christians. I am honored to be among you.

I come in a spirit of friendship, bringing greetings from many in the United States who are your friends, and indeed, your relatives.

Like many Americans, I am of European heritage. My mother, Ann Björkman, immigrated from Sweden as a young woman. All my relatives on my mother’s side live in Sweden and Northern Europe. My father was born to a young, working class Irish woman who gave him up for adoption, and he was raised by a family of English and Scottish descent—the Belknaps and the Edgars. My husband’s family on his father’s side comes from Germany and immigrated to the US in the mid-19th century (hence, our surname, Budde) His mother’s family, the Mahoneys, fled Ireland during the Great Famine.

We are family.

I am among the countless Americans grateful for the family ties, shared values, and alliance between Europe and the United States. Those ties have been tested in the past, and we are well aware that on the level of public policy, they are sorely tested now because of a dramatic realignment of political power in the United States, and a corresponding shift in values and alliances. I am here, in part, to assure you that not all Americans are in support of that shift. Many of us are heartbroken by what is being said and done around the world in our name.

In the United States we are also dealing with the trauma of what is happening within our country. Thousands of civil servants have lost their jobs. Entire agencies of government are being dismantled. An aggressive deportation strategy for migrants is underway, and nearly all options for people to legally immigrate have been closed. We are witnessing a disregard for the rule of law from those elected and appointed to uphold the law. And the president has just proposed a federal budget that would drastically reduce government investment where we need it most—in education, health care, housing and medical research.

Many of these changes, at least in theory, were supported by the majority of Americans who voted in last year’s elections. The majority not only voted for President Trump but also gave his party control over every branch of the federal government.

Thus I ask for your prayers as Christians in the United States, and all people of faith and goodwill, discern how we are to live with moral courage in a time sorely in need of grace. I assure you of our prayers for you.

One of the greatest challenges in the United States today is what I would describe to you as a culture of contempt that has normalized hateful speech and encourages violence. The culture of contempt distorts truth and hinders our ability to have meaningful conversations across our very real differences. We are deeply divided, and the intensity of this polarization, and the culture of contempt that sustains it, threatens to destroy us. It is actively promoted by those within and outside the United States who benefit financially and politically from our divisions.

The Christian witness in the United States is also divided, for we are a part of the country in which we dwell. We are well-represented across the spectrum of political loyalties and societal polarities. We are influenced by the same pressures as everyone else, and we commit many of the same sins.

Thus it is essential for Christians leaders to speak and act with humility in the wider society in which we live, for we are in need of the same forgiveness, mercy, and grace that we are called by God to embody for others.

So in a time in need of God’s grace, and of courage on the part of its people, we must first ask ourselves: where do we turn, as people of faith, when we feel discouraged, disoriented, and overwhelmed? What is the source of our strength and the light illuminates our path? What, in other words, is our north star?
The astronomical north star is a fixed point in the night sky. Our forebears relied on it for navigation because it remains steady in the northern hemisphere, marking true north. Its constancy is what makes it a tool for guidance. Metaphorically, our north star is whatever helps guide us when we aren’t sure what lies ahead. It symbolizes whatever gives us a sense of direction and purpose that keeps us moving forward in disorienting times.

For those of us who are Christians, the life and teachings of Jesus are our north star. In private and public life, we are to follow him.

And Jesus’ north star was the prophetic tradition of ancient Israel.

In one version of how Jesus’ public ministry began, as told in the Gospel of Luke, he felt the Holy Spirit descend upon him as a dove when he rose from the waters of his baptism by John. That same spirit led him through a time of trial and temptation in the wilderness. Afterwards, he returned to his hometown of Nazareth, and in the synagogue community that raised him, he declared himself the fulfillment of words written centuries before by the prophet Isaiah:

The spirit of the Lord God is upon me, because the Lord has anointed me; he has sent me to bring good news to the oppressed, to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and release to the prisoners; to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor. (Isaiah 61:1-2)

Jesus understood his purpose in light of the prophet’s highest communal visions of equity and justice. To borrow a phrase from Roman Catholic social teaching, from the beginning, Jesus had “a preferential option for the poor.”

As the late Christian author Rachel Held Evans would often say, “Jesus didn’t come only to die for us. He came to live for us.” He came to show us how to live and how to love.

Thus, in our tumultuous time, I believe that our greatest contribution as Christians, is to speak of what we know and testify to what we have seen. More importantly, we are to live as best we can according to the highest aspirations of humankind revealed to us in Jesus:

to recognize the inherent, God-given dignity of every human being

to love our neighbors as ourselves, and even to love our enemies

to share what we have and to strive for a equitable and just society

to refrain from evil and refuse to hate

to be mindful of the power of our words, and to speak without malice or contempt

to forgive, as we have been forgiven

to live in hope

to be willing to sacrifice, even our very lives, for the sake of love.

That is our calling as Christians, one that we can never fulfill on our own power, but only through the love and mercy of Christ that lives in us.

As the Apostle Paul wrote (and this is a guiding text for my life):

For we do not proclaim ourselves; we proclaim Jesus Christ as Lord and ourselves as your slaves for Jesus’ sake. For it is the God who said, ‘Let light shine out of darkness’, who has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. But we have this treasure in clay jars, so that it may be made clear that this extraordinary power belongs to God and does not come from us. (2 Corinthians 4:1;4-7)

In the United States, the Christian witness is complicated by an ascendant, politically powerful movement known as Christian nationalism. It is the most serious threat to the witness of the church today.

While the term “Christian nationalism” is relatively new, this is not a new phenomenon. It has its roots in the mythology of our founding as a nation: that we were founded as a Christian nation, on Christian principles, built by white men. It perpetuates the idea that as a country we have unique favor with God as evidenced by our prosperity. Its ideology is racist—specifically, that of white supremacy—and dismissive about the capacity of women in leadership or public life.

The current strain of Christian nationalism encourages its adherents to see themselves as under constant attack by the evils of secular society, and that the government must protect the primacy of Christianity as they understand it. But it is an expression of Christianity that bears little resemblance to Christ. Christian nationalism is firmly aligned with the goals of the current administration and it is one of the many influences moving our country toward authoritarianism.

But if the response to the sermon I preached on January 21st has revealed anything, it is that simply professing a faith rooted in mercy, dignity, honesty and humility is like water in the desert for parched souls.

The gratitude from Christians and non-Christians alike has evoked in me a sense of responsibility to promote and amplify a Christian worldview that seeks to promote the highest of human aspirations, what Jesus called the kingdom of heaven and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. called the Beloved Community. It has given me hope that we, as Christians, have a vital contribution to make as bearers of hope, possibility and truth-telling.

Though I am a Christian to the core, I reject the Christian nationalist vision that Christians are called to dominate the society in which we live. When Christians engage in civic discourse and public life, it must be in the service of all people, and in respect and with deep appreciation for the many ways the sacred mystery we call God has been revealed and experienced across time and culture.

The variety of humankind, and all of creation, suggests that God loves diversity. There is nothing more powerful than practitioners of different faiths finding common cause for the good of all: think of Martin Luther King, Jr. inspired by Ghandi; the friendship between the Archbishop Demond Tutu and the Dalai Lama; the interfaith alliances across this country and around the globe all suggest to us that we can indeed live together in solidarity and together work for the good of all God’s children. We can and we must.

I also believe that we are called to do our part to stop those who are determined to dismantle the institutions, destroy the guardrails of our democracy, and accelerate the very trends we need to reverse for the human species to survive.

The question I have been most frequently asked in my time in Europe is why has the American populace been silent and seemingly accepting of the Trump Administration’s actions. Why aren’t we all in the streets? Why aren’t we speaking up? Why aren’t we doing more?

I cannot answer that question definitively. I’m not sure that I understand myself. It is true that there is as yet no cohesive societal movement in response to the changes in our country, which is not to say that no one is resisting or pushing back, but efforts are small in comparison to the onslaught of damage.

Let me simply say that for me, personally, it is still hard to accept what is happening in our country. We are up against a lot, and what we need is a broad coalition united by a common vision large enough to hold all of us. We cannot go back to who we were before, because where we were before led us to where we are now.

We need a new vision, new ways of weaving our country together.

Wherever I go, people tell me that what they need most of all now is hope, hope that we can, indeed, stop the damage being done and work toward a vision of society in which all of us, in our God-given diversity, can thrive. They long, as I do, for a different conversation marked by dignity, the coming together of people from different viewpoints and life experiences to solve the problems we collectively face. I am committed to creating space for such conversations, where we truly listen to one another, rather than speak about one another in derision and contempt.

We can be the hope bearers. Our faith is one of hope, never denying the power of evil and death, and yet, affirming that the life-affirming spirit of God is always at work to bring about good. Seeds of new possibilities, invisible to us now, have already been planted in the soil of our lives, and they are slowly taking root. New life will emerge from the ashes of what is lost.

Will the clergy persons in the room please raise your hands? Like you, I am in a pulpit nearly every Sunday attempting to offer a word of hope. Like you, in preparation I study our sacred texts, ponder the world and our place in it, and consider the particular community to which I will speak.

At the heart of this practice of spiritual leadership is this basic question. What does God have to say to us now?

Our texts and traditions speak with many voices and perspectives. But the strongest, clearest, most consistent message from those sent by God or who speak on God’s behalf is this: Fear not, for I am with you.

It isn’t a promise of rescue, though there are stories of rescue and I long for one now. It has the hint of chastisement, but we needn’t hear it as such, but rather as a reminder that we can turn to God in our fear, and seek the reassurance and grace of God’s presence.

When we long for more, it’s hard to imagine how God’s mere presence could possibly be enough. Until it’s all we have and by grace, it is enough.

What else does God have to say to us?

The Christian faith is founded on one simple premise: that all human beings are God’s beloved. The words that Jesus heard at his baptism, “You are the Beloved, with you I am well pleased.” are for all of us.

When the Apostle Paul wrote that nothing can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus, he meant it. That doesn’t mean we always act in loving ways. When we don’t treat others, or ourselves for that matter, as the beloved of God, that doesn’t change God’s love for us.

Lastly, our sacred texts are filled with stories of ordinary people called to do extraordinary things for which they are not equipped and prepared. What I hear in those stories and in my own prayer life is this: Offer what you have.

What we have to offer is ourselves. Think of Jesus’ disciples with nothing but a few loaves and some fish with which to feed a multitude. Their offering isn’t nearly enough to meet the need, but Jesus asks for their offering anyway, and through it, provides food enough for all, with some to spare.

These are some of the words I hold onto when I am in need of grace, in a time when courage is called for, and I offer them to you:

Be not afraid.
You are God’s beloved.
Offer what you have.

I also believe that in a time of needed grace, when courage is required of us, that there is something we need to say to God.

What do you say to God in your times of prayer? I say all sorts of things—I can’t help it. I pray for help. For forgiveness. For guidance, for myself and those I love, and for our world.

Then there often follows a moment when I feel the need to say something else to God—that I am here, willing to stay present and engaged, even when times are hard.

There is a story from the Gospel of John that tells of a time, when Jesus was at prayer near the end of his life. This is not the more familiar story of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane found in the other three gospels, when he prays that, if possible, the cup of suffering pass him by. In this account, Jesus is in Bethany, a small village outside of Jerusalem, where he is preparing for his final entry into Jerusalem.

This is his prayer:

Now my soul is troubled. And what shall I say? Father, spare me from this hour? No, it is for this reason that I have come to his hour. Father, glorify your name.” (John 12:27-28)

When we pray with that kind of resolve, we are, in essence, saying to God,

“We are here. It is for this hour we have come. No matter what happens, we are here. And we will do our best to embody your spirit in whatever way is needed.”

Now we aren’t asking God to change what cannot be changed. Rather we are reassuring God, and one another, that we are not going anywhere no matter what.

We are here. This is our time to be God’s people on this earth. With God’s grace and strength, we will rise to this moment.

I believe in the innate human capacity to take enormous evolutionary leaps for the good. Our forebears have done the seemingly impossible in the past, and we can do it now. It is to that potential that God calls us.

One final thought on what we will say to God and to ourselves in this moment. From our promises at baptism: We will respect the dignity of every human being

In a culture of contempt, we will speak with dignity. In a world of mean-spiritedness, we will act with kindness and love. At a time when it is tempting to be cynical and despairing, we will live in hope.

This is a time for us as Christians to be present in as many places as we can and offer what we have to give. It is a time for us to invest in the things we believe in; to find, if not common cause with those with whom we differ, at least shared ground with anyone working toward the common goals for different reasons. As followers of Jesus, we are to speak up for the inherent belovedness and dignity of others.

To do this we need to be grounded daily in our own belovedness, drawing from the wells of God’s love for us, and to pray daily for wisdom, strength, and grace. For there is a lot at stake and the success of our efforts is not certain.

But for Christians, hopelessness is not an option—not because of us, but because of Christ’s dwelling in us and our ultimate hope in our true home in the love of God. We have our north star. In that faith, we go on. We are the ones now. For this hour, we are here.

Go forth, dear friends in Christ, and by God’s grace, be who you are.