Upholding Human Dignity in a Culture of Contempt: An Evening with Tim Shriver

by | May 14, 2025

Will you strive for justice and peace among all people and respect the dignity of every human being?
The Baptismal Covenant

On Thursday evening, May 22nd, I invite you to join me, either in person at Washington National Cathedral or online, for a conversation with Tim Shriver on The Role of Human Dignity in Public Life. The event is free and open to all, though registration is required.

Tim Shriver is Chairman of Special Olympics International, author of The Call to Unite: Voices of Hope and Awakening, and co-founder of Project UNITE, whose mission is to promote human dignity as a positive alternative to the culture of contempt so pervasive in both our private and public lives.

On May 22nd, Tim will introduce UNITE’s signature offering, The Dignity Index, as a tool for respectful engagement across differences, and we then will talk about its implications in our current political climate.

The Dignity Index is an eight-point scale to assess the way we speak of those with whom we truly differ, or fear, or whose behaviour we find egregious. Low scores are for expressions of contempt (1-4) while higher scores (5-8) reflect language grounded in dignity. The dividing line between contempt and dignity is somewhere between levels four and five in the Dignity Index scale.

A level four statement of any kind mocks and attacks the other side’s background, their beliefs, their commitment, or their competence. At level four, our assumption is that We’re better than those people. They don’t really belong. They’re not one of us.

In contrast, at level five, we listen to the other side’s point of view and respectfully explain our own views, with the conviction that those on the other side have a right to be here and a right to be heard. They belong here too.

Going down from level four to level three, is language that attacks the other side’s moral character, not just their capabilities or competence. Level three’s guiding assumption is We’re the good people and they’re the bad people. It’s us versus them.

Going down to level two, we now accuse those with whom we differ not just of doing bad or being bad, but promoting evil. Those people are evil and they’re going to ruin everything if we let them. It’s us or them. Finally at level one, we arrive at justifications for genocide, as violent words to escalate violent actions. They’re not even human. It’s our moral duty to destroy them before they destroy us.

Moving up the dignity scale from level five, in which we listen to others’ point of view and respectfully explain our own convictions is level six, when our speech and actions reflect our welcome duty to work with those whom we differ with to find common ground and act on it. We always talk to the other side, searching for the values and interests we share.

Level seven goes further still, for now we want to fully engage those with whom we differ, willing to discuss our deepest disagreements to see what breakthroughs we can find. We’re willing to go there, engaging even those with values and interests we don’t share, and being open to admitting mistakes and even changing our minds.

Finally, at level eight, we can see ourselves in every human being; we refuse to hate anyone. For we are fully persuaded that each one of us is born with inherent worth, so we treat everyone with dignity—no matter what.

We can’t deny that human dignity is continually trampled on in our political and wider social spheres. Contempt dominates our public discourse, and it creeps into our personal lives as well. How are we to engage without falling prey to the very behaviour we dislike in others? And how can we resist the equally strong temptation to say or do nothing in a volatile context?

The Dignity Index is one tool to help guide our efforts.

I first came across Tim Shriver’s work last year in the tense, highly polarized environment leading up to the national elections. It remains one of the most useful tools to help me regulate my own actions and speech. It hasn’t changed my convictions, but it informs the way I engage with others, and it helps hold me accountable to our baptismal promises.

Indeed, one of the fascinating outcomes of engagement with the Dignity Index is known as “the Mirror Effect.” At first we are tempted to use the Index as a tool for judging others, but it quickly becomes a mirror for seeing ourselves and evaluating our own speech.

It also provides agency for change. Spending time with the Index, we realize how pervasive contempt has become, that we all contribute to it, and thus we can take steps to change our behavior and modify our speech toward dignity.

If you’d like to learn more, I hope you’ll join me in welcoming Tim Shriver on May 22nd.

One hopeful assertion Tim makes is that when given a vision of dignity over contempt, we naturally are drawn to it. Moreover, when we are given tools to promote dignity over contempt, we rise to the challenge of using them. “While it’s hard to see contempt when we use it,” he says, “it’s hard to use contempt when we see it.”