Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.
Romans 12:21
In a week of sobering news, I was grateful to find inspiration in the moral courage of others. Courage is contagious, which is something to remember whenever we’re feeling discouraged. Scripture reminds us that we are all surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses whose examples help us to persevere in hope.
I write this reflection after spending a day at Virginia Theological Seminary celebrating the life of Bishop John T. Walker, whose gentle strength and moral clarity continue to inspire many, nearly three decades after his untimely death. In tears and laughter, people shared what it was like to be in his presence.
Particularly moving to me was a story Bishop Nathan Baxter told of how, in 1985, a voting block of retired bishops prevented Bishop Walker from being elected the first Black Presiding Bishop. The anger and frustration of his supporters was volatile. Bishop Walker quietly told them that while he, too, was disappointed, he still had important work to do, and so did they. “Don’t let disappointment keep you from doing what God has called you to do.”
In another example of moral courage this week, Cardinal Robert McElroy of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Washington preached a powerful sermon on Sunday in defense of immigrants:
Catholic social teaching states that every nation has the right to effectively control its own borders and provide security. Thus, efforts to secure our borders and deport those undocumented immigrants convicted of serious crimes constitute legitimate national goals. At times, our government asserts that these goals constitute the essence and scope of its immigration enforcement efforts, and if that were true Catholic teaching would raise no objection.
But the reality we are facing here in the Archdiocese of Washington and across our country is far different. For our government is engaged in — by its own admission and by the tumultuous enforcement actions it has launched – a comprehensive campaign to uproot millions of families and hard-working men and women who have come to our country seeking a better life that includes contributing to building up the best elements of our culture and society. This campaign relies on fear and terror at its core, for the government knows that it cannot succeed in its efforts except by bringing new dimensions of fear and terror to our nation’s history and life.
As a Church we must console and peacefully stand in solidarity with the undocumented men and women whose lives are being upended by the government’s campaign of fear and terror. Courage and sacrifice must be the hallmark of our actions at this moment of historic and deliberate suffering being visited upon people living truly good lives that are a credit to our nation. As citizens, we must not be silent as this profound injustice is carried out in our name.
I commend his sermon in its entirety to you.
Lastly, this week I came across an article highlighting an event at Utah Valley University, where Charlie Kirk was assassinated two weeks ago. On September 26, Harvard professor and author Arthur Brooks addressed a crowd of over 5000 people. He began by audaciously suggesting that those gathered, in their grief, were “called to respond to Kirk’s murder by following the most countercultural teaching in the history of human history: to love our enemies.” 1
Brooks wasn’t suggesting that Kirk’s assassin be spared punishment for his crime. But he was asking his audience, and all of us, to lay aside assumptions about other Americans whose worldviews we dislike or distrust. Specifically, Brooks warned against what sociologists refer to as “motive attribution asymmetry,” which is what occurs when people on both sides of a polarized issue believe, incorrectly, that they are motivated solely by love and their opponents solely by hate.
Again, I commend the full text of Brooks’ speech. It draws heavily from a book Brooks wrote in 2019, Love Your Enemies: How Decent People Can Save America from the Culture of Contempt, which is also worth reading.
Brooks believes that for our country to heal, we need to have moral courage, which he defines not as standing up to the people with whom we disagree, but rather standing up to the people with whom you agree, on behalf of those with whom you disagree. This isn’t about our differences, political or otherwise, but rather the refusal to see whole portions of our society through the lens of hatred, and to speak up when politicians or pundits we happen to agree with degrade or dehumanize those of opposing views.
In his Utah speech, Brooks recounts when he was to give an economic policy speech at a gathering at which several politicians were also scheduled to speak. Their positions were ones that Brooks shared, but the way the politicians presented denigrated those with opposing views, troubled him. Predictably, they complimented the audience for their patriotism and then spoke of the opposition as evil and filled with hate. Brooks spoke last, and after giving his prepared remarks, he said:
My friends, you have been hearing from the previous speakers that your opponents don’t love America. But I want you to remember something. Those opponents are neighbors of yours. They are relatives of yours. They’re not stupid or evil. They’re simply Americans who don’t agree with you on politics. Nobody has ever been persuaded with insults. Nobody has ever been hated into agreement. But you have one tool that will work: love.
This is a powerful expression of what followers of Jesus recognize as true to his teachings. But what are we to do when we are confronted with hatred? Or when we ourselves don’t have the capacity to love those who have harmed us or those we love?
Brooks tells of a time when he asked the Dalai Lama, the spiritual leader of Tibetan Buddhism, what to do when all he felt was contempt, and he didn’t know how to love his enemies. The Dalai Lama is well practiced in loving his enemies: he prays daily for the well-being of the Chinese Communists who expelled him from his homeland in 1959. “It doesn’t matter how you feel,” he told Brooks. “Show warmheartedness.”
By quoting Brooks at length, I am not advocating for anything other than robust engagement with the issues of our day, which are matters of life and death for many, and that we be clear about where we stand. We do no one any service by stepping back from one another for fear of causing offense.
Yet how we engage matters. With God’s help and the inspiration we draw from one another, we can be clear and kind at the same time.
May you be of good courage and hold fast to that which is good.
Courage is contagious, and so is love.
1https://www.thefp.com/p/arthur-brooks-how-to-heal-our-country-charlie-kirk-utah-valley-university
