by Bishop Mariann | Apr 21, 2024
The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want. He makes me lie down in green pastures; he leads me beside still waters;*He restores my soul.* He leads me in right paths* for his name’s sake…
Psalm 23
We know love by this, that he laid down his life for us—and we ought to lay down our lives for one another.
1 John 3:16
I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep. The hired hand, who is not the shepherd and does not own the sheep, sees the wolf coming and leaves the sheep and runs away—and the wolf snatches them and scatters them. The hired hand runs away because the hired hand does not care for the sheep. I am the good shepherd. I know my own and my own know me, just as the Father knows me and I know the Father. And I lay down my life for the sheep. I have other sheep that do not belong to this fold. I must bring them also, and they will listen to my voice. So there will be one flock, one shepherd. For this reason the Father loves me, because I lay down my life in order to take it up again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have power to lay it down, and I have power to take it up again. I have received this command from my Father.
John 10:11-18
I’d like to speak to you this morning about one of the most transformative and life- affirming experiences that we can have as human beings, and that is the experience of being seen, for who we are, in all our vulnerabilities and strengths, and not only seen, but accepted and loved.
Years ago a member of a parish I once served wrote a book about his work as a psychotherapist, and in particular, on those breakthrough moments in the therapeutic process when someone experiences healing and release from past trauma. He asked his patients to identify what it was like for them when those breakthrough moments occurred. To a person they told him there wasn’t one moment they could point to, but rather the cumulative healing power of many small moments, building at last to a kind internal crescendo—sometimes quite powerful and dramatic, and but more often in a kind of calm awareness that life was different, a bit like waking up one morning and realizing that a pain you’ve lived with forever is gone.
They also told him that what all those small, cumulative moments had in common was that they occurred within the therapeutic experience of being seen by another person in all their pain and inner contradictions, and not seen, but fully accepted and prized for who they were.
This is a kind of vision that plumbs greater depths than what our eyes can see on the surface, and how we present ourselves to one another in daily life. There’s a story in one of the early books of the Old Testament, or the Jewish Bible, in which a prophet named Samuel is sent by God to find the one God has chosen to be the next king of Israel. God sends Samuel to a man named Jesse who has seven sons. One of the seven, God told him, was to be Israel’s next king, but which one? When considering each of the seven sons, God told Samuel not to pay attention to physical attributes, “for the Lord does not see as mortals see; they look on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart.’ (I Samuel 16:7)
Heart vision, as we might call it, is a spiritual grace; it is a gift given us by the One who sees to the depths of who we are.
Let’s pause for a moment and contemplate together the astonishing assertion that God sees each one of us to the core, not discounting our outer attributes and outwardly focused personas (for they, too, are a part of us), but going to the deeper to the parts of our being that can be a mystery even to ourselves.
Think of the prayer we prayed as we began worship: O God, to whom all our hearts are open, all our desires are known, and from whom no secrets are hidden.
Each of the Scripture passages we’ve heard this morning speaks to us of God’s love, particularly Psalm 23, perhaps the most well known and beloved passages in the Bible.
There’s another psalm that speaks the way God sees and knows us. I invite you to close your eyes and listen to these words from Psalm 139:
O Lord, you have searched me and known me.
You know my sitting down and my rising up;
you discern my thoughts from afar
You trace my journeys and my resting places,
and are acquainted with all my ways.
Even there is not a word on my lips,
But you, O Lord, know it altogether.
You press upon me, behind and before,
and lay your hand upon me.
Such knowledge is too wonderful for me;
it is so high that I cannot attain it.
Where can I go then from your spirit?
Where can I flee from your presence?
If I climb up to heaven, you are there;
if I make the grave my bed, you are there also.
If I take the wings of the morning
and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea,
even there your hand shall lead me,
and your right hand shall hold me fast.
If I say, ‘Surely the darkness shall cover me,
and the light around me become night’,
even the darkness is not dark to you;
the night is as bright as the day,
for darkness is as light to you.
(Ps. 139-1-11)
What does contemplating God seeing you so deeply evoke in you?
In the Bible there are numerous examples of people responding to the realization that God sees them at the core with strong feelings of unworthiness and shame. The prophet Isaiah’s response, for example, was a lament: “Woe is me. For I am a man of unclean lips and I come from a people of unclean lips.” (Isaiah 6:5) Similarly, when the fisherman known as Simon Peter first sensed that Jesus could see right through to his heart, he said, “Depart from me, Lord. For I am a sinful man.” (Luke 5:8)
In both instances, and countless others like them, God’s response, Jesus’ response, is in essence, “Yeah, I know all that. I know everything that you imagine makes you unworthy of my love. And I still love you. There isn’t anything you can do or say or fail to do or say that will keep me from loving you. I need you to receive that love and then to join me in seeing and loving others in the same way.”
I need you to receive that love and then to join me in seeing and loving others in the same way.
So here is my first invitation, and gentle exhortation, as your bishop: Between now and next Sunday, spend a few moments in silence—sitting in a chair, lying in bed before you get up or as you are falling asleep, walking through the neighborhood or driving in your car—and picture in your mind God gazing upon you with eyes of love.
It’s not as easy as it sounds, or at least, it isn’t for me. Whenever I sit down and try to focus attention on the image of God’s gaze of love upon me, my mind goes everywhere else—it’s what the Buddhists call “our monkey brains,” and the Christian mystic Martin Laird describes “our interior soap opera, the constant chatter of the cocktail party going on in our heads.”1 There’s nothing to be done about that inner noise except to take note of it, take a breath, and refocus again on God gazing on us. It helps me to read the words of Psalm 139, or contemplate the image of Jesus as the Good Shepherd who calls me by name. The goal isn’t so much to silence those voices as it is to calm them down and allow ourselves to receive something of love of God made known to us in Jesus.
It takes time and practice to experience God’s love. Because we are human, the best and more reliable conduit of God’s love is that of another person who has the grace and capacity to love us for who we are, as we are.
Those who know themselves to be seen, accepted, and prized by God often have extraordinary healing power. You can feel it being in their presence, for they have been graced with greater capacity to see as God sees and love as God loves—not perfectly, but sufficiently to be a channel of God’s grace. I suspect that we’ve all been gifted with moments of heart vision and love—it’s a wonderful feeling, to see someone, if fleetingly, as God sees and to love with God’s love.
There’s a direct correlation between receiving unconditional love and acceptance and our capacity to offer such acceptance and love for others. We aren’t Jesus, and on this side of heaven we’ll never fully know the breadth of such love on either the giving and the receiving end, but we can catch glimpses of it, and we can get better at such love with intention and practice. To be sure, some people seem naturally gifted in their capacity to love, but most of us learn to love by trial and error, and as a direct result of being loved ourselves.
This spring I’ve been part of a small group of people across the diocese going through a ten-week introductory course to the Christian life and faith known as Being With. (It’s part of our diocesan effort to explore and cultivate helpful resources for congregations.) The foundational premise of the course is that God’s deepest desire, as revealed to us in Jesus, is to be with us. In his life among us, Jesus showed us the true character of God, more truthfully than we’d ever seen it before or have seen it since. He comes among us still in relationship, in which we are seen and known at the depths of our being, and in fact, has been with us since our lives began.
In our session last week, we focused on Jesus’ ministry when he walked the earth, focusing on three distinct aspects; first, how Jesus formed a new community of friendship and accountability among those who became his disciples; second, how he chose to be in relationship with those marginalized, traumatized, and oppressed in his society; and third, how he called to account in a more confrontational way the authorities of his day. I was one presenting the material for the course last week, and there’s a line I read to the group that has stayed with me ever since: “The relationship that brings about real change is friendship because to be a friend is to say, ‘I am allowing myself to be changed by knowing you.’”2
In that spirit, my second invitation, or gentle exhortation, to you this morning is to consider the people on the margins of your life that you might engage with in a spirit of friendship—not to fix them, offer them charity, or do things for them, but rather to be with them, willing to see and be seen by them, and be changed yourself by virtue of knowing them.
As your rector knows, I have felt drawn to be in relationship with the mostly Black clergy of the neighborhoods in Washington most affected by the epidemic of gun violence and youth crime. Many are native Washingtonians, some who have been ministering in the city for decades, others who are younger and went away for their education, but then chose to return, to live and work in neighborhoods that they had every reason to leave. The last thing these ministers need or want is a white woman from the other side of town showing up to “help” them. But they graciously accept me whenever I join them in a spirit of friendship. I was with them last night in a prayer service, where they brought to God their grief (you may recall that three teenagers were killed just last week), and resolved to work together this summer to provide refuge and healing in their communities. I am willing to be changed by knowing them, and being their friend in Christ. Perhaps together we can be part of the solutions our city desperately needs.
Where might you be called to friendship? And how might you be changed as a result of learning to see as God sees and love as God loves? Start with yourself. Spend time each day remembering that Jesus knows you by name and loves you. Then—as best you can—strive to see with the vision of your heart, and love others in the spirit of friendship.
1Martin Laird, Into the Silent Land: A Guide to the Christian Practice of Contemplation, (Oxford University Press, 2006) Kindle ed. 15.
2Being With Leaders’ Guide: A Course Exploring Christian Faith and Life
by Bishop Mariann | Apr 18, 2024
Thus it is written, that the Messiah is to suffer and to rise from the dead on the third day, and that repentance and forgiveness of sins is to be proclaimed in his name to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem. You are witnesses of these things.
Luke 24:46-47
This Easter season I’ve been thinking about forgiveness, and in particular, how to understand the notion that through Jesus’ death and resurrection we receive forgiveness for our sins.
Between human beings, forgiveness can be a complex, elusive, and fraught experience. We rightfully ask, who has the authority to forgive another person? Are there times when forgiveness isn’t possible, or is granted too soon? What if we can’t forgive, or others refuse to forgive us? What about the need for restitution and amendment of life?
Considering what forgiveness means in relationship with God, we also face perplexing questions. When do we offend or fail God? For what do we need forgiveness? How does Jesus’ death atone for our sins? And what does that mean? Throughout the centuries, this has been a topic of wide-ranging theological interpretation and debate.
This we know from the biblical accounts: In his lifetime, Jesus of Nazareth spoke and taught about forgiveness a lot—it is the defining characteristic of his ministry. He emphasized our need to offer and receive forgiveness from one another, and to trust in the merciful forgiveness of God. He embodied forgiveness to such a degree that people felt its liberating power in his presence. Even as he was dying on the cross, he prayed for God to forgive his murderers. After his resurrection, Jesus specifically sought out Simon Peter, who publicly denied knowing him after his arrest, to assure Simon Peter that he was forgiven for what he had done.
Perhaps another time I’ll write about what in theological language is known as “atonement theory,” the ways Jesus’ death and resurrection have been understood to reconcile us to God. For now, I’ll simply say that on a personal level I understand why forgiveness is central to the Christian faith. For while my identity as a follower of Jesus rests on multiple pillars, the most impactful spiritual experiences of my life have been when I was forgiven for things I had done or failed to do, when I felt loved unconditionally for who I am, despite the ways I fail, get things wrong, and consciously or unconsciously participate in the evils of this world.
One such experience stands out in my memory: It doesn’t involve the worst things done, but the forgiveness I received still informs my understanding of the liberating power of what Jesus offers us all.
As a young adult, I was part of a Christian community that I loved. The people were thoughtful, plucky, and deeply engaged in struggles for justice. I was so inspired by the church’s leadership that I overcommitted myself, making promises that I couldn’t keep (a tendency that plagues me still). While these were not heinous sins, they were significant promises, and I let people down whom I cared about and admired.
In my embarrassment and guilt, I stopped going to church. I never said goodbye; I simply drifted away.
Months later, as I was preparing to move to another city, I realized that I needed to come clean with the church I had failed. Mustering my courage, I made an appointment with the senior pastor to apologize. I rehearsed everything I was going to say, and as soon as I sat down, I acknowledged all that I had done and failed to do.
I don’t remember exactly what she said to me in response. She didn’t minimize my failure or patronize me with assurances that my behavior was no big deal. But I felt heard in her presence, and seen for who I was. We spoke of ways I might make amends to the people I had hurt, and she gently exhorted me to be mindful of the ways that good intentions can cause harm. While she was the one offering me forgiveness, there was a palpable feeling of holiness in the air. Jesus was in the room.
I left her office walking on clouds. I thought to myself, “So this is what forgiveness feels like.” I vowed that day to become the kind of person able to offer such forgiveness to others whenever I could.
There is more to the Christian faith than forgiveness for our sins. But when we need forgiveness, there is no one better than Jesus to set us free. His forgiveness works through us now. If we choose, we can participate in the miracle of forgiveness, daring to receive it for ourselves and sharing it with others. The better we get at forgiveness, the more credible and life-affirming our Christian witness will be.
I wonder if you know what it’s like to be set free.
I wonder if you know what it’s like to help Jesus set someone else free through the power of forgiveness.
For me, it’s like walking on clouds.
by Bishop Mariann | Apr 14, 2024
While the disciples were telling how they had seen Jesus risen from the dead, Jesus himself stood among them and said to them, “Peace be with you.” They were startled and terrified, and thought that they were seeing a ghost. He said to them, “Why are you frightened, and why do doubts arise in your hearts? Look at my hands and my feet; see that it is I myself. Touch me and see; for a ghost does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.” And when he had said this, he showed him his hands and his feet. While in their joy they were disbelieving and wondering, he said to them, “Have you anything here to eat?” They gave him a piece of broiled fish, and he took it and ate it in their presence. Then he said to them, “These are my words that I spoke to you while I was still with you—that everything written about me in the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms must be fulfilled.” Then he opened their minds to understand the scriptures, and he said to them, “Thus it is written, that the Messiah is to suffer and to rise from the dead on the third day, and that repentance and forgiveness of sins is to be proclaimed in his name to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem. You are witnesses of these things.
Luke 24-48
I’ve just returned from a week in Honduras, visiting a residential and day school for children living in extreme poverty. My husband Paul and I worked at that school in the first year of our marriage, and I’ve been back many times, though it’s been a long time since my last visit. Like all who travel internationally, I’m experiencing upon my return the dissonance between what I have witnessed in another part of the world that God loves and Jesus came to save and where I live.
This is not a sermon about that dissonance; rather, it is about what it means to be a witness.
“You are witnesses to these things,” the newly-resurrected Jesus told his astonished disciples. And to what were they witnesses? According to the text, “That the one sent from God was to suffer and to rise from the dead on the last day, and that repentance and forgiveness of sins is to be proclaimed in his name to all the nations, beginning from Jerusalem.”
That’s a big witness. They were the ones who remembered Jesus’ teachings and what it was like to be in his presence. They were the ones who watched him die, and then, incredibly, experienced him as alive after death in ways both material and mystical.
You and I are not witnesses to those things. But our faith depends upon the witness of the first disciples as it is recorded in our biblical texts.
Many Christians whom I admire insist that the biblical stories are enough, that they must be enough for us, because the bible is the Word of God. Jesus is who he says he is because the witnesses wrote down what they saw and what they saw is true.
I believe that the Bible is a sacred text, that the stories told about Jesus are the foundation of our faith, and that through the biblical texts, God speaks to us. I believe these things because on one more than one occasion God has spoken to me in ways that are for me to put into words, but that nonetheless affirm my sense that Jesus can be trusted. It doesn’t happen all the time, and it’s more a mystical connection than an objective reality, but I’ve come to trust it.
Yet I confess that, for me, the stories themselves are not enough. I doubt that I would be Christian on the basis of the texts alone, were it not for the ways I’ve witnessed living faith in other people who have guided me on the Christian path. It’s said that faith is more caught than taught, and for me that was certainly the case. Not every person who claims to be a Jesus follower inspires my faith, but those that do are a spiritual lifeline for me. Some I’ve never met, but what I’ve learned of their witness made me want to be like them. Others were people who for whatever reason took an interest in me, or watched out for me—in short, who loved me in ways that felt more than human. Through them I felt the love of God.
Yet I’m sure that not even they would have been enough to keep me on the Christian path if I hadn’t had, on occasion, experiences that I can only describe as encounters with the living Christ. There have been times when I felt guided, forgiven, and strengthened by a power and a presence that I cannot prove to you, but that nonetheless assured me, in that moment, that Christ was real, and real for me.
What I’m trying to describe here, in general terms, is what people in other traditions might call “my testimony,” that is, how it is that I became and remain a person who believes in and strives to follow Jesus Christ.
The longer I live as a Christian, the more I realize that what grounds and sustains my life of faith isn’t one thing, but a constellation made up of many parts. The biblical stories are foundational, because of the ways they have woven themselves into my life story as a source of insight, inspiration and challenge. They have also frustrated and angered me for the way they have been used to justify human cruelty and prejudice in the name of God. The Bible is a complicated compilation of texts to spend your life connected to, but without them we’d lose our connection to Jesus of Nazareth and the spiritual traditions from which he came. Yet equally foundational are the people I’ve mentioned and the experiences I’ve had, not to mention the long stretches of doubt and emptiness that are also part of a life of faith.
Because I was just in Honduras, one experience from the year Paul and I lived there comes to mind. It was a hard year. The children at the school were street kids who knew how to wrap people like me around their little fingers. The environment was harsh—hot, dry and dirty. Within days of our arrival, my hopes and fantasies about the good we would do there had been shattered.
One day after work I walked through the neighborhood near the school and vented all my frustrations. I wasn’t consciously praying. It was more like rehearsing in my mind all that hurt, confused and angered me. At some point, I remember asking out loud “Is it always going to be this hard?” I wasn’t expecting an answer, but an answer came almost immediately. “Yes.”
I couldn’t remember a time when God had answered my prayers so quickly. It made me laugh. Then I heard, “And I will be with you.”
I don’t have experiences like that very often. But what God said to me that day got me through a tough year, and subsequent years when life was hard. Life isn’t always hard, but when it is, it’s good to know that someone has your back. And more than once, Jesus has shown up to tell me that he has mine.
Through the years I’ve learned that if I am to have a relationship with the living Christ of any depth, as with any relationship, what I bring to it matters. It matters that I stay close to the Scriptures that tell his story and through which he sometimes speaks. It matters that I show up in community with other Jesus followers, for their inspiration, wisdom and encouragement (and ample opportunities to practice patience and forgiveness). It matters that I show up in times of quiet prayer, or as in the situation I described, of shouting prayer. (There are long stretches in prayer when not much happens, but on occasion, I sense a real connection to the mystery of God.) It matters that I stretch myself in ways that help me learn how to love as Jesus loves.
I’ve also learned that I am not the primary initiator of this relationship, nor is everything up to me. Jesus’ teachings makes abundantly clear that the God he reveals to us will always go the extra mile to be company. In fact, we can walk away and stay away for years, and should we decide to come back, God will greet us as a beloved child.
I am also persuaded, despite the biblical passages that suggest otherwise, that God is not a bully. Jesus is not someone we must love and choose to follow–or else. Because that’s not how love works. We can choose to follow Jesus, or not. But we cannot stop the God whom Jesus reveals from loving us. We don’t have that power.
In the Scripture passages before us this morning, and throughout the entire worship service, there are several references to Jesus’ forgiveness of our sins. In the gospel, Jesus is quite clear that he had come to suffer and die so that all we might “repent” (a religious word that means to feel and express remorse for wrongs we have done and to commit to a new way of life), and receive forgiveness for our sins.
In the Book of Acts, we’ve been dropped into a scene in which the Apostle Peter has just healed a man who was lame from birth, and he did this miracle in the name of Jesus. Afterwards he addresses the astonished crowd and immediately chastises them for their part in Jesus’ death. You acted in ignorance, he tells them, as did your rulers who carried out the murder. But it was destined for the Messiah to suffer so that you might repent and receive forgiveness for your sins.
I’m not going to try to make sense of all this in the few moments I have left. But I’ve been thinking about this notion of our need to be forgiven for our sins, and Jesus’ death somehow accomplishing that for us. What I want to say to you is this: while my faith and my identity as a follower of Jesus rests on several pillars, among the life-transforming spiritual experiences of my life have been when I been forgiven for something I said or did that I regretted afterwards, and when I have felt accepted and loved unconditionally for who I am, despite the ways I fail, get things wrong, and consciously or unconsciously participate in the evils of this world.
Let me close by telling you of such a time. It isn’t about the worst thing I’ve said or done, but the memory of the forgiveness I received has stayed with me and informs my understanding of what Jesus did and does for us.
Before I was ordained I was part of a Christian community that I loved. It was plucky, thoughtful, and deeply engaged in the struggles for justice of our city. It also had a disproportionately large number of vulnerable adults as members. I was so inspired by the leadership of that church that I overcommitted myself, promising to do things that, in the end, I could not do. (a tendency that I have to this day). My failures had a significant, hurtful impact on the most vulnerable in the congregation.
In my embarrassment and guilt, I stopped going to that church. It was too painful. I never said goodbye; I simply drifted away.
The time came for me to leave that city—I accepted a lay ministry position on the other side of the country. As I was packing my things to leave, I realized that I had to come clean with the congregation and its leaders. I mustered the courage to make an appointment with the senior pastor to apologize. I rehearsed everything I was going to say and when I sat down, I acknowledged all that I had done, and more importantly, what I had failed to do.
I don’t remember exactly what the pastor said to me in response. I know that she didn’t minimize my failure or patronize me with assurances that my behavior was no big deal. I felt heard in her presence, and seen for who I was. I felt loved and forgiven. While she was the one offering me forgiveness, Jesus was in the room. I left her office as if walking on clouds.
Later I thought to myself, “This is what Jesus meant—this is liberation that forgiveness brings.” I vowed that day to become the kind of person able to offer such forgiveness to another person whenever the tables were turned.
There is more to the Christian faith than forgiveness for our sins. But when you need forgiveness and a way out of bondage you’re in, there is no one better than Jesus to lead you home. If we choose, we get to participate in the miracle of forgiveness, by daring to receive it for ourselves and share it with others. We play a part in Jesus’ ministry of forgiveness, and the unconditional love that undergirds it. The better we get at it, the more credible and life affirming our witness will be.
To be a witness is to speak of what you know and testify to what we have seen. I’m here to testify to the fact that a relationship with Jesus isn’t about one thing, but at the top of the list is forgiveness.
I wonder what you know, and what you have seen.
I wonder if you know what it’s like to be set free. And what it’s like to help Jesus set someone else free.
For me, it’s like walking on clouds.
by Bishop Mariann | Apr 4, 2024
On this most Holy Night, in which our Lord Jesus passed over from death to live, the Church invites her members, dispersed throughout the world, to gather in vigil and prayer.
Easter Vigil Liturgy, Book of Common Prayer
When the sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome bought spices, so that they might go and anoint him. And very early on the first day of the week, when the sun had risen, they went to the tomb. They had been saying to one another, “Who will roll away the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” When they looked up, they saw that the stone, which was very large, had already been rolled back. As they entered the tomb, they saw a young man, dressed in a white robe, sitting on the right side; and they were alarmed. But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed; you are looking for Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has been raised; he is not here. Look, there is the place they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you.” So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.
Mark 16:1-8
Resurrection is the mysterious process of life rising out of death. It always begins small. In the darkest hour, a seed of life begins to stir, and we rise. Before we know what’s happening, we’re moving toward what lies on a far horizon. To anyone watching us, we’re just going about our day, and we are. But something has changed and we know it.
Faith in the resurrection doesn’t require us to cast a blind eye to all that is not or has yet to be redeemed. For starters, we needn’t pretend that the world isn’t on fire. We know that as we gather here in relative safety, others are huddled in fear for their lives, and we can hold their grief, and ours, with us now. Nor do we have to surrender our perplexity or skepticism in the face of all we don’t understand.
Recently I spoke by telephone with an old friend, someone I’ve known and loved for over 30 years. She and her family were active in the congregation I served in Toledo, Ohio for the first five years of my ordained ministry. She is our younger son’s godmother.
After catching up on family and other things, I asked her if she had plans for Easter. (By the way, she and her family had stopped attending a long time ago.) She said, “Well, this wasn’t the conversation I wasn’t planning on having with my friend the bishop, but since you asked, I need to tell you that of all Christian holidays, Easter is the one I struggle with most. I don’t know how to make sense of the idea that Jesus died for our sins. It doesn’t bother me to be around people for whom it does make sense, but it’s a real stumbling block for me, and I’ve been thinking about it since we spoke.
I was in my car while we were having this conversation, and all I was really asking was where she was going to have dinner. So I wasn’t sure where to begin. Finally I said, light-heartedly, “You know, you are the very first person I know who has struggled with this.” She laughed, which was good. Then I assured her that Jesus dying for our sins has been a subject of intense debate among Christians throughout the ages, and thus there are many ways to think about it.
I was already thinking about a few articles and essays on the resurrection that I wanted to send her. “Before we talk in earnest about this,” I said, “it would help me to know what you mean when you say ‘Jesus died for our sins.’ It can mean very different things to different people.” I was thinking of all the times when people say to me that they don’t believe in God and I ask them to describe the God they don’t believe in, because chances are good that I don’t believe in that God, either.
By then I had reached my destination and we had to stop. But I’ve been thinking about our conversation since then, and it occurred to me that there was one story in particular that I wanted to share with her, because that best expresses my understanding of what the phrase ‘Jesus died for our sins’ means. It doesn’t speak to me intellectually, but poetically. It doesn’t answer all the questions I have, but it resonates in my heart.
So let me close by telling this story to you. In doing so, I honor a dear friend who shared it with me years ago and who died last summer. It’s not my story, but it feels like mine—that’s how deeply it speaks to me of forgiveness and love and what Jesus makes possible for us.
This is for you, Perry Epes.
The story is found in a trilogy, The Seed and the Sower, written by the South African author, Laurens van der Post. It begins with the haunting confession of a young British soldier:
“I had a brother once and I betrayed him.”
He goes on, “The betrayal in itself was so slight that most people would find ‘betrayal’ too exaggerated a word. Yet as one recognizes the nature of the seed from the tree, and the tree by its fruit, and the fruit by the taste on the tongue, so I know the betrayal from its consequences and the tyrannical flavor it left behind in my emotions…
So this is a tale of shame, the shame that this young man, who was blessed with physical beauty and intelligence, felt about his younger brother, who was, in contrast, slightly deformed, quiet and self-conscious. His brother’s only gift, it seemed, was that of song, hardly anything in comparison to the other’s many talents. Few noticed this gift, and it was a source of curiosity among other boys. The young man felt his brother’s deformity as a threat to his own identity, and while he was on the surface protective and affectionate, inside he felt embarrassed and resentful.
The time came for his brother to join him at boarding school, and when the hazing rituals began—a humiliating experience for any boy—his brother was particularly humiliated and scorned. He felt that he ought to say something, but he did nothing but watch from a distance, avoiding his brother’s increasingly desperate eyes that searched for him in the mocking crowds. Afterwards he made light of his brother’s pain and they never spoke of it again. Nor did his brother ever sing again.
Years past and during World War II, the older brother found himself in Palestine as a soldier in the British Army. There he met an old priest who became his friend. The priest told him that every year at Easter, he walked the seven mile walk between Jerusalem and Emmaus, to remember Jesus’ encounter with the two disciples on the road. “I walk only at night,” the priest told him, “to remind myself of all the ways I fail to recognize Jesus in the daylight of my life.” That Easter night the soldier joined him. It was an unremarkable experience, but shortly afterwards he became quite ill with a recurring bout of malaria.
Fevered and hallucinating, he dreamed of the Resurrected One on the road. “Where is Judas?” Jesus asked in the dream. “We can’t go on without him.” The soldier listened as the other disciples explained to Jesus that Judas was dead, that he hanged himself in shame. Jesus responded by looking up to heaven in prayer. “This cannot be! If I fail in this, I fail in all else besides. His deed, too, must be redeemed.”
Then the man in his dream stepped forward. “I am Judas.” Jesus smiled. “Good. Now we can both be free.” “But I am not free,” the man confessed. “I had a brother once, and I betrayed him.” Jesus nodded slowly, in understanding kindness. “Then you must go to your brother and make our peace with him, even as I have had to do with my need of you.”
On his next furlough, the man traveled back to South Africa, found his brother on their family farm and acknowledged his guilt. “You came all the way here simply to say this to me?” the brother marveled. When the soldier left to return to his military post, he heard his brother singing.
What I love about this story, and why it speaks to me of Jesus’ dying for our sins, isn’t that it ends in such a satisfying reconciliation. That almost never happens for me. What I love is Jesus’ question: “Where is Judas?” and his insistence to God, “We can’t go on without him.”
I love that the accomplished brother carried in his soul the secret of his guilt, and it was there, in that dark place with no one save the priest who heard his confession, that Jesus met him and set him free. I love that forgiveness came with a path of restitution, a way of making things as right as we can and to join with Jesus in helping others to rise, too.
So yes, I believe that Jesus died for our sins, not as a substituting sacrifice, but as an expression of sacrificial love that will not let us go, no matter who we are, what we have done, or what has been done to us.
To be a person of faith in this world is a daily discipline of taking small steps each day toward life, even if it isn’t the life we wanted or imagined, even when the worst thing possible has happened. It is a grace that meets us where we are, but does not leave us there.
Resurrection asks us to stake our life on hope when hope feels small. The poet Gwendolyn Brooks, the first African American to win the Pulitzer Prize, once wrote, “Say to the down-keepers, the sun-slappers, the self-soilers, the harmony-hushers, ‘even if you are not ready for day, it cannot always be night.’”
It cannot always be night. Even though it’s still dark, the light of Christ is calling us, asking us to be the ones to move out in faith. Who knows what will be lost if we don’t? And what might happen when we do?
Read Bishop Mariann’s full Easter Vigil sermon here
by Bishop Mariann | Mar 30, 2024
On this most Holy Night, in which our Lord Jesus passed over from death to live, the Church invites her members, dispersed throughout the world, to gather in vigil and prayer.
Easter Vigil Liturgy, Book of Common Prayer
When the sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome bought spices, so that they might go and anoint him. And very early on the first day of the week, when the sun had risen, they went to the tomb. They had been saying to one another, “Who will roll away the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” When they looked up, they saw that the stone, which was very large, had already been rolled back. As they entered the tomb, they saw a young man, dressed in a white robe, sitting on the right side; and they were alarmed. But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed; you are looking for Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has been raised; he is not here. Look, there is the place they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you.” So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.
Mark 16:1-8
Sometimes we have to move toward the light while it is still dark.
Sometimes we have to move toward love even when we don’t feel it.
Sometimes we have to move toward life even when we’re just going through the motions, and not really living anymore.
Moving toward light when it’s still dark is awkward, and it’s tentative. But there are times when we simply need to move.
Early on the first Easter morning, it was the women of Jesus’ inner circle who moved. They went first, not that they had any idea that that was what they were doing. They rose that night from the stupor of grief, fully expecting to anoint a dead body.
That’s how resurrection works. Someone gets up in the middle of the night, gets up and moves, and in the movement something happens, and dawn breaks.
Notice, too, that resurrection is a collective experience, with implications for many people, but someone has to go first and make a path so others can follow. That’s what the women did. What they experienced was beyond credulity. So “they said nothing to anyone of what they heard and saw because they were afraid.” (Mk 16:8)
Well, so says that text. But eventually they did tell somebody, despite their fear, no doubt, struggling to believe what the young man at the tomb had told them as much as those first listening to that bizarre story.
There’s another version of the story (there are lots of versions, by the way) in which the young man at the tomb becomes an angel. In another Jesus himself appears in the garden, rather telling them to go to Galilee to meet him there. There’s another version in which the men eventually show up at the tomb after the women (just saying), and in another, the men gather in fear in the same room where they had shared their final meal with Jesus. In yet another, two of the men were so bereft they simply had to get out of town and they started walking toward another town named Emmaus. There’s one more in which the disciples all go back to Galilee to resume their previous lives as fishermen.
For all the variations on the earliest accounts of Jesus’ resurrection, there is a common thread. Jesus appears to the disciples in ways that are at once other-worldly, in that he wasn’t simply resuscitated, He is alive, but not as before and they know it. At the same time, his appearances are also strikingly mundane. He simply showed up as they were going through the motions of life, which made it all rather frightening and wonderful, and strangely normal.
I cannot speak to you from personal experience about what happened on that first Easter, or of what happens to us on the other side of our physical death.
But this I know: on this side of our final crossing over, while the context of resurrection is death, it takes place in the midst of daily life. Something or someone dies, and with that something or someone, a part of us dies, too. For a while—sometimes for a very long time—we live as though dead ourselves. If the loss is deep enough, that’s just fine with us.
Resurrection is the mysterious process of life rising out of that death. It always begins small. In the darkest hour, a seed of life begins to stir, and we rise. Before we know what’s happening, we’re moving toward what lies on a far horizon. To anyone watching us, we’re just going about our day, and we are. But something has changed and we know it.
Faith in the resurrection doesn’t require us to cast a blind eye to all that is not or has yet to be redeemed. For starters, we needn’t pretend that the world isn’t on fire. We know that as we gather here in relative safety, others are huddled in fear for their lives, and we can hold their grief, and ours, with us now. Nor do we have to surrender our perplexity or skepticism in the face of all we don’t understand.
Recently I spoke by telephone with an old friend, someone I’ve known and loved for over 30 years. She and her family were active in the congregation I served in Toledo, Ohio for the first five years of my ordained ministry. She is our younger son’s godmother.
After catching up on family and other things, I asked her if she had plans for Easter. (By the way, she and her family had stopped attending a long time ago.) She said, “Well, this wasn’t the conversation I wasn’t planning on having with my friend the bishop, but since you asked, I need to tell you that of all Christian holidays, Easter is the one I struggle with most. I don’t know how to make sense of the idea that Jesus died for our sins. It doesn’t bother me to be around people for whom it does make sense, but it’s a real stumbling block for me, and I’ve been thinking about it since we spoke.
I was in my car while we were having this conversation, and all I was really asking was where she was going to have dinner. So I wasn’t sure where to begin. Finally I said, light-heartedly, “You know, you are the very first person I know who has struggled with this.” She laughed, which was good. Then I assured her that Jesus dying for our sins has been a subject of intense debate among Christians throughout the ages, and thus there are many ways to think about it.
I was already thinking about a few articles and essays on the resurrection that I wanted to send her. “Before we talk in earnest about this,” I said, “it would help me to know what you mean when you say ‘Jesus died for our sins.’ It can mean very different things to different people.” I was thinking of all the times when people say to me that they don’t believe in God and I ask them to describe the God they don’t believe in, because chances are good that I don’t believe in that God, either.
By then I had reached my destination and we had to stop. But I’ve been thinking about our conversation since then, and it occurred to me that there was one story in particular that I wanted to share with her, because that best expresses my understanding of what the phrase ‘Jesus died for our sins’ means. It doesn’t speak to me intellectually, but poetically. It doesn’t answer all the questions I have, but it resonates in my heart.
So let me close by telling this story to you. In doing so, I honor a dear friend who shared it with me years ago and who died last summer. It’s not my story, but it feels like mine—that’s how deeply it speaks to me of forgiveness and love and what Jesus makes possible for us.
This is for you, Perry Epes.
The story is found in a trilogy, The Seed and the Sower, written by the South African author, Laurens van der Post. It begins with the haunting confession of a young British soldier:
“I had a brother once and I betrayed him.”
He goes on, “The betrayal in itself was so slight that most people would find ‘betrayal’ too exaggerated a word. Yet as one recognizes the nature of the seed from the tree, and the tree by its fruit, and the fruit by the taste on the tongue, so I know the betrayal from its consequences and the tyrannical flavor it left behind in my emotions…
So this is a tale of shame, the shame that this young man, who was blessed with physical beauty and intelligence, felt about his younger brother, who was, in contrast, slightly deformed, quiet and self-conscious. His brother’s only gift, it seemed, was that of song, hardly anything in comparison to the other’s many talents. Few noticed this gift, and it was a source of curiosity among other boys. The young man felt his brother’s deformity as a threat to his own identity, and while he was on the surface protective and affectionate, inside he felt embarrassed and resentful.
The time came for his brother to join him at boarding school, and when the hazing rituals began—a humiliating experience for any boy—his brother was particularly humiliated and scorned. He felt that he ought to say something, but he did nothing but watch from a distance, avoiding his brother’s increasingly desperate eyes that searched for him in the mocking crowds. Afterwards he made light of his brother’s pain and they never spoke of it again. Nor did his brother ever sing again.
Years past and during World War II, the older brother found himself in Palestine as a soldier in the British Army. There he met an old priest who became his friend. The priest told him that every year at Easter, he walked the seven mile walk between Jerusalem and Emmaus, to remember Jesus’ encounter with the two disciples on the road. “I walk only at night,” the priest told him, “to remind myself of all the ways I fail to recognize Jesus in the daylight of my life.” That Easter night the soldier joined him. It was an unremarkable experience, but shortly afterwards he became quite ill with a recurring bout of malaria.
Fevered and hallucinating, he dreamed of the Resurrected One on the road. “Where is Judas?” Jesus asked in the dream. “We can’t go on without him.” The soldier listened as the other disciples explained to Jesus that Judas was dead, that he hanged himself in shame. Jesus responded by looking up to heaven in prayer. “This cannot be! If I fail in this, I fail in all else besides. His deed, too, must be redeemed.”
Then the man in his dream stepped forward. “I am Judas.” Jesus smiled. “Good. Now we can both be free.” “But I am not free,” the man confessed. “I had a brother once, and I betrayed him.” Jesus nodded slowly, in understanding kindness. “Then you must go to your brother and make our peace with him, even as I have had to do with my need of you.”
On his next furlough, the man traveled back to South Africa, found his brother on their family farm and acknowledged his guilt. “You came all the way here simply to say this to me?” the brother marveled. When the soldier left to return to his military post, he heard his brother singing.
What I love about this story, and why it speaks to me of Jesus’ dying for our sins, isn’t that it ends in such a satisfying reconciliation. That almost never happens for me. What I love is Jesus’ question: “Where is Judas?” and his insistence to God, “We can’t go on without him.”
I love that the accomplished brother carried in his soul the secret of his guilt, and it was there, in that dark place with no one save the priest who heard his confession, that Jesus met him and set him free. I love that forgiveness came with a path of restitution, a way of making things as right as we can and to join with Jesus in helping others to rise, too.
So yes, I believe that Jesus died for our sins, not as a substituting sacrifice, but as an expression of sacrificial love that will not let us go, no matter who we are, what we have done, or what has been done to us.
To be a person of faith in this world is a daily discipline of taking small steps each day toward life, even if it isn’t the life we wanted or imagined, even when the worst thing possible has happened. It is a grace that meets us where we are, but does not leave us there.
Resurrection asks us to stake our life on hope when hope feels small. The poet Gwendolyn Brooks, the first African American to win the Pulitzer Prize, once wrote, “Say to the down-keepers, the sun-slappers, the self-soilers, the harmony-hushers, ‘even if you are not ready for day, it cannot always be night.’”
It cannot always be night. Even though it’s still dark, the light of Christ is calling us, asking us to be the ones to move out in faith. Who knows what will be lost if we don’t? And what might happen when we do?