Embracing the Age of Authenticity

Embracing the Age of Authenticity

“But it’s how we’ve always done it!”
“We don’t have enough volunteers.”
“How can we grow our membership to minimize our deficit?”

How often have you heard these laments in your parish? Or voiced them yourself during times of turbulence, when the path forward feels daunting or unclear? You are not alone; and, this is all a part of a larger evolution. This article looks at how changes in the church reflect a broader cultural shift in the United States from the Age of Association to the Age of Authenticity.

 

The Age of Association

From European colonization through the late 1700s, church, politics, and education were closely linked and funded by local taxes. After these connections loosened, American society saw a rise in voluntary, member-funded organizations—country clubs, labor unions, bowling leagues and yes, churches—that gave people meaning, purpose, and belonging. This era lasted until the late 1960s.1

That time period is called the Age of Association. It was marked by a surge in voluntary groups and organizations that shaped communities and civic life. These associations brought people together for shared purposes but also had limitations: leadership tended to remain in the hands of a few, structures often became rigid over time, and their success depended heavily on members’ steady participation and financial stability in the broader economy.

We see echoes of these same patterns in our churches today. Leadership often falls to a small circle of long-standing members, leaving little room for new leaders to develop. Long-loved traditions can sometimes become barriers to needed change. And sustaining ministry still depends on the time, energy, and resources of congregants—commitments that are increasingly difficult as people juggle demanding schedules, shifting priorities, and economic uncertainty.

 

Facing a Shift

We are now living through a major cultural shift from the Age of Association to the Age of Authenticity. The Age of Authenticity emphasizes self-discovery and the construction of identity through individual choices, often at the expense of trust in and reliance on institutions. “Institutions may have some instrumental value, but [current] relationships to them are fluid, changeable, and loose.”2

People increasingly seek meaning and community individually while distrusting traditional structures. And many church leaders—rather than considering how they can adapt, support, and uplift the spiritual life of the congregation in this new age—instead feel stuck spending all their time keeping up with the management of an institution born in the age of association.

 

What does this mean for churches?

This is a big challenge for our churches. But it’s also a huge opportunity. People are starving for connection. We are facing increasing mental health issues, political polarization, and societal injustices. Our parishes are surrounded by people seeking to make meaning of the current landscape. They are seeking a place to ground themselves in what is true. They are looking to build relationships to help them through the hard times. They are not looking for a place to be a “pledging unit” or a “butt in the pew.”

This is our time to reinstill the core beliefs of our parish—in Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection, the movement of the Holy Spirit, and how God is already at work in the world around us.

This is our time to capitalize on the core practices of our faith—scripture study, forgiveness, prayer, worship, and hospitality.

This is our time to identify the core values of our community—love of neighbor, discernment, grace, and faith.


So what do we do?

As Karl Vaters writes, “Discipleship fixes everything.”3 Here are some practical ideas for how to begin this shift toward embracing the Age of Authenticity.

There is a host of people outside your church doors just waiting for you to experiment, extend invitations, and have conversations.

In the words of Dwight Zscheile and Blair Pogue, “The church is made for times like this…”4

If you want to have a conversation about how this shift is impacting your parish, don’t hesitate to reach out to the Rev. Canon Anne-Marie Jeffery or the Rev. Emily Labrecque.


1Zscheile, Dwight. “From the Age of Association to Authenticity”, Faith + Lead blog
2Dwight J. Zscheile and Blair A. Pogue, Embracing the Mixed Ecology: Inherited and New Forms of Christian Community Flourishing Together (New York: Church Publishing, June 3, 2025), p. 9.
3Karl Vaters, De-Sizing Church: How Church Became a Science, Then an Obsession, and What’s Next (Moody Publishers, April 2, 2024), p. 159.
4Zcheile and Pogue, pp. 12-13

 

Becoming Better Neighbors: A Learning Day

Becoming Better Neighbors: A Learning Day

Does your church have neighbors? How about friends? Are you an integral part of a community made up of people and institutions and human needs and services and conversations about the future? Or are you just one more building where no one but the people already inside know much about what you do?

Participants in this learning day will explore the possibilities for developing deep and sustaining relationships with our neighbors–relationships of mutual support and shared visioning for the future, relationships that mean that we are known for who we are and what we do and what we believe, even by those who live and believe quite differently. This event is for churches at all stages of growth and vitality that seek deeper and stronger connections with their surrounding communities. For churches that are growing among younger generations, community relationships provide the grounding for the kind of engaged faith many are seeking. For churches that are experiencing a reduced stream of visitors, becoming known in your community as a strong partner and friend is an important step towards letting the people who need you know that you are ready to welcome them.

The day will be structured around presentations by Stacy Brungardt from Focused Community Strategies, who will share her experience and expertise about building community relationships in sustained ways. We will also have plenty of time to learn from one another, share our own experiences, and start making plans for the work to come!

Lunch to accommodate a range of dietary needs will be provided. Spanish and ASL interpretation will be arranged as needed.

Register here: https://forms.gle/yw6o7vUKja3UDjSt7

Working with a Persona: The Next Vital Step for St. James, Potomac

Working with a Persona: The Next Vital Step for St. James, Potomac

Back when Anglican churches were first established, they were created to serve specific geographic areas—what became known as “parish bounds” or parish boundaries. Each church drew its membership from within that boundary and at a time when travel was mostly done by foot or horse, there wasn’t much question of whether parishioners would worship at their “neighborhood” church.

As culture and society—and access to new methods of transportation—have evolved, so too has this reality. In many cases today here in the Diocese of Washington, we have what might be considered overlapping parishes—churches situated physically close enough together as to seem to pull from the same potential pool of members.

So how do we as parish leaders know who to reach out to when we are planted in a booming metropolis? Or, if we’re in a more rural area, how do we engage in the wider community in a way that might bring people through our doors?

Developing a persona is one effective way to get to the root of these questions.

With demographic information provided through MissionInsite about your neighbors and your own experience in the community surrounding your parish, you can begin to understand the types of neighbors you have and how you might serve their needs. What do they value? How do they spend their free time? Who do they connect within the wider community? What stage of life are they in?

Think of a persona, then, as a fictional representation of your neighbor(s)—a reference tool that will help you make informed decisions about your parish’s future ministry and community engagement efforts.

Developing a persona might be especially helpful if you’re in a very rural area where you don’t have immediate neighbors you can easily get to know, or if you’re in a densely populated area where there’s too many neighbors to count. This resource is a wealth of information. To learn more about how to use MissionInsite, contact the Rev. Emily Labrecque.

It’s one thing for us to explain why we think using a persona can be helpful when it comes to taking the next vital step in the life of your parish. But let’s hear what happened when one EDOW parish chose to take a closer look at their neighborhood.

In 2023, St. James’ Episcopal Church in Potomac, MD began the process of coming to understand their neighbors more deeply. Their rector, the Rev. Meredith Heffner, writes:

“We were invited to use MissionInsite to take a look at the community around St. James’, asking ourselves if our ministries serve our community in the most effective ways…. In response, with the MissionInsite material, we spent the next few months defining our ‘persona,’ a couple we named, Connor and Allison.”

Based on the demographic report from MissionInsite, St. James’ determined that Connor and Allison are a married couple with two high-school aged kids. They are both on social media and consume news from traditional news sources like CNN and the Washington Post. They believe in tolerance and diversity and support social causes. They are comfortable with traditional forms of worship and seek warm, friendly encounters.

During the same time that St. James was developing and refining their “Connor and Allison” persona, they were also learning that their congregation was burned out.

The leadership team realized they needed to provide opportunities for fellowship and formation that did not require a heavy lift. Taking that into consideration with their persona, St. James found ways to connect both the needs/desires/concerns of Connor and Allison with the reality at St. James.

“We didn’t know [right away] how we would use our persona,” Rev. Meredith shares, “but over time what’s been helpful is recognizing, in a neighborhood of Connors and Allisons, how many of our traditional expectations of “Church” don’t make sense.”

Having the persona to work with continues to be fruitful.

With all the recent government upheaval, it felt important to reassess how the congregation responded to the needs of Connor and Allison given their jobs as government employees, so the St. James’ leadership brought their persona into their vestry retreat. When Meredith handed the persona for her vestry to re-read, “the room caught on fire.”

The vestry was so compelled by Allison and Connor’s new (perceived) needs that they instantly began assessing their ministries to discern how best to support their persona family. “This made our visioning and brainstorming easy and Spirit-filled,” Rev. Meredith says. Each vestry liaison to a committee was tasked with sharing the new list of ideas with committee members for discussion and discernment of next steps.

Holding the probable financial impact of job loss front of mind, the finance committee generated a list of actions they might take—some of which overlap with other committees, such as pastoral care and communications—to insure they continue serving the needs of the congregation through rough waters:

  • Emergency financial help if needed
  • Transparency / communication [of parish finances] / continuing parish meetings
  • Prepare for “budget flexibility” and communicating to parish (e.g., if income drops)
  • Reminders that pledges can be changed or paused, as well as method to do so
  • Reminders on how to use various giving platforms

Think about how impactful those actions will be to the Connors and Allisons in their neighborhood. This type of adaptability and proactive response to your neighbors’ needs is a hallmark of a vital congregation. We look forward to seeing the outcomes for St. James.

When your ministries feel as though they can barely stay afloat and you’re trying to be everything to everyone, developing a persona can be a crucial piece of the puzzle to helping you discern who and how to reach your neighbors.

If you’d like to explore this idea further, please reach out to the Rev. Anne-Marie Jeffery, Canon for Congregational Vitality or the Rev. Emily Labrecque, Missioner for Church Revitalization.

Committee on Congregational Stewardship and Diocesan Support: Application Process Open

Committee on Congregational Stewardship and Diocesan Support: Application Process Open

At the December 2023 Diocesan Council meeting, a resolution was presented and passed calling for the establishment of a Committee on Congregational Stewardship and Diocesan Support.

The work before the committee is to review the history of congregational giving to the mission and ministry of the Diocese and—through engagement with active leaders from around the diocese, lay and clergy, new and longtime—recommend concrete, actionable steps that we as a diocese can take to arrive at a consensus that fits this moment in time in the life of the Diocese around appropriate levels of congregational investment in our common Diocesan mission and ministry.

Learn more:
Watch the Rev. Jessica Hitchcock’s presentation about the committee at the recent Diocesan Convention

Apply to serve:
Committee on Congregational Stewardship and Diocesan Support Application

The deadline to submit an application is Wednesday, February 21 by 5:00 p.m.

Using MissionInsite to Grow Parish Vitality

Using MissionInsite to Grow Parish Vitality

Is your parish constantly seeking out young families only to discover they’re not showing up?

In the Tending Our Soil Thriving Congregation Initiative, one of the tools that congregations have found most useful is called MissionInsite. MissionInsite is a “cloud-based technology platform that bridges the gap between data and decisionable information by answering the ‘where’ and ‘what about’ questions in your [church] and community.” MissionInsite provides data such as population demographics, economic details, sociological insights, and more, to help you better understand your community.

In the first year of Tending Our Soil, each participating congregation draws a geographic boundary around their community– typically a 15 minute walk if they’re in an urban area or a 15 minute drive if in a suburban area–and run reports that provide, in detail, the type of people living in that area.

Imagine if you knew the typical household type in your neighborhood. How much better might you be able to reach your neighbors if you knew who actually lived there! St. Dunstan’s in Bethesda had been trying to reach young families. They tried to provide Sunday School and Vacation Bible School, and other programming that would appeal to children and families. However, when they ran their MissionInsite reports, they discovered that their neighborhood was actually full of empty nesters. They were surrounded by middle-aged parents who suddenly found themselves with a lot of time on their hands, searching for meaning in a life separate from their children. What an opportunity this has been for St. Dunstan’s to rethink how they offer themselves to the community.

Similarly, St. Paul’s on K Street in Foggy Bottom used this opportunity to pair their MissionInsite data with an ancient custom called “Beating the Bounds.” This used to be a vital custom to churches at a time when maps were not readily available and the community was known through its people.

As St. Paul’s parishioner Nathan Brown writes, “The parish boundaries determined important issues, such as where parishioners could graze their livestock to the tithe collected by the parish for the maintenance of the Church and clergy. For these reasons, it was important that parishioners understood the boundaries and passed this knowledge on.”

During the 7 mile walk around their bounds, the team of 20 parishioners from St. Paul’s discovered much about their community. Brown writes,

“During our walk around our bounds, we encountered members of our community from Sec. Pete Buttigieg, a stampede of marathon runners, tourists, a marching band, and locals. We also were reminded of how much work is still needed, passing the tents of those experiencing homelessness. As we reached the relative quiet of Rock Creek Park, it was impossible not to reflect upon the magnitude of our calling as members of the parish.”

St. Paul’s discovered that their demographics matched what they saw in their community. This experience called them to a deeper understanding of and relationship with those around them.

If you are looking for answers, trying to discern who’s in your community and how you might serve them best, I recommend using MissionInsite. This tool is free and available to each parish in the diocese. If you want to have a wealth of useful information at your fingertips, you can the Rev. Canon Anne-Marie Jeffery for more information.

Getting to know our neighbors is one of the best things you can do as you seek to be a vital parish in your community. Let’s get to work!