by Bishop Mariann | Jul 26, 2024
Bishop Mariann delivered this sermon on Friday, July 26, 2024 at St. Mark’s Cathedral in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Good evening. I am Mariann Budde, and for eighteen years I served as rector of St. John’s in Minneapolis—a congregation filled with passionate, strong-willed people who prepared me well for my current vocation.
Heartfelt thanks to Bishop Craig Loya and Canon Blair Pogue for the kind invitation to join you for this service of remembrance and celebration. It’s wonderful to be among former colleagues and good friends, and to meet many of the current leaders of the Episcopal Church in Minnesota. While I left thirteen years ago, a part of me is still here and always will be. My husband Paul and I raised our sons as Minnesotans. We return several times a year to the place where I am known as Mariann and my title is Grandma.
Let me begin with an excerpt from Womanpriest, memoir of the Rev. Alla Renée Bozarth-Campbell, beloved in this diocese, whose fiftieth anniversary of ordination we celebrate tonight, and whose stole I am honored to wear:
She writes:
My story begins with Jesus in the Gospels and the liberating word he spoke to the women he met. His message, revealing to them possibilities for themselves that were not apparent in their cultures, carries the same freedom to me: be all you can be. Through my own encounter with the Gospels, I have heard Christ calling me to lay claim on the dignity that is mine as a human being created in the image of God, female.
My story begins with the examples of the heroic women in the Hebrew Scripture and their courageous witness to the integrity and holiness of womanhood…
I look to the ministry of Mary Magdalene to whom the risen Christ first appeared. In the truest sense, she was the “Apostle of Apostles,” because she was the first one sent by the risen Christ to proclaim the Good News of Christ’s resurrection to the others.
…My story begins with their stories, and with the hidden history of all the great women of our religious tradition from the beginning to the present. History has too often overlooked these women, relegating them to secondary roles in the unfolding drama of Christianity, when, if fact, they are central figures.1
***
For all who have heeded the call to follow Jesus, our stories begin with these stories too. For alongside the men of their time, women have always been there. Women have always been, in Alla’s words, “active participants and agents of the creation of our religious tradition,” the vessel through which we have come to know the Risen Christ.
The President of the House of Deputies at the 1976 General Convention was a prominent Black lay leader, Dr. Charles Lawrence. After the resolution in support of ordaining women to the priesthood and episcopate was finally approved by both bishops and deputies, a journalist asked him, “Dr. Lawrence, now that women’s ordination has passed, what about the ordination of homosexuals? Is that coming next?” He replied, “That was not a vote to ordain women. It was a vote to no longer ordain only certain categories of people.”2 Bishop Robert DeWitt, one of the three bishops who ordained the Philadelphia Eleven, said of that day, “The human family is the beneficiary.”
The human family is the beneficiary whenever we acknowledge the full humanity of any category of persons previously excluded on the basis of their being from bearing the image of God to another.
May I have a show of hands? How many women priests have been met at the back of church by someone in tears because she had never seen a woman preside at worship before? What is that about? An affirmation of their being as women. Now, thank God, it’s normative for girls and boys growing up in the Episcopal Church to see women priests—something unimaginable when some of us were children and girls could not be altar servers, and women couldn’t serve on vestries, represent their congregations at Diocean conventions, or be elected deputies for General Convention.
***
On the official website of the film The Philadelphia Eleven, producer and director Margo Gursey writes:
I am not an Episcopalian… to me this story is for everyone. It is how to break down barriers with grace, and be true to oneself in the process. And it is about standing up to institutions that do not allow all people to be who they are called to be.3
What a gift her film is to us. Producing it took longer than any other of Guernsey’s projects, and the biggest roadblock was a lack of funding. But then a small group of mostly Episcopal women organized to raise the money, contacting donors large and small. They knew that the 50th anniversary of the Philadelphia ordination was a big deal and they were determined that the film’s debut would be part of it. More on that in a moment.
When asked what inspired her to make the documentary, Guernsey said that it was reading Pauli Murray’s autobiography, Song in A Weary Throat. “Murray was at the ordination,” Guernsey said, “and the way she tells the story drew me in.”
Pauli Murray was more than simply there at the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia. A lifelong Episcopalian, Pauli Murray had dedicated her life to gender and racial equality as a lawyer during Jim Crow and the Civil Rights Era. When she was accepted into Howard University law school in 1941, Murray was stunned by the sexism she experienced there among her Black male peers. She called it “Jane Crow.” But as a devout Anglo-Catholic, Murray was initially opposed to the idea of women priests. It wasn’t until 1972, with her law practice and teaching careers behind her, that she found herself a student at General Theological Seminary preparing for the priesthood.
It was a call that surprised her, and yet, in retrospect, like most calls that come later in life, it felt as if her whole life had been preparing her for it. The General Convention had yet to pass a resolution affirming that women could be ordained as priests and deacons, but she entered seminary assuming (as did her bishop) that such a resolution would surely pass in the fall of 1973. That, as we know, did not happen, largely because of the way votes were counted in those days.
It was a stunning blow. Murray was among the many men and women who were grief-stricken, frustrated and angry. Some immediately started planning for the next Convention in 1976. Others were no longer willing to wait.
In December of 1973, five male deacons were ordained as priests at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine in New York City. Five women deacons with identical qualifications also presented themselves at the altar before Bishop Paul Moore. Moore was supportive of women’s ordination, but like all active bishops of that time, he would not “break collegiality” with other bishops or act without the affirmation of General Convention. “Go in peace, my sisters,” he told them sadly. Pauli Murray watched as the five women turned and exited the church. “No funeral procession could have been more sorrowful,” she writes. Murray raced down the side aisle to join the women outside the Cathedral, only to discover that more than half the congregation was already there in tearful support.4
After that the mood at General Seminary turned ugly. Most male seminarians were outraged that women deacons would disrupt an ordination service to “make a political statement.” The lines of division were hardening. Some bishops who supported the ordination of women announced moratoriums on all ordinations in their dioceses until women could be ordained alongside men. Others threatened to leave the church if women were to be ordained and take their dioceses with them.
“The proverbial dam broke in June 1974,” Alla writes, when two prominent male leaders publicly called upon bishops of the Church to use their authority to ordain women. (It’s stunning to realize in retrospect that there was nothing in canon law that explicitly said women couldn’t be priests.) Dr. Charles Willie, Harvard professor and Vice President of the House of Deputies, preached a sermon in which he said, “The church is in need of a bishop who believes that in Christ there is neither male or female, and with the courage and humility to disobey an unjust law.”5
A meeting was called on July 10. Three ordaining bishops were present, as were six women deacons. The Rev. Paul Washington offered the use of the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia. From the onset of the meeting, “the attention was focused on the impasse created by the inaction of diocesan bishops who refused to ordain women to the priesthood even though no written law prohibited it. The approval of the General Convention, while supportive, was not necessary to change the interpretation of the law, which every diocesan bishop had the authority to do.” The twenty-one clergy and laypersons at that fateful meeting agreed: “Christian charity requires that the impasse be broken by action.”6
Into that cauldron of intense debate, deferred dreams, a stalled bureaucratic process, and doomsday predictions, eleven women agreed to be ordained without the official approval of their bishops. Their courage cannot be overstated. Of course they were ready and well-prepared. Their internal sense of call had been affirmed by others in the church. But the arguments against women’s ordination to the priesthood, as Pauli Murray reminds us, “carried the force of a two-thousand year tribal taboo that was deeply embedded in the psyche.” so much so that when she took the train from New York City to Philadelphia to attend the ordination, Murray was terrified. “My panic was so great that I might have left the train in Newark if I had not met two clergy-women of the United Church of Christ, whose obvious enthusiasm for the event calmed some of my fears.”7
She goes on:
In Philadelphia, we joined a throng of two thousand people from many parts of the country, who crowded into the Church of the Advocate. None of us knew what to expect, although there were rumors that dissidents might try to disrupt the proceedings. . . a few male priests fairly screamed their objections. Their hysterical outburst was received calmly, and when they had left the church the ceremony continued with customary beauty and solemnity. By the end of the service the joyous spirit that enveloped the congregation swept away all my doubts as to the rightness of the action taken that day. My most cherished memory is kneeling before the newly priested Jeannet Piccard to receive her blessing.8
It was, by all accounts, a glimpse of a new heaven and a new earth.
But the struggle was far from over. Every conceivable effort was made to discredit the women, invalidate their ordination, and censure the men who presided at it and the subsequent rectors who invited the women priests to preside at Eucharist. Resistance was so strong that many believe that had another ordination of four women not taken place in Washington, DC in 1975, momentum would not have shifted toward an affirmative vote at the General Convention the following year.
Bishop William Creighton of Washington, DC, a supporter of women’s ordination, nonetheless tried to stop the ordination of the Washington Four, and he censured the rector of St. Stephen’s and the Incarnation when Alison Cheek celebrated Eucharist there. But in the spring of 1976, Creighton shifted his position and publicly stated that no matter the vote at the Convention later that year, he would begin to ordain women.
Turns out, it was a matter of interpretation after all.
Back to the significance of this anniversary: There is something particularly poignant about the span of fifty years. Enough time has passed for us to see a given moment within a larger arc of history. The arguments against the ordination of women seem almost laughable now, and we would laugh were they not so strongly held and hurtful to so many.
Many who were at the center of the story fifty years ago are gone now, though many are still here, who were young in those years. With the passage of time, some are freer to tell their stories than they were as they were living them, or maybe we are more open to listening. Some were passionate with a vision of what could be, determined to find a way; others weren’t quite sure of what was happening, only that it was really big and life-changing and more than a little frightening. Still others resisted the change actively or passively, only to wake up years later to realize their views had changed. Before long, some of the most resistant forget how hard they fought against what they have now come to accept as normative. Hearing them talk, honestly, you’d think the change had been their idea all along.
But there is no room for judgment tonight. For in fifty years’ time who knows how we will be perceived on the arcs of change that we find ourselves on now?
So what are we to carry with us going forward? In closing, I offer these thoughts:
First: Things that once seemed impossible are impossible, until they’re not. Looking back, the change seems inevitable, but those who lived through it know better. It took every ounce of courage and strength to break through, and the cost was immeasurably high. Tonight we give thanks for those who paid the price for what we are blessed to take as a given. But I wonder, what seemingly impossible tasks are you and I called to work for now, at great sacrifice, on behalf of future generations?
Second: On the arc of any longed-for change, we don’t always know, nor can we choose, where we find ourselves within the more limited arc of our lives. But what we can choose is to occupy our space with as much intention, integrity and faithfulness as we have within us, to do our part with humility and grace. Not everyone is on center stage. The sacrifice of those who go first must be followed by the willingness of others to go second, and third, and fourth, until momentum shifts in favor of the new. This kind of change is the work of many generations, as the first women who petitioned to be seated at the General Convention in 1934 would tell us if they could.
Third: We’d be made of stone if we didn’t get discouraged or even lose heart along the way. So let me say a word about the inevitable disappointment we feel when the wheels of change grind to a halt, or even worse, after the hard-won moment when something big shifts and we glimpse for a moment the world as surely God intends. For even then, it turns out that we’re all still human; the church is still the church in all its stubborn imperfection and sin; as is the world in which we live. Some of the most poignant letters I’ve received in the last year were written by those who fought hard for women’s ordination because they longed for something greater that, in their estimation, had yet to come to pass.
Beyond one mountain, as the Haitians remind us, lies another mountain.
That’s when we realize that we’re not in charge of the universe, or the church, after all. And did I mention that we’re all still human?
Fourth and finally: As Alla’s words reminded us at the beginning of my sermon, our story doesn’t begin with us, and it doesn’t end with us, either. We are part of a living faith that spans generations of time. Our story begins and ends with Jesus, and the loving, life-giving, affirming God he came to embody, and whose Spirit lives within and among us still. In the brief span of time that is ours to live, we are the ones to persevere in faith, hope and love, walking humbly with our God on the path of justice.
Thankful for those whose courage we celebrate tonight, may we carry on, trusting in the God who created us all in divine image, and longs for us to be all that we can be—not for ourselves alone, but in love for those who will be here fifty years from now.
Amen.
1Alla Renée Bozarth-Campbell, Womanpriest: A Personal Odyssey (San Diego: LuraMedia, 1988) 83-4.
2Paula Lawrence-Wehmiller, The Love Loaf: An Ordination Story, June 30, 2019.
3Director Margo Gursey’s Statement
4Pauli Murray, Song in a Weary Throat, (New York: W. Norton & Company, 1987), 561-2.
5Bozarth-Campbell, 92.
6Ibid, 93.
7Murray, 562.
8Ibid, 563
by Bishop Mariann | Jul 17, 2024
In the year that King Uzziah died, I saw the Lord . . Isaiah 6:1
Rejoice in the Lord always. Philipiians 4:4
Jesus said to his disciples, ‘The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few; therefore ask the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into his harvest.’ Matthew 9:38
It is good for us to be here, in this sacred space, with one another; good to be here in this moment, confident that God the Father, through Jesus Christ the Son, will pour the Holy Spirit upon Aaron Robert Dunn and Mary Caitlin Frazier and make them priests in the church.
It’s because of you, Caitlin and Aaron, that we are here, because of your faithfulness on a long journey of discernment, education and spiritual formation that has brought you here.
Canon Robert Philips and I spent time with Aaron and Caitlin yesterday afternoon. It allowed us the opportunity to say privately what I would like to say publicly–that it has been an honor to walk alongside these two servants of God on their path toward ordination. Let me also take this opportunity to thank you, their family, teachers, mentors, classmates, and all who have been guides and companions on the way. No one walks this road alone.
Finally, may we all give thanks and praise to God, the source of all life and who is love; to our Lord Jesus, whose living presence is the greatest of mysteries and greatest of gifts, who calls us each by name, and to the Holy Spirit who inspires and sustains us all.
We are not here to build a sacramental monument to your priesthood, but rather, in humility and praise, to create a space in which the Spirit might bring to fruition all that has been at work in you until now. We are here to give thanks to the One who calls us all in ways both ambiguous and clear, in moments that are sealed in our memory forever and through those long stretches where nothing seems to be happening at all. We are here to open ourselves as best we can to a holy presence that touches us in the places of our greatest need and vulnerabilities, and amplifies our giftedness, this One to whom our hearts are open and from whom no secrets our hid, who works in and through us, accomplishing far more than we could ask for or imagine.
One of the questions that the Rev. Anne-Marie Jeffery, our Canon for Congregational Vitality, often poses at the beginning of a vestry meeting or other church gathering is this: “Where and when did you first meet Jesus? Or asked another way, “When did you become conscious of his presence?” The answers, even among life-long Episcopalians, can be remarkably specific, not unlike Isaiah’ description of what was surely one of the most transformative experiences of his life that happened, as we heard, in the year King Uzziah died. That was when Isaiah saw the Lord, when he was lifted into the presence of holiness, and felt his sinfulness forgiven. In the year that King Uzziah died, he heard the call. In the year that King Uzziah died, Isaiah said yes.
Uzziah’s death is now forever linked in our memory of Isaiah’s his encounter with holiness, an experience so powerful, intimate and healing that it forever marked him, and gave him the courage to answer the Lord’s call.
We all have such moments. For those of us called to follow Jesus, they are our mystical encounters with the living Christ; for all human beings, those moments come when we sensed a call, a summons, that was uniquely ours to answer. As we think of them and give voice to them, the details become important. Was it a moment associated with loss or with joy, or both? Was it during a time of relative peace and well-being, or of hardship and anxiety? Was the marking moment a private one, known only to a few others, or associated with an event of national or global significance?
It’s important to linger here tonight, on such moments. They are part of the gospel of our lives. As Archbishop Oscar Romero is believed to have said to the priests of war-torn El Salvador, I say to you, “Your life may be the only gospel some people will ever know.” And as regards your priesthood, let me be so bold to suggest that the most interesting thing about you isn’t you at all (as wonderful and interesting as you are), but who Jesus is to you and for you and with you. What have you known of the healing, merciful presence of the Risen Christ?
One thing that such an experience of holiness does is plant us right where we are. “Here am I,” Isaiah said. I’m here. I’m right here. Only then could he answer the call to be sent somewhere else by God, when he knew where he was at that moment. And as it turned out, God didn’t send Isaiah very far. He was to proclaim God’s prophetic word right where he was.
On the spiritual significance of being here the author Brian McLaren writes this:
Here is the simple word by which we show up, respond to the one calling our name. Here is the way we name where we are—pleasant or unpleasant, desired or not—and declare ourselves present to God’s presence….
The simple word here places us out in the woods, so to speak, calling out so that we can be found by the one seeking us: “Here I am, in the presence of a mystery. Here I am, in the presence of a Presence who transcends, surpasses, overflows, and exceeds every attempt at definition, description, and even conception.
He goes on:
This kind of awakening begins the transformation of a religious life into a spiritual life, a life with God—not later and elsewhere, but here and now. How much higher and wider and deeper and richer our lives become when we awaken to the presence of the real, wild, mysterious, living God…. We begin to live with a perpetual Here I am, and here you are, in our hearts, inviting constant, vital connection, unbroken communion, lifelong friendship—starting right here, starting right now.
It all sounds so wonderful. And yet.
I don’t know about you, but there are times when, quite frankly, I struggle to be where I am. Memories of the past; longings for the future; the rough edges of emptiness in relationship; the inadequacies of my prayer life, that surely I can improve by buying another book about prayer; on and on, all that conspires to keep me from being right where I am, with Jesus and with you.
But then, by the grace of God, something happens to bring me back. And I realize, in the words of the Benedictine Joan Chittister, “that Holiness is in the Here and Now.” The British priest, Sam Wells points out in one of his books, the first question God asks Adam in the Garden of Eden is “Where are you?” Where, indeed.
By now, you might be wondering why I’m going on like this, as if being here was something Cailtin and Aaron are struggling with. Let me assure you that they are very happy to be right where they are. In fact, throughout their entire journey, both Aaron and Caitlin have made it quite clear that they not only felt God’s call to the priesthood, but that they felt called to be here, among us. Time and again, they went the extra mile to be present, to help, to befriend, support and care.
Two rather remarkable examples of this: while in seminary and during the summer, (and before settling into St. George’s DC) , Aaron took it upon himself to worship in nearly every congregation in the Diocese of Washington. What’s more, he kept a spreadsheet! When he happened to mention that to me in one of his Ember Day letters, I immediately invited him to meet with me and others on the diocesan staff to share what he learned as a visitor in worship. I have yet to find a congregation of this diocese that doesn’t believe itself to be warm and welcoming to visitors, but how many of them are, really, if the visitor doesn’t happen to be a bishop? And is being welcoming, however we define that term, sufficiently compelling enough for those few who dare to venture through our church doors to feel inspired to return? Aaron went so far as to rank the top 10-15 of his congregational experiences—the ones he would gladly go back to. Wouldn’t you like to know which ones they are? The answers may surprise you. They did me.
As for Caitlin, during the summer when she moved back from Austin to finish her seminary studies at VTS, she offered to preach for rectors in the diocese that wanted a Sunday off. Not surprisingly, a good number took her up on her offer, all across the diocese, and she, too, learned a lot about us by showing up and offering to help.
Moreover, in their seminary years they were fully present to their lives, which on more than one occasion was not easy. They sought learning experiences that challenged them to grow. In the long stretches when the path before them was anything but clear, they remained patient and persevering. They asked for help when they needed it, but never once did they complain–at least not to their bishop.
They are truly glad to be here, to roll up their sleeves and join you as another laborer in God’s vineyard.
But you know, sometimes when we are given precisely what we have hoped or prayed for, that the struggle to be fully present sneaks up on us. I’m not sure why–perhaps because nothing is as ideal as what we first imagined it to be; or because we aren’t as ideal as we hoped ourselves to be; or maybe it’s because the air conditioning doesn’t work in the middle of a heat wave, or the rhythms of work that we assumed would be one way turn out to be something else entirely. Or maybe it’s because of an article that we’ve read about the future of the Church, or the country, or the planet, for that matter, really worries us. Who knows.
It happens all the time. We get knocked out of presence into the amorphous land of longing or anxiety or dissatisfaction with the ways things are. It happens.
When it happens to you, and it will, that’s what you must bring God in prayer, and to ask for the grace to be where you are, with joy and strength sufficient for the day. As the Apostle Paul writes, you can make our requests known to God. You can ask for the peace surpassing human understanding, and for sustaining confidence that God has called you, even when you’re barely holding on.
In closing, let me say a final word to you about the future of the Episcopal Church, which was certainly on the minds of a lot of us at the General Convention this summer, and is something that we all do well to consider given the stubborn trends of institutional decline that can seem stronger than all our efforts to create joyful, purposeful congregations through which to serve God’s mission in our world.
I came into my episcopate thirteen years ago fully persuaded that I was called to do all in my power to promote the spiritual renewal and structural transformation of the Episcopal Church. I am still so persuaded. And I have been humbled by how challenging the work can be. I’ve also been inspired by the people with whom I am blessed to work in this particular corner of Christ’s vineyard. I never expected this ministry to be easy, and it hasn’t been, but it’s also truly wonderful. I am grateful, as the Prayer Book says, whenever God leads to accomplishments that satisfy and delight us, and for those disappointments and failures that lead us to acknowledge our dependence on God alone.
But this I know: the clergy who lead whole-heartedly, who learn from their mistakes and keep going; who love the people in the congregations and forgive them for being human, and who learn to ask for forgiveness themselves; the clergy who know when to ask for help and who strive to learn and grow; those who love Christ and this Church, and inspire their people to be a blessing to others, and whose personal relationship with God in Christ sustains their joy–they are the ones, alongside the amazing leaders with whom they minister, with whom Christ is transforming his Church. I see it every day.
You are now joining their ranks. You needn’t be perfect. If my life is any example, you will surely fall and fail often, and it will hurt every time. But if you learn what you need to learn and keep showing up, not only will you be a humbler and wiser human being, you will be among those blessed saints that future Christians of our church will remember.
In the meantime, may you find your joy here, where you are, right now. You are called to the work of priesthood. Rejoice in that work. And know that we are rejoicing alongside you.
Amen.
by Keely Thrall | Jun 12, 2024
By the Grace of God and the people consenting
The Right Reverend Mariann Edgar Budde
Bishop of Washington
will ordain
to the Sacred Order of Priests
in Christ’s One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church
Aaron Robert Dunn
Mary Caitlin Frazier
on Thursday, July 18, 2024
7:00 p.m.
at the
Cathedral Church of St. Peter and St. Paul
3101 Wisconsin Avenue, NW
Washington, District of Columbia
by Bishop Mariann | Jan 19, 2023
The word of the Lord came to me saying, “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you; I appointed you a prophet to the nations.”
Jeremiah 4:1
I am among you as one who serves.
Luke 22:27
On behalf of all gathered in this beautiful Cathedral, and those worshiping with us via livestream, let me say to you, the six to be ordained, that it is a privilege to be here. We are blessed to have walked with you on your path toward ordained ministry.
Each of you has unique gifts of spiritual insight and exuberance, a joy for life, and compassion born of the particular suffering that has marked you. As Rachel Naomi Remen reminds us all, “It is the wisdom gained from our wounds and from our experience of suffering that makes us able to heal. . . Expertise cures, but wounded people can best be healed by other wounded people. For the healing of suffering is compassion, not expertise.”1
I’d like to speak to you tonight about the inner terrain of “the called life.” It isn’t, of course, a life unique to the ordained. Indeed, the Old Testament scholar Walter Brueggemann argues that the great hersey of our time is the notion that it’s possible, even desirable to live an uncalled life, with no other reference point than itself.2
You are blessed to know both the gift and the cost of a called life, a summoned life, which is the God-given potential for every human being. Everything I have to say you already know, but I pray it’s helpful to hear these truths as we give thanks for this particular claim God has placed in our heart.
The overriding characteristic of the inner terrain of a called life is gratitude, even amid struggle. Now I know, as do you, that in Scripture many of those called by God to a particular task respond with protest, a recitation of all the reasons they couldn’t possibly do or be what God is asking of them. And that is a common response to those who sense a call to God toward ordination. But as Hamlet’s mother said watching an actor overplay her lines, “They protesteth too much, methinks.” For when the reality sinks in, that God has, in fact, called you to step up, to say yes, to do the thing you felt you could not do, or even more amazingly, to do the thing you always wanted to do but never dreamed possible, while there is certainly a gulp factor and considerable hardship ahead, there is also profound gratitude for the life that is ours to claim and to live.
Again, this isn’t an experience reserved only for the ordained, nor is being called always, or even usually, tied to one’s job. For example, part of the call on my life right now is to care for my 91-year old mother. It’s not in my job description and it wasn’t my plan, but her well-being is a claim on my life. God has been very clear about that with me. Caring for her is but one of the reference points beyond myself to which I have been called. Yes, there are times when it’s hard and inconvenient, but it’s also a gift for which I pray to receive with gratitude.
You are called to ordained ministry, and not because of how marvelous you are, although as the poem I asked you to read earlier this evening declares, “you are more marvelous in your simple wish to find a way than the gilded roofs of any destination you could reach.”3 Your marvelousness is true about you, but so is everything else–the whole catastrophe of your existence. All of you is swept up into this call. That’s the amazing part, that the One for whom all hearts are open, all desires known, and from whom no secrets are hid has called you and called me. How could we respond with anything but gratitude?
It’s essential for us not only to feel but practice gratitude, because another dimension of its inner terrain is heartache.
Being called will break your heart. You know this. There’s no avoiding it. First of all, you can count on making a lot of mistakes, some of them quite spectacular. You will break your own heart in the ways that you fail. Moreover, the world and the church is filled with other human beings–imperfect, broken, sinful human beings, just like you. They’ll break your heart, too. To complicate things further, no matter where your vocational path takes you, this is a challenging time to be a Christian leader, and the challenges in the Episcopal Church are real.
I suppose it’s helpful to know in advance that your heart will be broken, but advance knowledge doesn’t really buffer the impact when it happens. That’s one reason why we all need support systems, to help us get through the heartbreaking times. There is no shame in asking for help. Nor is a broken heart the end of the world. As I said earlier, your broken heart will help heal other broken hearts.
That points to yet another dimension of the inner terrain call, and that is the need to cultivate resilience, and persistence, or what some in leadership circles are referring to nowadays as “grit.”
For at the heart of this call is leadership, servant leadership to be sure, but leadership nonetheless. We are called to lead people, be it another person or family, or a congregation, student body, or an entire community from wherever they are now to the place God beckons. Incidentally, the hardest person to lead, it’s been said, is yourself, and that’s part of the call, too–to listen to how and where God is beckoning you and then to move, as best you can, toward that horizon.
Resistance to leadership is to be expected, both internally and from others. As a result, those of us called to lead have no choice but to live and move and have our being in what has been aptly described as “the messy middle,” that place where nothing is clear, where what you thought was a God-inspired idea goes nowhere, where those who called you to lead them are now resisting you with everything they’ve got, and it occurs to you that working as a barista in your neighborhood coffee shop seems like a more fruitful place for ministry than the church.
The last dimension of the inner terrain of this call I’ll mention today is the capacity to dream. This is the gift of hope. Hope initially expresses itself in a vision for what the world could be, what the church could be, and a deep desire in us to get to that hopeful place. I often tease clergy when they describe the church they would like to serve: you know, that healthy, multicultural congregation, with enough resources to afford a staff, isn’t burdened by the weight and responsibilities of its building, and with lots of kids. I say, sure, we all want that church. But perhaps your call and mine is to bring hope and vision for that kind of church into being, to start from where most of our churches are now and lead accordingly.
For without such a dream, where would we be? God places God-sized dreams in the hearts of leaders for a reason. They are to be cherished, cultivated, and worked toward, in full acceptance that the journey toward their fulfillment is long, and we may not see the fruits of our labor in our lifetimes.
Dreams are also for our best efforts. I know that you don’t expect this work to be easy. But not only is it worth giving your life to a God-given dream, you will find your greatest joy in its fulfillment, and even in failure. For as Marian Wright Edelman once said, “It’s better to fail in the work that matters than to succeed in the work that doesn’t.”
But when things get hard, promise me that you will ask for help. We aren’t meant to do this work alone.
In closing, I know that there is much to be said about living a balanced life, but as your bishop, I confess that I can’t speak to you about such a life from personal experience. I have never known balance, as much as I have been taught, and believe, about its importance. But I can speak to you of the joy, gratitude, heartbreak, necessary resilience, and dreams of a called life. I can speak to you of a relationship with Christ that is deeply personal and sustaining, even when, as St. Paul tells us over and over again, that the way of the cross is the way of lie.
Remember that the One who has brought you thus far will see you through to completion on the day of our Lord Jesus. And that everyone of us here is grateful that you said yes to the call.
1Rachel Naomi Remen, Kitchen Table Wisdom–Stories that Heal (Riverhead Books, 1996).
2Walter Brueggemann, Hopeful Imagination: Voices in Exile (Fortress Press, 1996).
3“Santiago,” by David Whyte. Pilgrim @2012 Many Rivers Press.
by Allen Fitzpatrick | Dec 1, 2022
By the Grace of God and the people consenting
The Right Reverend Mariann Edgar Budde
Bishop of Washington
will ordain
to the Sacred Order of Deacons
in Christ’s One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church
Yaa Asantewa Kiara Addison
Eva Elena Bogino
Lara Rhiannon Case
Katherine Elizabeth Miksa
Andrew Wingham Ogletree
Creamilda Shirley Wulck-Nortey Yoda
on Thursday, January 19, 2023
The Feast of Wilfstan, Bishop of Worcester, 1095
7:00 p.m.
at the
Cathedral Church of St. Peter and St. Paul
3101 Wisconsin Avenue, NW,
Washington, District of Columbia
Your prayers and presence are requested.
Clergy: Red Stoles
Watch the service online