Palm Sunday: What Holy Week Asks of Us All

by | Mar 25, 2024

Assist us mercifully with your help, O Lord God of our salvation, that we may enter with joy upon the contemplation of those mighty acts, whereby you have given us life and immortality; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Almighty and everliving God, in your tender love for the human race you sent your Son our Savior Jesus Christ to take upon him our nature, and to suffer death upon the cross, giving us the example of his great humility: Mercifully grant that we may walk in the way of his suffering, and also share in his resurrection; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.

When it was noon, darkness came over the whole land until three in the afternoon. At three o’clock Jesus cried out with a loud voice, ‘Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?’ which means, ‘My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?’ When some of the bystanders heard it, they said, ‘Listen, he is calling for Elijah.’ And someone ran, filled a sponge with sour wine, put it on a stick, and gave it to him to drink, saying, ‘Wait, let us see whether Elijah will come to take him down.’ Then Jesus gave a loud cry and breathed his last. And the curtain of the temple was torn in two, from top to bottom. Now when the centurion, who stood facing him, saw that in this way he breathed his last, he said, ‘Truly this man was God’s Son!’ Mark 15:33-39 

Good morning, friends and guests of Epiphany. What a gift to be with you as we embark on Holy Week. 

Each Sunday morning worship service in our tradition begins with a brief prayer, known as a collect, that serves to introduce a theme or an idea that runs through or lies beneath the Scripture readings for the day. Given the range of texts we have heard before us today, not surprisingly there are two such prayers: 

Assist us mercifully with your help, O Lord God of our salvation, that we may enter with joy upon the contemplation of those mighty acts, whereby you have given us life and immortality. 

And 

Almighty and everliving God, in your tender love for the human race you sent your Son our Savior Jesus Christ to take upon him our nature, and to suffer death upon the cross, giving us the example of his great humility: Mercifully grant that we may walk in the way of his suffering, and also share in his resurrection.  

Two seemingly contradictory requests: 

May we enter with joy. And walk in the way of Jesus’ suffering. 

At our staff meeting last Tuesday, Canon Anne-Marie Jeffrey read aloud the lengthy gospel narrative that Glenna and I just read to you now. She read with such intensity that her whole body shook. Sitting next to her, I could feel her energy, like electricity passing between us. As she read, I realized how far I am from the kind of suffering Jesus endured, the excruciating combination of intense physical suffering, public disgrace, and abandonment. It was a short step from that thought to a mental survey of similar suffering that human beings have experienced across the ages and are experiencing now.

We didn’t reflect on the reading afterwards, as is our custom. We simply shared the questions it evoked for us. Such as: 

What was it like to be so helpless about what was happening?

Why are humans so cruel to one another?

Why is cruelty exercised by every level of society?

Why does Jesus have to be so alone?

I didn’t have a question to offer. What could I say in response to a degree of suffering I had never known? 

That’s not to say I know nothing of suffering, for suffering is universal, as is grief. While none of us here may know human pain at its most extreme, we all know something of pain, and we are witnesses to others’ pain, both far and near. 

Perhaps one of the questions for us to ponder in Holy Week is this: how close are we willing to stand and how long are we able to gaze on the most intense suffering that some of our fellow human beings are experiencing right now at the hands of others of our fellow human beings? 

***

“What does Christianity have to say to the ones with their backs against the wall?” Howard Thurman famously asked back in 1949? 

And what do we say? 

A close friend, whose faith has always been an inspiration, said to me in the early stages of searing grief, “I am silent before God.” She had no words to describe her forsakenness.

If pressed, I’m sure that she could have said that intellectually she knew that God was present, and that she believed all the things that people like me would say (and she herself had said to others) about God not being the source of her suffering.

But in her hour of deepest pain, there were no words. As I stood with her, I, too, was at a loss for words. 

I wonder if silence is the first, necessary response before all suffering and grief, followed by gestures of humble compassion that convey our willingness to stay present with them in their pain, that see what has happened. If there’s a way to mitigate or soften some of that pain, we’re glad to do it, knowing as we do that we cannot take it away completely, or carry it for them. 

Anger is surely another necessary response at times–anger at what has happened, frustration as to why it happened, a demand to know who allowed it–whatever it is-to have happened. 

But in our anger or sadness, it’s important not to allow whatever we say or don’t say to become the main thing; in other words, that we not attempt to place ourselves in the middle of their story, as if it were about us. We are to stand alongside them, as witnesses and quiet companions. 

And where is joy in all this? 

Where indeed. 

The celebrations of Holy Week and Easter ask a lot of us emotionally, not only in their intensity, but in the range of human experience they bring to the fore, all compressed into one week. We began this morning with a procession of triumphal entry. The Palm Sunday services I remember as a child were filled with flowers–I think we even filled a cross made of meshed wire with our flowers, and of course, we had our palms. It was all great fun. 

But now, no sooner do we sit down in church after waving our palms in procession that we’re asked to consider Jesus’ cross, and there are no flowers. Just the story told, from beginning to end, of how it was that the man who entered Jerusalem in triumph would be dead by week’s end. 

Throughout the week, we linger on the events of each day. 

On Thursday we’ll commemorate Jesus’ final meal of solidarity with his disciples, filled with gestures of great love, and then join him in the garden of his agony and betrayal. 

Friday is unequivocally the darkest of days, as we remember Jesus’ trial, crucifixion death, and yet strangely we call this Friday “Good.” 

Then, in the emptiness and quiet of Saturday, we open the door for hope to emerge, first in darkness, then in the early morning light of Sunday’s dawn. And when we gather in church next week at this time–Easter Sunday–we will proclaim with anyone who joins us that Jesus is not dead, but alive in spirit and a living presence for all who seek him. We will be so bold as to say that the worst things that can happen to us, and that we do to one another, is never God’s final word for us. Thus Jesus’ rising from the dead is an occasion for joy even when–perhaps especially when–we have yet to rise from whatever death we are still experiencing or grieving.  

It’s a lot to hold, especially in one week. Love and betrayal. Triumph and failure. Confusion and grief. Joy and pain and joy again. 

How much can our hearts hold?  As it turns out, quite a lot. 

While the circumstances of our lives at the moment may not match the scale of intensity that Holy Week represents, I daresay we all know what it’s like when life asks us to hold strong competing emotions at the same time. Things can be both wonderful and terrible. Or when we’re in deep pain, someone we love may be celebrating; or conversely, we are the ones celebrating and someone we love is hurting. There can be beauty and horror on the same day. 

Michele Morgan is a priest in this diocese who entered seminary in the fall of 2001. She attended General Theological Seminary, located in the Chelsea neighborhood of Manhattan, two miles north of the World Trade Center. She told me recently that whenever she thinks back on the fateful day of September 11, the first thing that comes to mind is how beautiful the morning was–”a perfect fall day in New York.” It was warm; the sky was clear blue, and her day began in a new community forming around the highest of spiritual aspirations. By mid-morning, news of the towers falling had reached the seminary, and she was among those who dropped everything and moved toward the pain, to see how she could help.

I was Michele’s parish priest at the time, and we spoke on that surreal day. She sent an email for me to read at the hastily-scheduled prayer service at our church that night: In it she wrote:

I am safe and sound in New York.  It is more than a lot of people can say at this time.  I am humbled by the events today and I do not have that much of a response. Just to let you know I am about two miles north of the World Trade Center.  I am in a lovely part of the world and it is a beautiful day here.

We were in class and my cell phone kept going off, I did not answer it and I kept listening to and participating in a conversation about Resurrection and the idea of a “pure victim.”  We talked about the quality of mercy and how we live it and how we are called to it.  

Class ended early because the chapel bell started to ring at 10 am and it did not stop.  We went to church and found out what had happened.  I had a woman to one side of me whose husband was in the air flying to Baltimore, my friend Sean was working at the Corp of Engineers (2 blocks from the trade center), one of my classmates’ brother in law works at the 23rd floor of the Trade Center.  We prayed the Great Litany for them and for everyone else. 

After Chapel I tried to get through to the people I could to let them know that I was okay.  I seemed to have a phone that could get through so I was able to call a lot of families all over the country.  Thank God I kept my local Minneapolis area code.

I then tried to go down to St. Vincent’s to give blood. There were so many people that they sent us up to Roosevelt Hospital, there was thousands and thousands
of people in line to give blood.  There were many who could not give blood who were walking up and down the line giving us food so that we would be able to give.

It was truly amazing. 

I saw businessmen and women walking up ninth avenue covered head to toe in dust.  They looked like they had been through a volcano explosion.  There were women walking around with their high heels in their hands with cheap plastic shoes on their feet.  There was a man with a huge box giving people shoes so that they could walk home.  

The quality of mercy is alive and well in New York.  Keep praying for us and I will of course keep you in my prayers as well.

Peace, Michele 

There is calamitous suffering all around us now. Perhaps such suffering is engulfing you and your loved ones now. If that’s the case, I am very sorry, and I pray that in this holy season Jesus comes to you with great love, and that mercy surrounds you. Perhaps others of you, like me, are witnesses to suffering this Holy Week. If so, I pray that you and I are given the courage, as Michele was on that fateful  day, to move toward the pain, and not  look away, so that it may be said, in part because of us, that the quality of mercy is alive and well wherever the reality of resurrection seems very far away. 

Amen.