A Teaspoon of Hope

by | Oct 17, 2024

One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, said to him, ‘There is a boy here who has five barley loaves and two fish. But what are they among so many people?’
John 6:8-9

At the grocery store near my home people often stand by the entrance asking for financial assistance, or to solicit signatures or donations for a cause. I rarely stop to speak with them. Typically I go grocery shopping on my way home from work or after visiting my mother, with little energy left in me to engage with anyone.

This isn’t an example of what’s known as compassion fatigue. In my case, it’s simply fatigue. Everyone close to me knows what I’m like when I’m tired, and suffice to say, I’m not at my best. No one is, which is why we all need rhythms of rest and renewal.

Compassion fatigue, on the other hand, is an emotional condition caused by the unrelenting demands of caring for others in intense, highly stressful environments such as under-resourced healthcare settings and schools, disaster areas, and war zones. Compassion fatigue can lead to lethargy, depression, and substance abuse. It often includes what’s known as “secondary traumatic stress,” when caregivers become traumatized by continual exposure to the trauma of others.

Given the state of our world and the intense suffering of so many, those called upon to show up when floods come, bombs drop, food runs out, or bullets tear through human flesh are the unacknowledged heroes of our time. The toll on their bodies and souls is immense. Because so many contexts of suffering can go on for years, compassion fatigue is compounded by the sense that there is no end in sight.

If you are among the caregivers and responders to human suffering, or if you are among those dedicating your life to addressing the most intractable issues of our time, thank you. May the mercy and compassion of God sustain you, and may you give yourself permission to draw from the wells that replenish you, for you, too, need rest. Moreover, I remind myself and others who are not as proximate to suffering as you are of our responsibility to support you, and whenever possible, to join in your profound ministry of presence and care.

Yet rest isn’t the only thing we need to live a life of sustained compassion and proximity to suffering. We also need hope. “Hope,” Old Testament scholar Walter Brueggeman reminds us, “does not need to silence the rumblings of crisis to be hope.” In fact, the opposite is true. Hope is what gets us through the storm.

Our Jewish friends and neighbors have just finished celebrating their High Holy Days, or Days of Awe: Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, and Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement. A rabbi I greatly admire, Sharon Brous, founding rabbi of the IKAR synagogue in California and author of The Amen Effect, preached a sermon on Rosh Hashanah entitled “A Hope Born from the Depth of Sorrow.” She began with a somber recitation of the sorrow from this past year until her listeners surely wondered when the hopeful part would come. She acknowledged how tempting it is amid such pain to shut down. “What are we to do,” she asked, “when there are fires raging all around us?”

It was only then that Rabbi Brous spoke of hope, not as optimism or wishful thinking, but rather a fundamental orientation toward life, rooted in our God’s continual invitation to choose against despair. “Hope,” she said, “is not a feeling. It is a core value, and a spiritual practice. Hope must be practiced.”

Brous went on, speaking primarily to those who are not closest to the suffering we all decry, but those, like most of us, who are two or three steps removed, and wonder what we are to do. “It isn’t enough,” she said, “to gaze at others with admiration for their dedication. We must support and amplify their efforts.”

Nothing is more dispiriting to those most proximate to human suffering than to endure the indifference of others who could be helpful but choose to look the other way, or worse, offer cynical, poorly informed opinions from a safe distance.

Hope, however, and the willingness to lend a hand, donate resources, reach out with a word of encouragement, may be the best antidote for compassion fatigue. To know that other people see what’s happening and care enough to reach out and make an offering, no matter how small, establishes a lifeline to the wider human community. It helps those carrying the heaviest burdens not to feel so alone.

Brous concluded her sermon with a famous quote from the renowned Israeli author, Amos Oz, who in his lifetime was an ardent supporter of a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine. He, like Rabbi Sharon Brous, refused to accept that hatred and violence must always define the relationship between Israelis and Palestinians.

Oz was once asked, considering all that is broken in the world, what people should do. “There is, indeed, a great fire of hatred raging all around us,” he replied. “Our choices are these: We can run for our lives. We can write an angry letter (or in our day a social media post). Or we can pick up our bucket and pour water on the fire. If we don’t have a bucket, we can pick up our cup. If we don’t have a cup, we can pick up a teaspoon and pour a bit of water on the fire.”

Surely we all have a teaspoon’s worth of hope and love to offer this world, even when we’re tired. Sometimes we might even have a cup, and other times a bucket. Equally important, we can resist the temptation of cynicism, which serves as a convenient excuse for doing nothing.

I can’t promise that I’ll actively engage with every person standing outside our grocery store. But writing this, I resolve to do what I can to be present and kind, and from time to time, do for one person what I wish could do for many.

And I pray for Christ to show us all how to make our offering of hope, amplifying and supporting the efforts of those who are dedicating their lives to make a difference where human suffering is the greatest. Our small offerings, amplified by grace, may provide the needed lifeline to keep hope alive where it is most needed.