James and John, the sons of Zebedee, came forward to him and said to him, ‘Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask of you.’ And he said to them, ‘What is it you want me to do for you?’ And they said to him, ‘Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory.’ But Jesus said to them, ‘You do not know what you are asking. Are you able to drink the cup that I drink, or be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with?’ They replied, ‘We are able.’ Then Jesus said to them, ‘The cup that I drink you will drink; and with the baptism with which I am baptized, you will be baptized; but to sit at my right hand or at my left is not mine to grant, but it is for those for whom it has been prepared.’When the ten heard this, they began to be angry with James and John. So Jesus called them and said to them, ‘You know that among the Gentiles those whom they recognize as their rulers lord it over them, and their great ones are tyrants over them. But it is not so among you; but whoever wishes to become great among you must be your servant, and whoever wishes to be first among you must be slave of all. For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many.’
10:35-4
Anthony de Mello, a Jesuit priest from India, loved to tell a story about a woman, presumably on her deathbed, who suddenly had a feeling that she was being taken up to heaven to stand before the Seat of Judgment.
“Who are you?” a Voice asked. “I’m the wife of the mayor,” she replied.
“I did not ask whose wife you are, but who you are.”
“I am the mother of four children,” she said.
“I did not ask you whose mother you are, but who you are.”
I am a schoolteacher.”
“I didn’t ask you what your profession is, but who you are.”
And so it went. No matter what she replied, she did not seem to give a satisfactory answer to the question, “Who are you?” “I’m a Christian.” “I did not ask you your religion, but who you are.” “I’m the one who went to church every day and always helped the poor and needy.” “I did not ask you what you did but who you are.” She evidently failed the examination, for she was sent back to earth. When she recovered from her illness, she was determined to find out who she was. And that determination made all the difference in her life.1
There are some questions that last a lifetime, because our answers to them will evolve and change as we live. “Who am I?” is one of those questions. We answer it differently at ages 10, 15, 25, 50 and 80. The woman at heaven’s gate wasn’t wrong in any of her answers, only that she seemed ready to stop with each one of them.
The question of our identity isn’t one we answer once and are done with, but that we continue to ask throughout life.
Jesus was a master at asking questions that seem at first rather straightforward, but the more we live with the questions he asks, the deeper they take us. In a book entitled,
Jesus is the Question, author Martin Copenhaver went through the four gospel accounts of Jesus’ life and counted up all the questions that Jesus asked.
Any guesses as to how many?
307.
By contrast, according to Copenhaer, people asked Jesus 183 questions, and of those 183, he only directly answered 3 of them. More typically, he responded either by telling a story or by asking a question of his own.
Why do you suppose Jesus loved asking questions?
Questions open possibilities, prompt creative thinking, and give space for the Holy Spirit to move within us, especially when they can be answered on multiple levels.
Here are some of questions Jesus asked:
Once when Jesus was sharing a meal with a group of religious leaders known as the Pharisees, a woman barged into the room and began washing Jesus’ feet—a rather brazen thing to do. Even more so because the woman was known in the community as a sinner, for reasons we are not told. As you can imagine, the Pharisees were horrified and tried to push the woman away. Jesus stopped them, and he asked the Pharisees:
Do you see this woman?
On the surface it’s a straightforward question that could be answered yes or no. Obviously they saw her in the room. But Jesus was asking a deeper question: do you see her? Do you acknowledge her as a human being with God-given dignity and worth? As we ponder his question at that level, we’re invited to ask ourselves how we see each other, and those who barge into our lives unannounced or otherwise make us uncomfortable. Are they an intrusion? An inconvenience? Or do we see them for the child of God that they are? Is there anyone in your life that Jesus hopes that you will see for them for who they are? Does he want to see yourself with eyes of compassion and understanding?
Jesus also asked questions about love.
You remember the story of the lawyer who comes and asks Jesus what he needed to do to inherit eternal life. Jesus responds with a question in return, “What is written in the law of God? And how do you interpret it?” These were easy questions for the lawyer to answer, and he does, quoting the Jewish Scriptures: You shall love the Lord you God with all your heart, mind and strength; and love your neighbor as yourself.” Jesus says, “That’s correct. Do this and you shall live.” Then the lawyer presses him further, “And who is my neighbor?” How did Jesus answer him? With a story of a man who was beaten, robbed and left for dead on the side of the road. Two religious men came down that same road and deliberately avoided the wounded man. Finally, a man of a despised race came by, had compassion, and ensured the wounded man’s safety.
What does Jesus ask the lawyer then? Who do you suppose was the neighbor to the wounded man? This wasn’t what the lawyer had expected from his original question, “who is my neighbor?” Through the story Jesus invites the lawyer, and us by extension, to see others less in terms of who is worthy of our love as neighbors and more in terms of who we are as neighbors. “It was the man who showed compassion,” the lawyer answered his own original question. “Exactly,” Jesus replied, “Go and do likewise.”
Jesus asked questions about faith.
Once the disciples were in the middle of a large lake, caught in a raging storm. They were terrified; meanwhile, Jesus was asleep in the stern. They woke him up in a panic, begging him to do something and save them. After he calms the storm with the words “Be still,” he turned and asked his frightened and now amazed followers:
Why are you afraid? Why do you doubt? Where is your faith?
I have a lot of compassion for the disciples in the boat, for I would have been terrified, too, and there are many times when we all have good reason to be afraid. So hearing Jesus ask questions like “Why are you afraid?” is a bit jarring, especially if we hear him ask them in tones of exasperation or shame. But I like to imagine Jesus asking these questions in tones of encouragement, as if to say: You can trust me. I know that this is a hard and scary time. Why are you afraid? I’m here.
“Faith,” Copenhaver reminds us, “isn’t so much about believing certain things; it’s about putting our trust in someone.” Wherever you and I have good reason to be afraid, Jesus wants us to hear in the “why are you afraid?” his reassurance that we can trust him.
So let’s turn now to the question in the gospel passage for this morning, in which Jesus asks his two disciples, James and John, a question in response to a request that they made of him that makes me smile every time I read it: “Teacher, we want you to do whatever we ask you to.”
Ignoring the audacity of their request, and perhaps amused by it, Jesus asks them, “What do you want me to do for you?” They tell him that they want to be his favorites—they want to be the ones sitting closest to him when he comes into his glory.
Now I Imagine Jesus looking at James and John with compassion, for they have no idea what they are asking. He gently asks them, “Are you willing to endure what I must endure?” “Oh yes,” they reply, again having no clue what kind of suffering awaited Jesus in Jerusalem.
By this time the other disciples have gotten wind of what James and John are up to, and they aren’t happy about it. That’s when Jesus turns this moment of disciple rivalry into an important lesson for them and for us: If we want to be close to Jesus, we need to put others first. The greatest among you, he says, will be those who walk the earth as a servant.
I wonder, if you were in the place of the disciples, how would you answer his question?
What do you want Jesus to do for you?
Our answers reveal a lot about us. I know that my answers vary. Like the woman standing before the Judgment Seat, I have many answers to the same question.
Holding Jesus’ question in light of my life allows me to consider the deeper desires that reside beneath more surface ones. One of the leaders of the early Christian movement, St. Augustine wrote of what he called “ordered desires.” What he meant is that we all have many desires, but in a virtuous life, some of our wants take priority over others. We do well to ask ourselves in what order we place our many desires.
For example, I may want something badly enough to be willing to attain it in ways that compromise my integrity. I also want to be a person of integrity. Does my desire for integrity take priority over whatever it is that I want, or does what I want mean more to me, in a given moment, than my integrity?
Let me also acknowledge what we all know, that sometimes we don’t receive what we want, in life or in prayer. And many of our unfulfilled desires are good—some of the best, we would argue.
Years ago, a dear friend of mine was diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer. He had good medical care, but from the beginning the doctors told him that the survival rate for this cancer was low. How was he to pray? How was I, as his friend, to pray?
What did we want Jesus to do for him? To heal him of his cancer. To make it go away. To help his body respond to the treatment. To guide the doctors in his care.
But if a cure was not possible, which it wasn’t, he prayed for the strength to face the reality of his disease; to be fully present for his wife and daughter in that days he had left, knowing that he might not be there to see her graduate from college or walk her down the aisle if she married.
We’ve all faced our own trials, the thing we wished we could be spared, but are not, the suffering our loved ones have endured that we wish we could spare them. Through it all, Jesus still asks, “What do you want me to do for you?”
I invite you to live with Jesus’ question for the next week. Imagine asking, and genuinely wanting to tell him what you would like him to do for you and those you love. And allow yourself to answer the question on many levels—so that you can experience the range of your desires. Then ask yourself which desires take priority.
In my case, I confess, that certain desires keep coming back, no matter how often I pray. And I’ve learned to allow them to be what they are and keep praying. If that’s true for you, perhaps that will always be your first answer. But then think of the woman at heaven’s gate being asked the question again and again. Allow Jesus to ask you, what else do you want? And what else? See where your desires take you.
Then, you might turn the conversation around and ask Jesus if there is anything he wants you to do for him? Imagine that—the Savior of the world asking something from you and from me. What would he say, do you suppose? And how might we respond?
1Anthony de Mello, Taking Flight: A Book of Story Meditations (New York: Doubleday, 1998)
