When he came to Nazareth, where he had been brought up, he went to the synagogue on the sabbath day, as was his custom. He stood up to read, and the scroll of the prophet Isaiah was given to him. He unrolled the scroll and found the place where it was written:‘The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to bring good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind,to let the oppressed go free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favour.’ And he rolled up the scroll, gave it back to the attendant, and sat down. The eyes of all in the synagogue were fixed on him. Then he began to say to them, ‘Today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing.’
Luke 4:16-21
One of the most haunting passages of Scripture for me is found in the Book of Psalms.
In Psalm 50, the voice speaking to the people of ancient Israel is God:
Here, O my people, I will speak. I will testify against you. I am God, your God.
What follows is a lengthy description of ancient Israel’s sins. Then God says this:
These things you have done, and I kept still. And you thought I am like you. (Ps.50:21)
Foundational to the Christian faith, inherited from Judaism, is the conviction that all human beings bear the image of God, the Imago Dei. Yet from our origins as a church in this land and throughout our history—embedded in our institutions, reflected in our financial priorities, expressed in our religious art and ways of worship—is the assumption that white people are the human standard by which all other people are measured, which is the same as saying that white people bear the image of God more than anyone else.
For centuries, the assumption of white superiority was defended and taught by our white forebears as theological truth. How else could our white forebears reconcile enslavement of other human beings and subsequent expressions of racial prejudice with the Christian faith?
In Washington National Cathedral’s examination of its racial history, now found on our reparations website, the Rev. Dr. Kortright Davis, Professor of Theology at Howard University School of Divinity, calls this assumption the “sin of white arrogance.” “White supremacy may be a heresy,” he said, “but white arrogance is a lived-out theme.”1
We in the Episcopal Church have rejected the theological arguments that once supported white supremacy, but the persistence of white arrogance is still the lived experience of far too many Black and brown persons in this diocese. It is a source of continual pain and frustration, which at times erupts into anger. It’s also important to acknowledge that white arrogance is a contributing factor to white supremacy, even when we have consciously rejected supremacy’s most egregious expressions.
As your bishop, I begin tonight with an apology to all who have been on the receiving end of white arrogance in our church. White people are often unaware of how our words and behavior affect persons of color, but that’s no excuse for having a worldview that revolves entirely around our experience, taking little notice of yours.
In 1995, the Diocese of Washington celebrated its 100th anniversary. One of the projects of that year-long celebration was to collect congregational histories. Fifty-six congregations submitted stories from their past that were compiled into a single document entitled, People of the Promise.2 The individual histories were organized into sections according to the century in which our congregations were established.
Of course, every congregation wanted to tell the best parts of their stories. Don’t we all?
So it is that in the histories of the congregations established in the 1600 and 1700s, a time when Maryland’s economy was increasingly dependent upon the tobacco trade and the enslavement of African Americans was a way of life, the enslaved are not mentioned—not even in those whose church buildings had balconies, whose prominent lay leaders were enslavers, and whose clergy were charged with “Christianizing” the indigenous people and the enslaved. Reading the histories, it’s as if there were no Black or brown people in our midst during the 17th and 18th centuries.
Moving into the 19th century, the stories of our congregations acknowledge that the divisions which led to the Civil War were as present within our congregations as they were in the wider society, both in Maryland and the District of Columbia. They tell of Unionist rectors in congregations mostly sympathetic to the Confederacy or vice-versa; of almost equally divided congregations and families within congregations. But again, all from a white perspective—with almost no mention of Black people or the issue of slavery. Even in stories about the “colored missions” established after the Civil War, they are described as if the only role our Black members played was being on the receiving end of white beneficence.
The tone of writing shifts considerably when the histories get to the 20th century, mostly in expressions of pride that both Black and white Episcopalians now worship together, and in the courageous decisions to integrate Episcopal schools. There is acknowledgement of the contributions of Black Episcopalians, but scant mention of what was happening in the society at large, such as the systematic disenfranchisement of Black Americans (which happened as the foundation of this Cathedral was laid), or the rise of Jim Crow, the deliberate economic and racial realignment of Washington, DC and surrounding towns and suburbs, the razing of Black neighborhoods, white flight when Black families were allowed, at last, to choose where they lived, the fierce resistance throughout our diocese to integrated public neighborhoods and schools and diocesan meetings, and the courageous role that Black Episopalians played after both world wars to realize full self-determination, citizenship, and a rightful place in our church.
Invisibility is painful.
Tonight, as your bishop, I apologize for the ways Black and brown persons throughout our history have not been fully recognized by white Episcopalians as children of God. As a result, they were denied fundamental rights and told in countless ways that Black and brown persons were less important than white. I apologize for the ways we simply did not see you. Canon Rose Duncan, describing her experience growing up at St. George’s Episcopal Church, says, “White people lived in a parallel existence that functionally resulted in Black life and experience discounted or just invisible.” Our focus and preoccupation has almost always been on our experience as white people, at the expense of yours.
The 1995 histories were written with the best of intentions. The authors surely didn’t mean to delegitimize Black members of our congregations and communities, but the impact remains, rooted in the assumption that white experience is the main story, and all other stories are to be understood in relation to that experience. Those brief histories are representative of nearly all other published histories of our congregations until now—as if there was an unspoken agreement that the uglier side of racial realities were not to be discussed.
The racial silence is as true for our historically Black congregations as it is for our predominantly white, with few exceptions. Why is that, do you suppose, given what we know?
Many of our congregations are now re-examining their history through the lens of race, and taking into account the lives of our Black forebears. To be clear, we are not the first generation of Episcopalians in the Diocese of Washington seeking to repair our racial past and address continuing harms. We wouldn’t be having this service tonight if we were. There are stories and examples of great courage, and of financial investment and support. Our task is to build on our forebears’ effort and not assume that the work of repair is something of the past.
But have you ever wondered why there is so much about our racial past that we simply didn’t know?
Last September a group of us from the diocese attended a church-wide summit on reparations. Episcopalians from across the country doing this work gathered to compare experiences and share learnings.
In one of the small group sessions, we were asked to reflect on our personal histories through the lens of race. The group I was in had eight people, both Black and white. As we talked, we realized that we had something in common—we all experienced what we came to describe as the wall of silence. At one time or another, we all received a clear, though often unspoken, message that certain topics related to race were off limits. We don’t talk about race. For some of us, there wasn’t even an awareness of anything to discuss, until the subject was somehow broached and immediately shut down. Which, by the way, has been part of our collective experience as we broach the subject of reparations—a subject no-to-be-discussed. Why is that?
I’ve been thinking back to my training in family systems, and in particular, the power of secrets in a family or any relational system, like a church. In his book Generation to Generation Rabbi Edwin Friedman writes this about secrets:
Secrets divide a family as an avalanche would a community… Secrets distort perceptions. People become confused or misled by information they obtain because they are only seeing part of the picture… The most important effect of secrets in any system is that they exacerbate other pathological processes unrelated to the content of the secret, because secrets generally function to keep anxiety high… When secrets are revealed, despite the fact that members are at first upset, the anxiety level generally decreases. This is particularly the case if those in the system continue to work at the issues that then surface, issues that often had precipitated the forming of a secret.3
With that in mind, hear the Rev. Dr. Maria Kane’s account of how St. Paul’s Waldorf experienced the revealing of one its secrets:
Upon arriving at St. Paul’s, Waldorf in 2014, I quickly learned that the fastest way to stoke a fire was to ask about the former balcony. Like most parishes established in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, St. Paul’s balcony was, in fact, a gallery for the enslaved. After slavery, Jim Crow segregation continued the dehumanizing pattern of relegating black parishioners to second-tier seating.
The story of its demise in the 1950s is one for the ages. However, to have heard some long-time parishioners retell it, the balcony had nothing to do with racism and everything to do with “church growth.” To suggest otherwise, was to slander the memory and good will of beloved parishioners.
Between the time of my arrival and now, oral histories and the contextualization of the balcony’s existence in the larger narrative of America’s history and Episcopal Church culture have helped the congregation to counter the narrative of “church growth.” We’ve uncovered a thread of holy resistance connecting the resistance of the 1950s to the resistance of the church’s Civil War-era rector, who did what was otherwise unthinkable in Maryland’s tobacco-producing region at the time: preach abolition and pray for President Lincoln.
While some still balk at the mention of the “balcony,” our continued discussions are slowly rendering it from “that-which-we-won’t-name” to simply one of St. Paul’s many complicated yet ever-surprising, and—increasingly on occasion—inspiring chapters.
The Rev. Dr. Kane concludes with these words:
The stories that we all tell (or don’t tell) about the past determine how we live the Gospel in the present and future. Parish history projects aren’t an exercise in shaming or disremembering. They are an act of holy “re-membering” that is so deeply a part of all of us. They situate us in God’s larger narrative of sin… and repair and redemption.4
Likewise, this service is not an exercise in shaming or disremembering. But the stories we tell and don’t tell about our past determine how we live Christ’s gospel in the present and future.
I wonder if one of the reasons it’s so hard even to broach the subject of reparations is, in part, because our forebears suppressed the most painful truths about our past. White Americans, in general, want to forget the horrors of slavery and distance ourselves from them. Our Black ancestors had their own reasons, no doubt born in trauma and the desire to close the door on the painful parts of their lives. In the Episcopal Church, we’ve had a hard time acknowledging that some of our most esteemed and beloved members—whom we mention with pride in our parish histories—were also enslavers, and not just in Southern Maryland. Examples abound in nearly all of our pre-1864 parishes.
It’s painful to admit that many of the white clergy honored by plaques and portraits in our churches justified slavery with the weight of religious authority; and that as an institution, we benefited financially from stolen lives and stolen labor. The first Bishop of Maryland, Thomas John Claggett, whose body lies beneath us in St. Joseph’s Chapel, inherited upon his father’s death two enslaved persons. Their names were Clem and Harry. Bishop Claggett is honored throughout both the dioceses of Maryland and Washington. We know nothing about Clem and Harry.
Regardless of who was or was not an enslaver, enslavement was, for many of our forebears, seen as a way of life. As diocesan historian Franklin Robinson writes, “Enslavement of human beings was taken for granted, codified, baked into the way society and business functioned.” It was not only accepted—it was sanctioned by the church.
“Did people in our churches question it?” he asks. “Some did, but more than likely most simply saw it as the way things were. It was for them (in a phrase that should haunt us all) back of mind. It was not until the outbreak of the Civil War that it entered the forefront of everyone’s thinking,” he writes. Every white person’s thinking, we should add, for I daresay slavery was never back of mind for the enslaved.
“For the enslavers,” he writes, “freedom for the enslaved population would upend society, changing the way life was lived and the way society functioned.”5 Christian though they were, they resisted the change.
At the same time, among our forebears some had great concern—a preoccupation even—with saving the souls of the enslaved. How could that be, when there was little or no corresponding concern for their humanity? When laws had to be passed, making it clear that baptism was not a path to freedom?
As your bishop, I stand here to express deep remorse for our church’s active participation and acceptance of the slave economy that was the bedrock of this country and helped build our churches.
These things we did, and God kept still. And we thought God was like us.
I grieve the many ways our white forebears distorted the gospel of Jesus to conform to the horrors of slavery and amazed that Jesus’ spirit and the promise of freedom took hold among communities of the enslaved. As bishop of this diocese, I apologize.
And I’m grateful that Jesus was, for many, a source of hope and strength.
In her book, Black and Episcopalian: The Struggle for Inclusion, the Rev. Dr. Gayle Fisher-Stewart describes an aspect of African spirituality known as soulity, which enables Africans in America to transform negativity into something creative. “We just have to look to the music created out of the soul-stealing, back-breaking evil of slavery. The enslaved did not convert to Christianity,” she writes, “rather, they redeemed Christianity.”6 We owe our Black forebears, and our Black siblings in Christ, not only an apology, but a debt of thanks.
I’d like to speak now of another wall of silence, which brings us to the time when the United States Congress outlawed the Transatlantic slave trade in 1808. At the same time, the demand for enslaved labor was increasing dramatically in the lower southern states, due to the booming cotton and sugar industries. Thus was born the Domestic Slave Trade. Between 1810 and 1860, an estimated one million enslaved and captured freed Blacks were forcibly taken from states like Maryland and the District of Columbia and sold further south.
The District of Columbia was a major hub in the domestic slave trade. It would have been impossible for anyone living then not to see it. Human traffickers marched enslaved persons through the streets of Washington and on the roads of Maryland in chains, storing them like cargo in holding pens underneath homes and offices. Then the enslaved were forced to walk or were shipped to southern states to be auctioned off to the highest bidder.
Last fall, on a learning day for the diocesan staff, we took a racial pilgrimage through Washington, DC, guided by the Rev. Dr. Fisher-Stewart. It was a sobering day, as we stood on street corners not far from our downtown congregations, imagining those who walked by in chains. We stood outside buildings in which enslaved persons were held in dank basements. We tried to imagine the cries of mothers, fathers, and children as they were separated. We then crossed the Potomac into Alexandria and visited the Freedom House Museum, built on what’s left of a large complex dedicated to trafficking thousands of Black men, women, and children in our region from 1828–1861.
Given that many of our white forebears were enslavers, and that the slave economy was becoming less profitable here than in the Deep South, it’s likely that some sold their enslaved persons to a trader. There is no doubt that many of our congregations benefitted economically from the domestic slave trade. Cotton and sugar were major drivers of the US economy, enriching many.
As your bishop, I am haunted by our church’s participation, complicity, and tacit acceptance of the crimes committed against humanity throughout the domestic slave trade. It happened right here, in our towns and farming communities, and in the nation’s capital.
These things we did, and God kept still. And we thought God was like us.
I regret that we haven’t acknowledged the domestic slave trade as part of our story, as if somehow the domestic slave trade didn’t happen on our watch, or even if it did, it didn’t really pertain to us. I stand here tonight to express that sorrow and allow us all to consider the long-lasting impact of our part in those heinous crimes.
Then came the devastations of Civil War, fought by the Confederate side to preserve slavery as a way of life.
When the war was over and the rebuilding of the nation began, there were heroic efforts on the part of the formerly enslaved to find long separated family members, to pursue education, establish homes and communities, and build churches. Some white Episcopalians supported these efforts, financially and otherwise, but the message was always clear. Freedom from enslavement did not mean equality to whites.
Not surprisingly, then, after the Civil War the Episcopal Church was not the spiritual home of choice for most newly liberated Black Americans. Astonishingly, for some it was. They stayed, or later joined our church.
Since then theirs has been a long struggle for full inclusion and equity. Things were especially tough at the turn of the 20th century, when our Black forebears experienced the resurgence of segregation, codified in housing and education policies; the rise of lynching as a form of racial terrorism; inequalities in all realms of American life, and persisting assumptions of racial inferiority—all of which went largely unmentioned and unchallenged in our diocese until the Second World War.
This was a time of flourishing for many of our white congregations, and of establishing churches along the corridors of the wealth increasingly concentrated in neighborhoods and communities where Black persons (and others) were not allowed to live. Eventually, thank God, the housing codes were abolished, and Black families were free to live where they chose and could afford. Immigration also changed the demographic of the makeup of our diocese, and continues to do so to this day. But the economic and social impact of early and mid-twentieth century laws and practices are still manifest today.
Throughout the early and mid-twentieth century, the indignities that Black Episcopalians endured in this diocese are too many to count—let me leave with just one visual, symbolic of everything. Until 1944, Black Episcopalians attending diocesan conventions were not allowed to sit at lunch alongside white Episcopalians. They were told to bring their lunches from home and to eat outside. I give thanks for Bishop Angus Dunn, who in his first year as the 4th bishop of Washington ordered that Black and white Episcopalians eat together.
I apologize for the bishops who allowed such practices to stand.
These things we did, and God kept still. And we thought God was like us.
We have worked to dismantle some of the most heinous and ridiculous practices of racism in our diocese. But disparities remain in our church and the society in which we live. We know this. Some of those disparities can be traced back to the wealth accumulated during the era of enslavement and racially-biased policies of the post Reconstruction era, the entrenchment of segregation during the early 20th century, and the continued concentration of wealth in some of our communities and the lack of financial resources in others.
If there was any doubt about the money, consider this. In 2024, the Church Pension Group—which currently manages $17.5 billion in assets—examined the top donors that launched the fund in 1917. While the report found no direct ties to slavery, it nonetheless included that “wealth accumulation for much of the 19th century cannot be separated from the economics of enslavement,” and “the unprecedented wealth accumulated among the social elite during the period of industrialization that followed the American Civil War.”
What is true of the Church Pension Fund is true for the Diocese of Maryland, out of which the Diocese of Washington was formed at the end of the 19th century. The concentration of wealth and poverty in subsequent eras is reflected in the lived realities of diverse populations. The wealth gap has only grown in the church, and I am persuaded that there is a debt to repay.
If, when, and how we do our generation’s part in that repayment is for us to decide.
Several years ago a member of our diocese asked if I would be willing to preside and preach at a service of repentance for our diocese’s participation in the slave trade and subsequent forms of anti-Black racism from which our diocese benefitted financially. Would I, as bishop, be willing to stand before you and God and apologize? At the time, I said that, personally, I wasn’t equipped to do that yet, nor could it be a solo effort, but something we worked toward together.
A lot of work has been done, in individual parishes and as a diocese, thanks to those who have dedicated themselves to this task. It is not complete, but if we waited until we were completely equipped, I’m not sure that day would ever come. So we are here tonight to look back on some of the most painful truths of our past, acknowledge them, move toward repentance and amendment of life, so that we might be free.
The Committee on Diocesan Reparations recommends that we begin with a fund dedicated to repair harms done to our historic and predominantly Black congregations, as one step we can take toward creating a diocese of equity. It is a step of great humility, as we acknowledge that we, as Episcopalian Christians, were not separate from the harsh racial realities of our country. They are part of our story.
As we know in our personal lives, acknowledgement is the first step of true repentance. That is why I stand before you tonight—to acknowledge our historical legacy of harm.
Then repentance requires an expression of remorse, which we are here to make—not for the first or the last time, but for this time, our time, as we have learned so much more about our past.
As we also know from personal experience, for repentance to be more than empty words, there are steps that follow for restitution and repair. The word repentance means to turn around and live differently.
In the words of the Rev. Dr. Kelly Brown Douglas, “reparations is about repairing the breach created by an unjust past. And for us as a Church it is also about working to repair the breach between our unjust present and God’s just future. We are planting the seeds for a more just future.”
We can’t undo the past. But we can, with God’s grace, move toward a more equitable church together. Thank you for your part in this important step in the long journey we’ve been on. May we be granted the strength and courage to keep going.
Amen.
1Washington National Cathedral Racial History
2People of the Promise: Diocese of Washington, 1895-1995, edited by Adrianne Dale and Carolyn Miller.
3Edwin H. Friedman: Generation to Generation: Family Process and Church and Synagogue (New York: The Guilford Press, 1985), 52-54.
4Maria Kane, Parish Histories: The Stories We Tell
5Franklin A. Robinson, Jr. Bindeth Up Our Wounds
6Gayle Fisher-Stewart, Black and Episcopalian: The Struggle for Inclusion (Church Publishing Incorporated, 2022), 78.
