Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight and the sin that clings so closely, and let us run with perseverance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus the pioneer and perfecter of our faith, who for the sake of* the joy that was set before him endured the cross, disregarding its shame, and has taken his seat at the right hand of the throne of God.
Hebrews 12:1-2
Good morning. My heartfelt thanks to Dean Markham for inviting me to be part of this year’s alumni gathering, and to all at the seminary who have welcomed us so warmly. Being here with all of you means more than I can say.
Although I serve just across the Potomac River, I’m not on campus as often as I would like. As I’m sure is true for all alumni, being here brings back memories and evokes awe, as we see how the seminary has evolved—spiritually, programmatically, and architecturally. As bishop, I am especially grateful for the seminary’s commitment to nurture younger seminarians, to ease the financial burden for all students, and for the hybrid program at General Theological Seminary, which provides a transformative learning experience for aspiring clergy while they work full-time in their current vocations.
Everything I say to you today is in service to a simple idea: courage is contagious, which is to say, like every gift of the Holy Spirit, it is mysterious and it is communal.
We are inspired to do what feels impossible when we see or hear of another person being brave. Courage is one of the Spirit’s many gifts, working in and through us, accomplishing far more than we could ask for or imagine. Courage is also an innate, God-given attribute of our species, enabling us to take small brave steps, and sometimes enormous leaps. It is a capacity that we can cultivate and strengthen through practice.
I’d like to begin with a few examples of how this seminary and its leaders have given me courage over the years.
I began my studies here in the fall of 1984, though I didn’t graduate with my class. In between our middler and senior year, I went to Honduras, with my brand new husband and the seminary’s blessing, to work at El Hogar de Amor y Esperanza, a ministry of The Episcopal Church in Honduras for children living in extreme poverty.
I didn’t know that spending a year in Central America was possible as part of my seminary education. I had assumed at the time that choosing to attend seminary (I was 24 years old) meant relinquishing the earlier sense of call that I felt to serve amid those ravaged by war and poverty in Central American countries, or those who had fled from those lands and made the harrowing journey to the United States for fear of their lives. During my first semester, while I was attending morning chapel and introductory classes in biblical studies, the colleagues with whom I had worked for two years in Arizona were on trial for providing sanctuary to refugees who had crossed the border illegally.
I came to VTS assuming that God was asking me to leave all of that behind, in order to be ordained in The Episcopal Church. It felt like I had cut off a limb, and initially, I was miserable here—I felt trapped in suburbia with people I didn’t know, including a man from the South exactly my age who insisted on calling me ma’am. Where was I?
Two things happened in that first semester to persuade me that I needed to be here. The first was that I learned about a woman who attended VTS a few years before who had taken a year off to work at El Hogar in Honduras. It hadn’t occurred to me that you could do that. But someone before me did, and it felt like a horizon that I could keep in my sight in those disorienting first months, and that my past and future were not as disconnected as I had feared.
Her example opened a door for me that I didn’t know existed.
Who opened a door like that for you?
For whom is your very presence opening such a door?
Courage is contagious.
The other thing that happened in my first semester was that the personal wounds and grief of my young life that I had thus far successfully kept at bay hit me with full force. I tried to put up a good front, but inside, I was drowning, and I didn’t know what to do or how to talk about it.
That fall the seminary invited Dr. Ann Belford Ulanov, Professor of Psychology and Religion, to speak for the Zabriskie Lectures. Her presence was electrifying—an icon of inner strength and wisdom that pierced my heart. Her words, the recordings of which I listened to dozens of times, gave me courage to face my pain—and more than face it, but actually befriend it, and to imagine becoming large enough inside to hold the pain without being overwhelmed by it. She helped me name a truth that I had suspected, but didn’t know what to do with, which was that no matter how noble the causes to which I dedicated my life, if I didn’t tend to the wounds, inner contradictions and sins of my own life, I would, through immaturity and arrogance, risk contributing to the very societal problems I wanted to help solve.
The chasm between the person I wanted to be and knew myself to be was enormous. When I dared to first give voice to that terrifying truth, the Rev. Churchill Gibson, chaplain in those years, smiled and said, “You are going to love what’s waiting for you on the other side of the journey you’ve just begun.” His faith in God’s grace and belief in my ability to walk what felt like a path in the dark encouraged me to take the first step.
“The world is full of miracles,” writes the Swedish novelist Frederick Backman, “but none greater than how far a young person can be carried by someone else’s belief in them.”1
Courage is contagious, and so is faith. I was 24 then. I’m 65 now. Those of us who are elders have a tremendous responsibility to be a blessing to those coming up behind us, to find our joy in their becoming, particularly as our influence in the many spheres of life that once defined us begins to wane. In the latter years of our vocations, we have important work to do, but increasingly, that work is off to the side or from behind, as others take their places in the center and up front.
Who were the people who believed in you when you didn’t believe in yourself?
Who are you believing in, investing in now?
Two other occasions when this seminary offered what felt like a lifeline for me. In 2002, I experienced a very public disappointment in ministry. I had been the rector of St. John’s, Minneapolis for 10 years, and I was a candidate for Dean of St. Mark’s Cathedral, two miles down the road. It was a long process, at the end I was one of two finalists and everyone in town knew it.
I was the one not chosen—an experience surely known to many, if not all alumni present.
I would have gladly committed the rest of my vocational life to that Cathedral. The disappointment knocked me down, personally and emotionally, for over a year. It was a lonely grief—everyone in my world, my family and the congregation I served—was relieved. The Cathedral was thrilled with its new dean. The world moved on, and I was frozen.
During that time I received a letter from VTS, granting me an award and inviting me to come to campus to preach. I was glad to be anywhere but Minneapolis. One morning while I was here, Barney Hawkins met me for breakfast in the refectory. Sitting across the table in his blazer and bow tie, he sized me up in about five minutes and said, “I think what you need to do, right now, is enroll in the Doctor of Ministry program.” The thought had not occurred to me, but it was the first inkling of a new path. “Okay,” I said, not knowing what I was signing up for. The work I did as a result of that invitation was an early step on the road that, eight years later, would lead to my current vocation.
At crucible moments we hold faith and courage for one another sufficient to take a small faithful step on a dark road. We hold flashlights for one another and say, “Keep going. Wherever it is you’re going, you’ll get there.”
Who has held that light for you?
For whom are you holding a light now?
One more example from this past year. In the first few hours and days after I preached at the Service for the Nation in January, the initial response that came toward me, the Cathedral, and the diocesan office, was overwhelmingly negative. That would soon shift, and extraordinary expressions of gratitude and support would become equally overwhelming, and last far longer. In those first hours and days, however, we were overrun with messages of hateful condemnation. If you’ve lived through anything like it, you know that it’s like a huge ocean wave crashing over you, knocking you hard to the sand, and swirling you around. There’s nothing you can do until the wave recedes. In the midst of the wave, someone shared with me Dean Markham’s public statement of institutional support. I immediately felt as if I was standing on firmer ground, because Dean Markham was so clear in affirming my faithfulness to biblical truths, with the full institutional backing of the seminary. So that when asked, time and again, if I would apologize to the President, I could calmly say, “I cannot apologize for proclaiming the gospel.”
In times of societal chaos, institutional courage is important. Courage is not only contagious, it is communal, as is our faith.
One last VTS story: while I’m not often on campus, I was here just last week, to take part in the seminary’s commemoration of one of its most illustrious students: John Thomas Walker. John Walker was the first African American to graduate from VTS in 1954, the first African American teacher at St. Paul’s School in Concord, New Hampshire, the first African American canon of Washington National Cathedral and then bishop of the Diocese of Washington.
I live and work every day in the blessed shadow of Bishop Walker. Across our diocese, people speak of him as if he were in the next room—that’s how powerful his legacy is.
Bishop Nathan Baxter spoke at the commemoration last week, and he told a particularly powerful story about Bishop Walker. Back in 1985, Walker was a leading candidate for Presiding Bishop. I was sitting in front of Maria Walker, John’s wife, as Bishop Baxter began talking, and I heard her say softly, “He lost by ten votes.” Bishop Baxter told us that it was a voting block of retired bishops, mostly from the South, who prevented Walker’s election.
It was a devastating blow to his supporters, many of whom were present at that General Convention. Their anger and frustration was palpable, Bishop Baxter told us. It felt raw and volatile, and it threatened to shut down the work of the Convention. But then Bishop Walker met with his supporters. He told them that while he, too, was very disappointed, he still had important work to do in his home diocese, and so did they.
He said, “Don’t let disappointment keep you from doing what God has called you to do.”
I don’t know if that’s a word you need to hear right now, but I do. For me, it’s not only disappointment that I feel now, but grief.
These are challenging times in the Diocese of Washington. A large percentage of our people have lost their jobs, and many have seen their life’s work in public service dismantled and destroyed. Those in our immigrant congregations are terrified, and nearly every family has a story of someone being picked up by masked officers and sent to detention centers. Congregations that serve vulnerable populations, particularly the homeless and food insecure, are facing rising needs and diminishing resources. Only the rectors serving generously endowed congregations have any confidence that they will reach their financial goals for next year.
Into this reality, I hear Bp. Walker’s words. We can’t let disappointment and grief keep us from doing what God has called us to do. In times like this, it’s important to remember that previous generations endured similar and far greater trials, that we are surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses whose examples inspire us to persevere in courage and hope. Through them, Jesus himself comes to us, with his strength and courage.
What is it, do you suppose, about someone’s courage that inspires us to be brave?
I think it touches something deep within us, because, in that moment, they embody what we know to be true, or that we hope for, and they show us, by their example, that it is possible to live according to that truth. As I was preparing for that sermon in January, I read about a group of Roman Catholic bishops in California who took a strong stand in support of migrants in their communities. Their courage to say what I knew—what we all know to be true—that the vast majority of migrants and refugees are not dangerous criminals, but active, contributing members of our society—inspired me to do the same.
And really, that so basic a sermon—not unlike what I daresay all of you preach Sunday after Sunday—would be a source of hope for many and cause such anger for others, says far less about the sermon than where we are as a nation.
Yesterday David French spoke to us about the centrality of hatred between red and blue, and I daresay that we can all relate. I have been deeply influenced by the work of Tim Shriver, Arthur C. Brooks and others who speak of the same phenomenon as “the culture of contempt,” that is sustained by a very well-funded “Outrage Industrial Complex” that keeps us all outraged about one thing or another. Moreover, we feel completely justified in our contempt because those with whom we disagree are so reprehensible. I told my dinner companions last night of a gathering at Washington National Cathedral when Tim Shriver asked us to raise our hands if we have ever said that we hate hateful people.
A lot of us raised our hands before we realized the irony of such a statement.
The only antidote to contempt is a commitment to treat every person, no matter who they are or what they stand for, with dignity. Shriver and others have formulated something they call the “Dignity Index” which I encourage you to look up. It’s a continuum of speech, from the most contemptuous, which is One on the scale, to the speech with the greatest dignity, which is Eight. The inflection point is between numbers Four and Five—Four and below are statements of increasing contempt. Statements Five and above move us in the direction of dignity.
A Level Four statement mocks and attacks the other side’s background, beliefs, commitments, competence, or performance. The subtext is: We’re better than those people. They don’t really belong. They’re not one of us. A Level Five statement is open to the other side’s point of view and respectfully explains its own goals, views, and plans. The subtext is: The other side has a right to be here and a right to be heard. They belong here, too.
To give you a sense of the trajectory in either direction, a Level Three statement attacks the other side’s moral character, not just their capabilities or competence. We’re the good people and they’re the bad people. It’s us vs. them.
Level Six sees it as a welcome duty to work with the other side to find common ground and act on it. We always talk to the other side, searching for the values and interests we share.
One of the great learnings of spending time with the Dignity Index is what is known as the Mirror Effect. At first, it seems like a great tool to evaluate other people’s speech, and to point out their contemptuous language. Over time, what happens is that we begin to hear and evaluate our own speech and recognize how much we have internalized contemptuous speech. Once you’ve heard the difference between contempt and dignity as it comes out of your own mouth, you can’t unhear it. And it changes you and the ways you want to speak to others, no matter what they are saying.
Now I grant that it is really hard to meet the lowest expressions of contempt with dignity: Level Two accuses the other side not just of doing bad or being bad, but promoting evil. Those people are evil and they’re going to ruin everything if we let them. It’s us or them. Level One escalates from violent words to violent actions. They’re not even human. It’s our moral duty to destroy them before they destroy us.
But the premise of the Index is that the only antidote to contempt is dignity, just as the only antidote to hatred is love. Darkness cannot drive out darkness; Hatred cannot drive out hatred. Contempt cannot drive out contempt.
I’ve chosen to stay in the public arena, as best I can while still being faithful to my work as bishop, because the response to the sermon on January 21st suggests that the basic principles that inform our Christian witness have been experienced by many as water in the desert for parched souls. At this stage in my life and ministry, I see my role now is to strengthen and amplify the courageous Christian witness that is taking place all over this country.
By “our Christian witness,” let me be clear that I am speaking of the institutional expression of Christianity that is seemingly no match for the ascendant, politically powerful movement now referred to as Christian nationalism. We aren’t big players on the national stage very often. For all the grandeur of a few buildings and the trappings of endowed wealth, we in The Episcopal Church don’t have many big levers of influence to pull.
But we have what we have. We have who we are, and we have our understanding of what it means to follow Jesus in our time.
I accepted Dean Markham’s invitation out of deep gratitude to him and this seminary, and to assure you, my dear colleagues and rising leaders in our church, that your ministry matters—your words, your witness, your daily efforts to strengthen and sustain Christian communities that embody a generous orthodoxy and compelling witness to Jesus’ way of love.
I don’t consider myself an expert on the role of faith in public life, though I’ve been thinking a lot about it these days. I’m trying to be clear about our lane, what part of the work of reconciliation and repair is ours to do.
Yesterday, David French ended his lecture with a famous line from Tolkien’s Return of King when Sam and Frodo are near the end of their exhausting journey and things don’t look good. At the moment, Sam looks up and sees a star, peering out of the shadows, and he realizes, looking at that star, that “there is a light and high beauty beyond the Shadow’s reach.”
This I know: Jesus is our star. He is the light shining in darkness that the darkness cannot overcome. In our private and public lives we do our imperfect best to follow Him and his teachings, to create and strengthen communities and institutions committed to following Him.
In the words of the late sociologist of religion Rober Bellah:
“Our greatest contribution to the world as Christians is, by God’s grace, to try to be who we are.”2
Our vocation in this tumultuous time is to speak of what we know and testify to what we have seen, and to live, as best we can, according to the highest aspirations of humankind as revealed to us in Christ and the riches of our spiritual heritage.
It is to that vision of justice and lovingkindness to which Jesus calls us, and to a life understood as a humble walk with our God, in Jesus’ way of love.
Truth be told, we are known more for our failures than our fruitfulness in this walk. But that does not negate God’s call. Indeed, our failures continually remind us, in the words of the Apostle Paul, that
We do not proclaim ourselves; we proclaim Jesus Christ as Lord and ourselves as your slaves for Jesus’ sake.For it is the God who said, ‘Let light shine out of darkness’, who has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. But we have this treasure in clay jars, so that it may be made clear that this extraordinary power belongs to God and does not come from us.
2 Corinthians 4:5-7
We are all clay jars, holding a great treasure.
I also know this: we in The Episcopal Church have been entrusted with a religious worldview that seeks to promote the highest of human aspirations, what Jesus called the kingdom of heaven here on earth, and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. called the Beloved Community. At our best, our ministry stands as a compelling and comprehensive alternative to the ascendancy of Christian nationalism, and individualism’s isolationist, materialist tendencies and lack of moral vocabulary. We have many sins and limitations. We have shameful parts of our history, and indeed, our current reality that we need to own up to. We are not as strong, institutionally, as we need to be to fulfill the aspirations and high calling God has placed on our hearts.
But this is our time.
I would love not to be where we are, with all that we are facing, barreling toward a future that none of us want to leave to our children and grandchildren. But in another great line from the first book of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, when young Frodo laments that he wished the ring had never come to him. The wise wizard Gandolf solemnly replies, “So do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.” And a bit later Gandolf says something to give us courage: “There are other forces at work in this world, Frodo, besides the will of evil.”
What we know from the courageous ones of our spiritual heritage, we have potential to take enormous evolutionary leaps for the good. Our forebears have done the impossible in the past, and it is to that potential that God calls us—not on our strength alone, but through the strength of God that flows through us and the courage we hold and share with one another.
Our sacred texts are filled with stories of ordinary people called to do extraordinary things for which they are not equipped and prepared. What those stories give us courage to do is to offer what we have and who we are—our souls and bodies—when times are hard.
A story from the gospels that I’m thinking a lot about these days is of a time when Jesus was at prayer near the end of his life. It’s not the more familiar story of Jesus in the garden praying that, if possible, the cup of suffering pass him by. Rather in this version, Jesus is in Bethany, a small village outside of Jerusalem where he is preparing for his final entry into Jerusalem.
This is his prayer:
Now my soul is troubled. And what shall I say? Father, spare me from this hour? No, it is for this reason that I have come to his hour. Father, glorify your name.”
John 12:27-28
When we proclaim our Lord’s prayer as our own, we are, in essence, saying to God,
“We are here. It is for this hour we have come. No matter what happens, we are here. And we will do our best to embody your spirit in whatever way is needed.”
With this resolve, we aren’t asking God to change what cannot be changed; or only to give us strength to persevere in hope. Rather we are reassuring God, and one another, that we are not going anywhere.
We are the ones now. For this hour, we are here. Our greatest contribution to the world is, by God’s grace, to try to be who, as Christians, we are.
The courage we need flows through and among us. It is contagious; it is mysterious, and it is communal, as is our faith in the abiding, empowering presence of Christ.
1Frederick Backman, My Friends: A Novel. Atria Books: Simon & Schuster, Kindle Edition, 361.
2“Epiphany,” by Robert Bellah, found in The Robert Bellah Reader, Robert Bellah, Steven M. Tipton, editors (Durham, NC; Duke University Press, 2006), 509.
