In the name of the One on whose solid rock we stand, Amen.
Good morning.
Dean Carter, President Bowman, distinguished alumni, faculty, staff, student body, and friends of Morehouse College gathered today: thank you for welcoming me and my husband, Dr. Paul Budde, so warmly. Thank you for inviting me to stand among such an extraordinary gathering of clergy and scholars in this magnificent chapeI. I am always grateful to be in the presence of Bishop Robert Wright of the Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta, whose leadership is an inspiration. One of the finest priests of our diocese, the Rev. Vincent Harris is here—a Morehouse man. Canon Leonard Hamlin of Washington National Cathedral is being honored today. And at the president’s side is one of the most influential spiritual leaders of the Washington, DC region, the Rev. Dr. Delman Coates. I didn’t know that you were a Morehouse man, Dr. Coates, but I must say that I am not surprised.
In the last few weeks, I’ve been reading up on Morehouse College—your history, values, and work ethic–which confirmed what I knew from a distance: being a Morehouse Man is a tremendous privilege and responsibility. You are blessed to be part of an institution that invests in the intellectual and character development of its students and calls us all to be part of a global community of men and women who make the conscious choice every day to aim high. In the ethos of former President Benjamin Elijah Mays (whose biography I am reading now)
Failure is not a sin for a Morehouse Man, only low aim.1
Morehouse’s long-standing commitment to teach the history and culture of Black people is especially important now, as there is once again a systematic effort to erase as much of Black history as possible. I say “once again” because this is not new. I grew up in an environment and was taught in schools, including a high-ranking university, where I was an American history major, in which I learned almost nothing in class about the history and culture of Black people.
Then one fateful day, I decided to take a church history course at my university’s neighboring seminary, Colgate Rochester/Bexley Hall/Crozier Divinity School in Rochester, NY. As you know, after graduating from Morehouse in 1948, Martin Luther King, Jr., enrolled in Crozier Theological Seminary, which was then an independent institution. King was one of eleven Black students. At Crozier, he was introduced to the great pacifist thinkers of the early 20th century, and he deepened his understanding of the social gospel movement. He heard Mordechai Johnson, President of Howard University, preach on the teachings of Mahatma Gandhi, and he engaged the ascendant work of theologian Reinhold Niebuhr. Like his years at Morehouse, his Crozer education was formative for King’s intellectual and character development.
By the time I was in college in the early 1980s, Crozer had merged with three other seminaries and relocated to Rochester, NY. That’s where I attended a lecture by Dr. Kennith Smith, one of King’s professors, who had written a book entitled Search for the Beloved Community: The Thinking of Martin Luther. That lecture and book blew open my world. I spent the rest of the semester reading all I could about the Civil Rights era and listening to live recordings of King’s sermons. It was the beginning of a journey that I am still traveling.
For all my ignorance, I didn’t have a Pollyanna view of life or of this country before college. I grew up poor alongside affluence, and when I lived with my father, in an alcoholic home, all of which can distort a child’s self-understanding. I came to faith in Jesus as a teenager and for a few years attended a Baptist Church and then a non-denominational community, before finding my spiritual home alongside my mother in the Episcopal Church. As a teenager, I had a keen sense of injustice–not for me, but others who didn’t have the few lifelines that I did, including my mother, who first rescued herself and then me.
In college, I worshiped as a Roman Catholic and was transfixated by the witness of Roman Catholic clergy who were being slaughtered in Central America for their solidarity with the poor by weapons, sent by the United States to dictators in those lands. I then focused my studies on American imperial foreign policy–which in the late 19th and early 20th century was pretty brutal. Thus, I was among the many who grew up in the 1970s and 80s, skeptical of American mythology and distrusting much of what our government told us. But until I encountered King, I knew almost nothing about Black history and Black culture. And I knew that I wasn’t the only one who didn’t know.
My point in telling you this part of my personal story:
Never underestimate the power of a lecture or a book to change your life.
By age 21, I imagined myself as a social justice warrior, eager to fight for the oppressed in both our country and in Central America. Although personally I was a bit of a mess, I was ready to go into battle, or so I thought. Suffice to say that I had a lot more learning ahead, and the personal wounds and character flaws that I was doing my best to hide would eventually catch up to me.
There is, it turns out, no short cuts on the road to character. No matter how noble the causes we take up, if we don’t tend to ourselves, we risk, through our immaturity and arrogance, contributing to the very societal problems we wish to solve.
On the road to character, we invariably make mistakes, the consequences of which we, or others, may have to live with for a long time. (I speak from experience.) While mistakes are to be expected, it’s important that we own up to them rather than blame others, and make restitution wherever possible. As we do this, year in and year out, we grow in wisdom, stature, and humility. By the grace of God, we come to view some of our mistakes as among the best things that happened to us–not for the pain they caused, but for the kind of people we became as a result of the lessons we learned.
My second point that I hope you will remember from all that I say today:
The road to character is a lifelong journey.
Rest assured that the God who has brought you to this moment in your life is not finished with you, and Jesus is with us, as he promised, to the end of the age. Yet personal agency is real, and every decision we make today, large or small, in some way determines the person we will be when we wake up tomorrow.
I was invited to address you today, and to receive an award associated with three spiritual giants of the twentieth century is because of a sermon I preached on January 21st. To be associated with Ghandi, King, and Mandela is an honor and a responsibility that I will never forget.
And my third and most important point is this:
Moments like that sermon are not necessarily the most decisive moments of courage in a person’s life, even if that’s the moment that others will remember.
I’m not downplaying the sermon, any more than I would dare to minimize the last five minutes of King’s I Have a Dream speech on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial in 1963. But one sermon or speech is not consequential on its own. It is decisive only to the extent that it is linked to a life of integrity, faithfulness, and sacrificial love, and to communities and movements dedicated to a higher purpose.
To use a sports metaphor: one play, no matter how brilliant, doesn’t win the game. One player, no matter how gifted, cannot carry an entire team. One game, no matter how perfectly played, doesn’t determine a season.
Gandhi, King, and Mandela were among the most gifted men to walk this earth and the greatest leaders of the 20th century. What made them great was the men they became over time and the movements to which they belonged.
Some of their decisive moments of courage were on the public stage, for the world to see. Many were not. The same is true for us.
The title of my address is Decisive Moments of Courage.
Over the course of a lifetime, such moments come to us in a variety of ways. What they have in common is that they all involve a decision, a conscious choice that we make.
The choice is almost always the fruit of a period of inner struggle that culminates in some kind of crisis or turning point. These are the marking events that set us on a particular path, or compel us to change paths. They shape the people we become and determine the lasting contributions we make during our short time on this earth.
The first, and perhaps most dramatic moment, particularly in the first half of life, is when we feel summoned to leave one place or way of being ourselves and move toward another. This is the heroic journey that informs all great literature and film. In our psycho-social development, it is the work of self-differentiation, when we consciously step out on our own. Often, we hesitate in such moments, and those close to us actively discourage us from leaving. This is understandable, for going involves risk and separation from what is familiar, and our leaving affects other people, sometimes in costly ways. Yet in the call to go, we feel summoned to take the risk and pay the cost, in order to fulfill a destiny that lies beyond our sight.
My first conscious, decisive moment with lasting consequence happened when I was 17 years old. It is no exaggeration to say that I wouldn’t be with you today were it not for the choice I made then. The details aren’t important; I mention it to underscore the fact that some of our most decisive moments happen in adolescence and young adulthood. The other marking aspect of that particular decision was that it was the first time I can remember trusting a voice, an inner authority over against the external authority figures in my life, including religious leaders, who loved me and wanted me to stay where I was.
It was, for me, what the great theologian (and Morehouse Man) Howard Thurman described as “the sound of the ‘genuine.” Hearing the sound of the genuine, which I heard as the voice of God, was both terrifying and exhilarating.
No doubt Thurman’s words have been often quoted to you, but they are worth hearing again:
If you cannot hear the sound of the genuine within you, you will never find whatever it is for which you are searching, and if you hear it and then do not follow it, it is better that you had never been born . . . If you cannot hear the sound of the genuine in you, you will spend all your days on the ends of strings that somebody else pulls.2
Howard Thurman heard a decisive call to go in 1943, when he was in his 40s, that compelled him to leave the esteemed position as Dean of Andrew Rankin Memorial Chapel at Howard University. He went to San Francisco to help establish the first interracial church in the country. It was a decision that puzzled and worried those around him. Not surprisingly, Howard’s President pressed him to reconsider. Thurman was aware of the risks, both personal and financial, and the fact that in his world, this was a move of downward mobility. Nonetheless, it was his chance to create a church that he believed would be worthy of Jesus himself, something that he had been preparing for all his life.3
About his decision and the Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples, Thurman wrote:
The movement of the Spirit of God in the hearts of [people] often calls them to act against the spirit of their times or causes them to anticipate a spirit which is yet in the making. In a moment of dedication, they are given wisdom and courage to dare a deed that challenges and to kindle a hope that inspires.4
Nothing about Thurman’s decision to go or the years that followed were easy. He poured everything he had into the work, which was both satisfying and disappointing, fulfilling and frustrating. But he never doubted the call. It was in those years that Thurman published the spiritual essays that are still worthy of our daily meditation, and he wrote his most influential book, Jesus and the Disinherited. After ten years in San Francisco, he would heed the call to go again, this time to Boston University, a historically white institution. He left reluctantly, because his work at the church did not feel complete, but he went to Boston, persuaded that he would have a wider platform for his message of non-violent resistance. There, he would also mentor a rising generation of leaders, Black and White. including the young Martin King, who, upon graduating from Crozier, enrolled at Boston University to pursue a Ph.D.
Whether for the first or hundredth time, in choosing to go, like Thurman, we feel as if our lives matter. When we go in fear, we are given the courage to do what we think we cannot do. When we go in excitement, it’s as if we are preparing our whole lives for this moment. The call to go is often dramatic and almost always public. That the cost is high merely confirms the importance of the call.
Yet an equally consequential decisive moment is on the other end of the experiential spectrum. This is when the call, the summons, is, to our surprise, to stay where we are. Making that choice, particularly when there are compelling reasons to leave (not the least of which is our own desire) involves a similar inner struggle, a building sense of crisis, resulting in a decisive moment as clear as the decision to go.
That’s where the similarity ends. For in choosing to say, we aren’t going anywhere, and no one sees the courage, and the struggle that such a decision involves. We may feel a bit trapped, particularly when the call to stay follows a disappointing loss of an opportunity that we thought was ours. Yet choosing to stay can be as consequential as going, for staying allows for depth and stability, which are essential to maturity and the ability to make a lasting difference in the lives of other people.
There is almost always a sacrifice in staying. Think of those in your life who made something possible for you through their stability, and what they gave up so that they could be the ground from which you learned to fly. In every long-term commitment we make, there will be multiple inflection points when we have to decide whether or not to stay, and each time is a new decision and with it a clarified vocation.
Hear this: Choosing to stay doesn’t mean staying the same, but to go deeper where we are, in new and life-transforming ways.
My first memorable decision to stay came when I was in my 30s, which was when I realized how little I knew about stability and perseverance. But there I was, married, with two small children, ordained and working in a church—all aspects of my life that I loved on most days, yet it was a slower, more mundane life than I had anticipated. I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was missing out on real life somewhere else, a more important, significant, happier life that was happening without me. It took time for me to accept and embrace the life that was mine, and that the call was to stay where I was and go deep.
We are all the beneficiaries of those who made the crucible decision to stay where they were. My mother, as an immigrant with two young daughters, decided to stay in this country after my father abruptly left us. She did so despite tremendous pressure from her family, and knowing that hers would be a hard and lonely life, working full time, going back to school, and raising us alone in an era when being a divorcé was a scandal.
The gospel of John, chapter 6, tells of the time when Jesus’ teaching became increasingly controversial, and many who once hung on to his every word began to fall away. Even some of those closest to him no longer wanted to be part of his movement. “This is a difficult teaching,” they said, “who can accept it?” In a moment of sober assessment, Jesus turns to the twelve disciples of his innermost circle and asks, “Do you also wish to go away?” The poignancy of that question is haunting. At last Simon Peter, God bless him, speaks up: “Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words of eternal life.” They had come too far to turn back now. Their destinies were bound up in his.
Later this year, womanist theologian the Rev. Canon Kelly Brown Douglas is coming to Morehouse. Hers is a story that includes the decision to stay in the Church, and specifically the Episcopal Church that raised her, despite its long history of harm done to Black people by those who claim to follow Jesus. It’s her story to tell, which she does eloquently in the canon of her writing. The cost for her to stay is high. Nonetheless, Canon Douglas feels called to stay, in part, to honor her ancestors and their faith in Jesus’ liberation love. When her adult son asked why she stays, and why she doesn’t give up hope, she reminded him of his great-great-great-grandmother:
Every time I think about Mama Mary, I think of those Black people who were born into slavery, died in slavery, and never drew a free breath. In fact, they never dreamt that they would ever breathe a free breath. Yet, they fought for freedom anyhow…. When I think of them and their fight for freedom, I cannot give in to that which would destroy Black life.5
She stays a Christian because she believes that Jesus, as the incarnation of God in human life, continues to experience the realities of crucifixion in the lives of Black people, and that he feels the pain of it as if for the first time. Like the women of Jesus’ day, she stays with Jesus at the foot of that cross, and finds hope in his resurrection–the same hope that her forebears passed onto her. Her life is the fulfillment of her ancestors’ faith, which she feels called to carry forward, and work toward the realization of another generation’s liberation.
I feel the gift of Canon Douglas’ moral courage every day, one that doesn’t allow me to forget the wider implications of a faith that is not only personal, but collective. More than once, in response to a given societal outrage, she has called me to say, “Mariann, we have to do something. We have to say something.” At great cost to herself, she chooses to stay in a predominantly white church where leaders like me need her continued prodding. We in the Episcopal Church owe her more than words can convey, for the integrity of our witness is at stake.
Dr. Douglas was one of several of my conversation partners as I was preparing my sermon on January 21st. Suffice to say, she was one who held my feet to the fire.
Moral courage is communal and multi-generational.
Stepping back into personal narrative, I’d like to highlight another decisive moment, which to my surprise, first came to me in the long years of little drama, when I knew the call was to stay where I was. During that time, I heard another summons on the edges of my life, prompting me to begin taking small steps toward a vision for my future that would take years to realize, if at all. I wasn’t certain where those steps would lead; I only knew that it was time to start moving toward a possibility that would require more of me than I was or could do at that time. I needed to apprentice myself to others; learn new skills; navigate challenging relationships; and attend, once again, to matters of personal integrity.
No one noticed what I was doing, that I was slowly and consciously moving toward a distant horizon. At several decisive moments during those years, when I thought the time had come for some greater work, I was wrong. Doors that I had hoped would open remained firmly shut. I learned to pick myself back up, and keep going.
My inspiration during that long, lonely time was those in our history who had worked all their lives to realize a dream that they did not live to see fulfilled, the ones called to start a long journey that others would finish. Without them and their faithfulness to the vision God had given them, what others realized in future generations would not have been possible.
In all candor, that’s how I feel about my life now. There is nothing about this historical moment that I would have chosen, and the road ahead for any of us is anything but clear. Much is being dismantled and destroyed in our country, deliberately so, and there is no going back. Whatever lies ahead will be something new, and we don’t know how long this particular season of our history will last. The decisions we make now, and the seeds we plant for the future, lie within our control.
What is clear to me is that this is our time. This is our life. As the wizard Gandalf said to the young Hobbit, Frodo, in J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, “While we cannot choose the times we live in, we can choose to respond to the time we are given.”6 For now, I am staying where I am and taking small steps on a journey toward a better future for all, whether or not I live to see it–not for my sake, but for those who are coming up behind me. And as a follower of Jesus, I also believe what Gandalf later reminded Frodo, as a word of encouragement: “There are other forces at work in this world, besides the will of evil.”
In closing, let me leave you with something I came across on the Morehouse website entitled, “An Open Letter to the Men of Morehouse,” written in February 2021, by Dr. Sylayman Clark, after being the guest lecturer for the class that I hope is required for all undergraduates: Introduction to Black Leadership.
Morehouse College, like most viable institutions, will continue to measure its success by the success of its students and alumni. . . In the final analysis, it is always fair and reasonable to ask how our actions and the work of our various organizations serve others and contribute to the greater good. How do we create and maintain organizations that generate more light and less heat? How do we build more bridges and fewer walls that permanently set us at odds with those of different appearances and persuasions? And as aspiring entrepreneurs, how might one do well in order to do good?
I ask these types of questions, firm in the belief that the future of our planet and indeed our species may well hinge on the actions of an authentic “critical mass” of servant leaders operating in all sectors of society and walks of life. The existence and workings of such leaders are clearly identifiable in our national history and in the worldwide annals of historical memory. And it matters not whether they constitute one tenth, one hundredth or one millionth of our global population. What is important is the fact that they effectively exert a leavening effect on society and call us to what Abraham Lincoln rightly referred to as our better angels.
It was Gandhi who famously said, “You must be the change you want to see in the world.” Or shifting metaphors one last time, in the words that the renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright is said to have told a class of aspiring young architects:
As a river can rise no higher than its source, so you can create no greater buildings than you are. So why not go to work on yourselves, so that you become what you would have your buildings be?”
Thank you. May God bless, sustain, and strengthen you on the roads to which you have been called. Amen.
1 Randal Maurice Jelks, Benjamin Elijah Mays, Schoolmaster of the Movement: A Biography, Kindle edition, Location 143.
2 Quoted in many places. https://summerstudy.yale.edu/sites/default/files/sound_of_the_genuine.pdf
3 Peter Eisenstadt, Against the Hounds of Hell: A Life of Howard Thurman (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2021), 206.
4 Quotation found on the Church of the Fellowship of All Peoples website
5 Kelly Brown Douglas, Resurrection Hope: A Future Where Black Lives Matter (Maryknoll New York: Orbis Press, 2021), 221.
6 J.R.R. Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings, Second Edition (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1954), 50.
