We Can Be Brave: On Moral Courage in Turbulent Times

by | Feb 8, 2026

We Can Be Brave: On Moral Courage in Turbulent Times
The Tippy McMichael Lecture
St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Fayetteville, AR
Saturday, February 7, 2026 and Sunday, February 8, 2026

Good evening. Thank you for inviting me to be with you this weekend, for your welcome and hospitality. All that I have learned about Tippy McMichael makes me wish to have known her, and I’m honored to take part in the lecture series that bears her name. 

If there is one message to take away from my time with you, it is that courage, while an innate characteristic, is also something that we learn throughout life. We learn from one another; we learn from life’s circumstances; and, we learn from the particular ways that God calls each one of us to do what, left to our own strength, would be impossible. 

I am persuaded that the sense of call, or summons, that we sometimes feel rising up within us, or that is simply required of us in a given circumstance, is one of the most transformative spiritual experiences of humankind. It moves us to make a conscious decision–to choose one path over another, step across a threshold, or come to terms with a reality that we cannot change. While sometimes we may feel excited by the call, for most of us, most of the time, we feel woefully unprepared. For what we’re being asked to do feels impossible. 

Thus, we learn to be brave, as Eleanor Roosevelt said, by doing the very thing we think we cannot do. We learn to be brave through practice. We learn by tapping into the great spiritual reservoirs of humanity. For those of us who are followers of Jesus, we learn to be brave through studying his teachings, gathering around his table, and trusting his guiding hand. 

Learning to be brave is humbling, at least it has been for me, in that it also involves acknowledging mistakes and missteps, taking responsibility for things I’ve done or said that were hurtful to others. But that’s part of what makes the learning process real, and why it is so helpful to learn from the examples of other people. In their human struggle, we come to embrace our own. 

I’m  currently reading the memoir of the Rev. James Lawson, Jr., entitled Nonviolent. While not as well known as Martin Luther King, Jr. or John Lewis, Lawson was a formidable spiritual and tactical leader of nonviolence during the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and 60. He continued as a practitioner and teacher of nonviolence until his death at age 95. 

The title of his memoir is In the opening sentence Lawson tells of an event in his childhood that shaped the man he would become:

 “I smacked a white boy in the face when I was four years old.” ¹

The other boy, his same age and whom Lawson considered a friend, had called him a racial epithet that was forbidden in Lawson’s house. Lawson remembers feeling shocked and betrayed. “He was rejecting me,” Lawson writes, “and somewhere within my little-boy self he was seeing me as not fully human, because I was Black.” So Lawson hit him as hard as a four-year old could. The other boy hit back, and that was the end of it. He never told his parents about what happened, sensing that his mother would disapprove. But the memory never left him. Later in life, Lawson came to understand what happened that day as a call from God. 

As that boy began his tirade, I felt a force rising up from deep inside, stronger than the mean message in his words. It was an inkling, or an impulse, a spur, urging me to challenge the heat he was spewing. I couldn’t resist it. If I could go back to my four-year-old self and explain that mysterious, astonishing, empowering force within me that day, I would tell my younger self that it was God’s love. And I would assure him that it would always be there for him from that day forward–reminding him that no one has the right to deny, question, or assault the fact of his humanity, his character, his essence.²

There would be more fights, each one giving him assurance that his dignity was worth defending with his fists. But when Lawson was in fourth grade, upon returning home after hitting yet another boy who had taunted him with racial slurs, he made the fateful decision to tell his mother.  

He remembers her standing at the kitchen sink, washing dishes. She didn’t turn to face him, but simply said softly, “Jimmy, what good did that do?” He was stunned into silence by her words. She continued talking, reminding him that they were Christians, that they sought to do God’s will; that they were people of love. 

“I don’t know how long her soliloquy was,” Lawson writes, “but I know she finished it with this sentence, ‘Jimmy, there must be a better a way.’” Then Lawson heard another voice, resounding deep within, that once again, seemed to be the voice of God: You will never fight in this way again. You will find a better way. ³

Those two events of his early childhood marked the beginning of Lawson’s life-long commitment to end racial injustice and violence, without resorting to violence himself. He never fought with his classmates again, and he went on to lead some of the most significant non-violent campaigns of the Civil Rights era.  

As I’ve told this small portion of Lawson’s story, I wonder if there is some aspect of it that resonates with yours. For me, there are at least two. First, I know what it feels like to learn a lesson in courage through a transgression. At four years old, Lawson could hardly be expected to have the moral capacity to weigh his options when his friend attacked his human dignity. Nonetheless, looking back, he knows that he will never resort to violence again. I also did things in my young life that I now regret, and even as I wrap arms of compassion around the little girl I once was, there is a part of me that won’t ever go there again. 

Second, and more importantly, is the way Lawson experienced God speaking to him, with a claim on his life. And in particular, how he felt in those moments.  In a similar way, there was a marking event in my adolescence in which I felt a sense of summons, an experience of inner clarity that wasn’t coming from me, though it rose up within me. I dared to believe that it was the voice of God. Whenever that feeling comes back–and it doesn’t very often–I have learned to listen and to follow as best I can, even when the path is costly. 

*** 

Which brings us to the topic of moral courage: 

Simply defined: moral courage is the willingness to speak up or take action for what you believe to be right, even in the face of fear, opposition, or personal risk. It is the willingness to face personal consequences such as criticism, rejection, or loss of status for a moral cause. Unlike physical courage, which requires facing physical danger, moral courage is the capacity to face social or emotional risks to uphold core, non-negotiable values. 

For moral courage, we need a North Star. 

The actual North Star is a fixed point in the night sky that our forebears relied on for navigation because it remains steady in the northern hemisphere, marking true north. Its constancy is what makes it a vital tool for guidance. Metaphorically, our North Star is whatever helps guide us when we aren’t sure what lies ahead. It symbolizes whatever gives us a sense of direction, or purpose. It’s what we hold onto, especially when we’re feeling disoriented or overwhelmed. It grounds us in certain truths that we hold onto, no matter what. 

What is our North Star?  

What truths do we hold onto when the proverbial winds blow?

This is something I’ve had to give a lot of thought to in the past year. I’ve often gone back to what to Jesus said to the Nicodemus, the Pharisee who came to him at night as told in the Gospel of John:

We speak of what we know and testify to what we have seen. (John 3:11)

That’s what I did my best to articulate at the Inaugural Prayer Service a year ago. I wasn’t speaking for myself, but for all of us, articulating as best I could, what we know and testifying to what we have seen. 

The fact that such a basic sermon–no different from what you would expect to hear from the pulpit at St. Paul’s on any given Sunday— would garner attention says far more about us as a nation than about me. Why would it cause such anger and even rage among some and be an affirmation and source of hope for so many others?  

What the continued response has evoked in me is a sense of responsibility to a religious worldview that seeks to promote the highest of human aspirations, what Jesus called the kingdom of heaven and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. called the Beloved Community. It has given me hope that we, as people of faith, have a vital contribution to make to what needs to be a compelling and comprehensive alternative to the ascendancy of Christian nationalism. And that we are called to do our part to stop those at the helm of our country now who are determined to dismantle the institutions and destroy the guardrails of our democracy and accelerate the very trends we need to reverse for the human species to survive.

Thus, in our tumultuous time, I believe that our greatest contribution as Christians, is for all of us to speak of what we know and testify to what we have seen. More importantly, to live as best we can according to the highest aspirations of humankind revealed to us in Jesus:

to recognize the inherent, God-given dignity of every being being 

to love our neighbors as ourselves, and even to love our enemies 

to share what we have and to strive for an equitable and just society 

to refrain from evil and refuse to hate 

to be mindful of the power of our words, and to speak without malice or contempt to forgive, as we have been forgiven 

to live in hope

to be willing to sacrifice, even our very lives, for the sake of love.  

That is our calling as Christians, one that we can never fulfill on our own power, but through the love and mercy of Christ that lives in us. 

****

In our efforts to be faithful to Christ, we find ourselves in common cause with some Christians and in opposition to others. This is nothing new: Christians have been disagreeing publicly on mercy since the Council of Jerusalem. (Acts 15). Indeed, what President Lincoln said of Christians fighting against one another in the Civil War is true Christians today on opposite sides of public discourse: “Both read the same Bible, and pray to the same God; and each invokes his aid against the other.”4

This raises important questions on how we disagree with one another publicly, and over what issues. 

I must say that I never anticipated being at odds with other Christians about the primacy of mercy.  As far as I can tell, it’s not that some of us think mercy is a good thing, and others think it’s bad. But there is real disagreement about when, how, by whom and for whom mercy should be given. 

The question of mercy has resurfaced this year with the federal government’s dramatic escalation of a policy of immigrant detention and deportation that is evoking terror in immigrant communities across the country. All eyes have been on Minnesota of late, because of the 3000 ICE and Immigration Border Patrol agents deployed there in early January, but the policy is nationwide. 

Some of the strongest supporters of these policies are Christians, though it may be that some of that support is waning. It’s hard to listen to Christians argue in support of what’s happening. 

One of the moral commitments I have made in this turbulent time is to lean hard on the promises we make as Christians in our baptism: To seek and serve Christ in all persons and to respect the dignity of every human being. Thus, to the best of my ability, I will assume the best in all persons and listen to those whose life experiences have led them to different conclusions. 

I have also learned over these many years in ministry that very few people change deeply held assumptions, prejudices or beliefs through persuasive argument, no matter how reasonable or biblically grounded my views seem to me.

We are changed through relationships. We learn love by being loved. We learn forgiveness by being forgiven. We learn mercy by receiving it. Jesus calls us into relationship with the most vulnerable and on the receiving end of dehumanizing speech; and also into relationship with those whose life experiences we do not share and with those with whom we disagree.  

With that in mind, I’d like to share with you two recent experiences:

Two weeks ago, I traveled to Minneapolis. I was one of over 700 clergypersons from around the country who answered the call to stand in solidarity with our counterparts in Minnesota. 

I trust you’ve seen videos and news reports of what life has been like there. I have strong family and vocational ties to Minnesota, and as a result, since early January, I have been on the receiving end of texts, emails and phone messages, all saying variations of: “Whatever you are hearing or seeing from where you are, it cannot convey the level of fear and chaos that we are experiencing.” The personal stories of how people have been treated by agents of the federal government are as horrific as those that have made headlines, and far more widespread. What is less reported, the Episcopal bishop Craig Loya would tell you, are the thousands of expressions of neighborly love through which Minnesotans are taking care of one another. 

It is one of the most moving things I have ever witnessed–the mass mobilization for love. 

I returned to Washington the morning Alex Pretti was shot. His death coupled with a disastrous attempt to convince Americans not to trust what they could see for themselves, seems to have shifted the tone and momentum of ICE, though as yet not enough for those who live there. It’s been heartwrenching to watch from a distance, because this is not an abstraction for me. People who I know and love are in legitimate fear of the federal government. 

The hardest people for me to respond to aren’t those who support the Administration’s stated goal of deporting 3000 detentions a day.  Rather it is the Christians who matter-of-factly speak of the need for safe borders; how unfortunate it was that the previous Administration allowed untold millions of people into our country; that the collateral damage of the current policy is indeed unfortunate, but people should know better than to resist arrest, or to interfere with enforcement officers doing their jobs. 

It’s difficult to be on the receiving end of such opinions, because what’s happening in Minnesota is not about securing the border or addressing an immigration policy that has been in need of reform for decades. It is a campaign of cruelty, designed to invoke fear, carried by officers under pressure to make arrests and who have been assured of complete immunity for their actions. It’s hard to know how to respond to those speaking from a distance, who either do not know, or don’t seem to care about what’s happening in plain sight, and from what we’re learning, behind the closed doors of detention centers across the country.  They aren’t bad people, and they aren’t necessarily wrong in some of their assessments. And yet, listening to them is devastating. 

It makes me wonder when I have spoken like that about people I don’t know and situations that I don’t fully understand. When do I speak with such ignorance and from sufficient distance as to be cruel? 

Proximity doesn’t ensure mercy; but distance and ignorance surely works against it.  

****

A second story: 

Last Saturday the Diocese of Washington held our annual convention. In the afternoon we debated a resolution entitled DIGNITY, NOT HATE, NOT MASS DEPORTATION, NOT SILENCE, a strong call for the congregations in the Diocese of Washington to take up the cause of migrants in our communities–with a list of prescribed actions for congratulations to take.  

It was a resolution crafted in passion and mercy for the most vulnerable among us. Knowing the Diocese of Washington as I do, I had no doubt that the resolution would pass. Nonetheless, those who came to the microphone to support it spoke as if they were at an outdoor rally, tasked with whipping up the crowd; or perhaps on the debate floor with hostile adversaries on the other side. 

No one spoke against the resolution, and I wasn’t surprised. It’s not that everyone was in agreement. I know and love lots of people in our diocese who hold a different view from the one being espoused. I was certain that many were on the Convention floor. There were even more, I was convinced, sympathetic to the resolution, but nonetheless uncomfortable with the strident tone of those putting it forward, the blanket statements made, and the sense of moral superiority in the room. 

I was troubled as I listened, because there was no mercy for those who held a different view or were uncertain. No one spoke in opposition because it wasn’t a welcome space to do so.  We failed to show mercy as we argued for the mercy that migrants rightfully deserve. It is a painful lesson that I take with me. 

***

As we draw this time together to a close, I want to return to the questions at the heart of everything I’ve said tonight. 

What does it mean to be brave, to have moral courage now? Not in the abstract, or what we hope for in others, but for ourselves, within the particular circumstances, relationships, convictions, and constraints that shape who we are and where we stand?   

Moral courage is rarely heroic in the ways we imagine. 

More often, it is steady, relational and sustained over time. 

Moral courage is to be guided by a North Star that helps us navigate in turbulent times. It calls us to speak truthfully about what we know and testify to what we have seen, while remaining open to what we do not yet understand. It asks us to stand for dignity without surrendering mercy, and to pursue justice without losing our capacity for humility.

For those of us who follow Jesus, our North Star is love: love that refuses to dehumanize, love that draws near rather than turns away, love that seeks a better way even when the cost is real and the outcome uncertain. 

Moral courage is not the absence of fear, but faithfulness in the presence of it. We can be brave because we are not asked to carry this alone. We are shaped by one another, strengthened by grace, and sustained by a God who meets us in the storm and walks with us into whatever comes next. 

For a time such as this–by God’s grace and with mercy for others and for ourselves–we can learn how to be brave.


1Rev. James Lawson Jr. and Emily Yellin, Nonviolent: A Memoir of Resistance, Agitation, and Love. (New York: Random House, 2026), 3.

2Nonviolent, 4.

3Nonviolent, 21.

4https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/second-inaugural-address-1865-2/