Thoughts on Reparations from a White Southerner

Thoughts on Reparations from a White Southerner

Several years ago I concluded that our nation must take on the very difficult work of coming to terms with slavery and the subsequent century of Jim Crow segregation. Growing up in North Carolina in the 1950s and 1960s, I experienced the results from this horrible legacy. My small hometown was completely segregated, including the schools that I attended. As a child I was able to see visibly the poor quality of the housing for the Black members of my community, and the low-paying jobs that Black people were forced to take, due to racial discrimination. While I was never explicitly taught in school, in church, or at home that segregation was wrong, I was taught a lesson of kindness and treating others as we would want them to treat us. This pattern of ethical thinking eventually translated for me when I was a college student into concluding that segregation and all racial discrimination was wrong and must end. This decision led to my working for the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) in the deep South during the civil rights movement. I absorbed the fervor of that era, and to this day singing the movement songs brings me to tears.

I grew up knowing that my ancestors had lived in the South beginning in the 18th century and that some of them served in the Civil War on the side of the Confederacy. More recently, I learned that I have Black cousins (through a fourth great-grandfather who fathered a child with the woman he enslaved). Around the same time, I became aware of the reparations process in Germany for those who suffered under the Nazi government. These types of awareness, repentance, and reparations seemed to me to be very necessary in the United States, so that our nation can experience healing from the devastating consequences of slavery and Jim Crow policies. Ultimately this may help us face the future as a more compassionate and less divided nation. While money is not always the solution to every problem, when harm can be traced, a transfer of financial assets from those who benefited (even if generations later) to those who suffered from those policies seems essential to me. On a small scale, I have contributed to the college fund for the daughter of my distant relative, as a form of personal reparations within my family.

Though it may come far in the future, ideally at some point we will create a national-level reparations policy. Until such time, we can demonstrate how such policies can be developed and implemented at a local level. If we can do this within the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, and disseminate our results widely, we can help to build momentum for similar work by other faith communities, other political jurisdictions, and—God willing—ultimately for reparations at the national level.

Embry Howell
Senior Warden, All Souls Episcopal Church
Member, Committee on Diocesan Reparations

Reparations and the Church

Reparations and the Church

As the election season begins to wind down one might take a moment to reflect on the tenor that has been a consistent part of the campaign.

I can’t help but wonder: If this country collectively had done the hard, faithful work of remembering, repenting, and reconciling around the historical harms against indigenous and Black people in the America’s, would this year’s political landscape be so fraught? Maybe America would know how to respect and appreciate the generational challenges faced by indigenous and Black people that are a direct result of practices that resulted in the profiting from genocide and enslaved labor.

Parts of The Episcopal Church are uncovering the painful ways in which its leaders and congregations participated in, and profited from, anti-black and anti-indigenous policies and practices. Multiple dioceses are looking at ways to repent publicly, and make amends, including remuneration for unpaid labor, return of stolen land, and actions that express in word and deed reconciliation. This is the work that the church should be engaged in. Helping shape a narrative of repentance for harms that have contributed to generational trauma and wealth inequity.

Reparations is the act of remembering, repenting, and reconciling. These are words that are laden with theological significance. Scripture points us to the act of remembering—remember the covenant (Genesis 9:15), remember the sabbath (Exodus 20), remember the acts of God (psalm 77). We also must remember those times where we have fallen short of who God has called to be. In Israel there is a museum dedicated to the remembrance of Holocaust victims. At the exit of the museum, Yad Vashem, are the words of Baal Shem Tov (founder of Hasidism), “Forgetfulness leads to exile while remembrance is the secret of redemption.” And it is redemption that Christians are promised. In his letter to the church in Rome, Paul writes, “We know that all things work together for good for those who love God, who are called according to his purpose (Romans 8).” As Mordecai told his cousin Esther, “God will save the people, but maybe you were called to use your power, position, and voice to make change happen now.”

The Gospel mandate calls the faithful to follow a Jesus who pushed his followers to act outside of their comfort zones. Jesus reminded those who were on the journey with him that he was calling them to take up their cross. To proclaim, at times, things that would be hard to say and hear. Jesus reminded his followers to seek forgiveness for their sins and return to God. People of faith follow a Jesus who, throughout his ministry, called his disciples to embrace counter cultural practices. We are all to be faithful, responsive, counter cultural, justice seekers who help make the love of God known to all people. It is not possible to fully respect the worth and dignity of every human knowing that our church sits on land that was taken, or that our church was built by unpaid labor, or that the proceeds from the selling of land or church buildings went to secure the legacy of White congregations. It is with repentance and a change of heart that we will illuminate the path towards redemption.

Christians are called to model behaviors that recognize the face of God in all people. Making reparations is one way the church can model faith-based values that include the actions of remembrance, repentance, and reconciliation. Ultimately, Jesus calls his followers to love as he loved. To share the love of God and participate in the creation of Beloved Community.

Reparations is one more step in the process of loving all our neighbors as ourselves.

The Rev. Glenna Huber
Chair, Policy Working Group, Committee on Diocesan Reparations
Rector, Church of the Epiphany, DC

Healing Histories: A Reparations Dialogue

Healing Histories: A Reparations Dialogue

The Committee on Diocesan Reparations and Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde cordially invite all Black-identifying parishioners—from any parish in the diocese and especially those at our historically Black parishes—to a day of fellowship and discussion of reparations at St. Luke’s Episcopal Church in DC (which is doubling as our brush arbor*).

The Committee will present on the work we have conducted so far, including our research into what reparations might look like in our diocese and how reparations may affect you and your parish. We will also devote good time to hearing your thoughts in a safe, welcoming space. Breakfast and lunch will be served.

Register here

*A brush arbor (also called hush or bush arbor) was a secluded, sacred place, often built with tree branches in remote locations, where enslaved people could worship and meet in secret.

A Reparations Retrospective

A Reparations Retrospective

The beauty of August is that it tends to be the month when life seems to slow down almost to a standstill. A time when you have more moments to catch your breath and actually smell the roses and the jasmine. Many of us leave for vacations with the goal of taking a break from the usual hectic day-to-day, and refreshing ourselves with a new environment. Life these days is a lot more instant and immediate than it used to be, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. But when summer comes, we are much more apt to allow ourselves the freedom of taking a little more time to just be instead of do.

What I love about August (aside from the fact that it’s my birth month) is that if we let it, it can be the perfect season not only to refresh, but also to contemplate and mentally adjust to the possibility (and reality) of change. As one writer put it, “When it’s a hundred degrees in the shade, it’s too hot to be anything but receptive and reflective.”

So this summer, I’m reflecting on the Episcopal Diocese of Washington’s commitment to reparations and what that means to the entire EDOW family. There are those who are firmly convinced that reparations is the right path, but differ intensely on how it should be both defined and applied. There are those who believe the exact opposite—that a reparations package is going too far and is completely unnecessary. Then there are those who are on the fence, or are unclear about where they stand, but believe that our Bishop Mariann Budde, as EDOW’s leader, is forging the path that God laid out for the diocese. And I believe God honors us as we pray for all of our leaders. There are many places in the Bible where we are directed to pray for them (and not just that they will come around to our way of thinking, but that they will actually be led by God).1

Reparations is an extremely difficult subject to wrap our collective heads around—no matter where we come from. Writing about it is harder still; because if you don’t know me or have never heard me talk about it, you may find it challenging to get a sense of who I am and how I approach this (with a lot of love and prayer). Reckoning honestly and objectively with the impacts of how our diocese benefitted from chattel slavery isn’t for the faint of heart, and the reparations committee is dedicated to engaging the entire diocese lovingly and respectfully throughout this process. To be clear, EDOW, as an entity, did not own slaves. However—as with most White organizations after the Civil War and during the era of Jim Crow—it did benefit from policies that allowed behaviors like anti-Black racism, and lifestyles like White supremacy to flourish. But if we approach reparations from the perspective that there will be winners and losers, then we’ve already lost. EDOW is one family, and this is not a zero-sum game. Restoration and reconciliation will always benefit the entire family, even if we don’t all agree on the methods—in this case, reparations.

As we examine our hearts during these quiet summer days, what comes to the surface? My prayer is that, as we listen to Spirit, we hear that still small voice. What are we being asked to do? What are we being asked to stop doing? Right now, we are in a season of change. God is doing new things throughout the world and throughout The Episcopal Church. Do you remember that old DC Talk song “God is Doing a New Thing”? Okay, I’m definitely showing my age. But I digress. My point is that God is calling all of us, as Episcopalians, but especially as Christians, to step up and represent. And that means dispelling old narratives, resolving old quarrels, putting aside old grudges, and maybe, even old ways of doing things. Jesus was a revolutionary. He shook up the status quo. Those early Christians didn’t become martyrs because they thought it was a flex. What is Spirit saying to us now? Will we listen… and (gulp) obey?

September is the season of harvest, and we’ll get back to doing (with a vengeance). But for now, while it’s still summertime and the livin’ is easy (allegedly), let’s make time to truly understand EDOW’s reparations mission. If you have questions, ask them. Invite us to your parish to talk. Come to our programs.

Speaking of programs, we have two coming up we’d like to bring to your attention. We’ve said many times that EDOW is one family. And sometimes, within a family, separate members need to have specific conversations so that the family unit comes back together stronger and more united than ever. Given the nature of the issue of the legacy of chattel slavery and collective trauma, we feel it behooves us to have a separate conversation with the Black members of this family. So while at first glance, that may appear counterintuitive, our hope is that you are able to see the bigger picture for the greater good. To that end, we’ve invited EDOW’s Black parishioners out for a day of history, education, and discussion on September 28th. The formal invitation has been shared with parish leaders and should appear in parish bulletins each week leading up to the event. (If your parish didn’t receive the invite, please contact us.) We’ll go into more depth about this event in our Diocesan Bulletin article next month.

The second event—Friday, January 24, 2025, on the evening before Diocesan Convention—is for the entire diocesan family. Planning is underway for this program which will take place at Washington National Cathedral. So stay tuned for more on that as well.

We sincerely hope to see you somewhere between now and Convention 2025.

Peace & Power,

Gigi Nelson
Education Chair for the Committee on Diocesan Reparations

11 Timothy 2:1-2: Urges believers to pray for all people in authority, including kings, for wisdom, and for peaceful and godly lives.
Titus 2:7-8: Asks that Jesus’ followers in leadership positions lead with integrity.
Psalm 22:28: Asks that leaders seek God’s will.
Ephesians 6:12: Acknowledges that there is a spiritual battle against evil forces, and that praying for those in authority can help them align with God’s will.

Jubilee… Reparations… Juneteenth

Jubilee… Reparations… Juneteenth

At first glance, this title might look like the beginning of a random word salad, but these words do make sense together. For starters, a Jubilee is an occurrence known and celebrated by many different cultures and religions (every 40 or 50 years depending on how you count a generation). However, it also has a uniquely African American connotation based on Leviticus 25:9-10.

“Then have the trumpet blown on the tenth day of the seventh month. Have the trumpet blown throughout your land on the Day of Reconciliation [Atonement]. You will make the fiftieth year holy, proclaiming freedom throughout the land to all its inhabitants. It will be a Jubilee year for you: each of you must return to your family property and to your extended family.” (Leviticus 25:9-10, CEB)

If any people understood the concept of freedom, it was the Israelites who’d left Egypt under the guidance of Moses, and with his siblings’ help. Understandably, in 1865 newly freed African Americans had a distinct appreciation for the stories in Exodus and Leviticus.

What did freedom mean to a people who had not been free for generations?

I imagine that there is a very specific kind of beauty in learning that one is no longer enslaved. The freedom to wake up when you want, dance and sing when you feel like it and not for a slave owner’s entertainment. To come and go as you please, marry whom you choose, raise your children, worship God in ways that are meaningful to you. Work at what your capabilities allow.

What do you do with freedom in this context? Where do you even start? Does a mother decide to learn to read, or does she go immediately in search of her children who were sold away to the deep south? Does she even have any money to make a trip like that possible? Does a husband set out to find his wife who had been given away to a family up North? Or does he set about working as hard as he can to build a life and stay put in the hopes that she returns to him? This uncertainty was a situation ripe for exploitation. And in post-Civil War America, that is what happened to most of the Freedmen—who ended up in sharecropper/tenant farmer situations.

It has been nearly 160 years since the end of the Civil War. And yet we still see the exploitative effects of those four centuries of enslavement in almost every aspect of American public life. By most metrics, African Americans overall have less generational wealth, less education, less access to good healthcare, live in environments more negatively affected by climate change, pay higher mortgages (even when the rates are already sky high), have worse encounters with law enforcement, the list goes on.

So what does any of that have to do with reparations in the Episcopal Diocese of Washington? Is there a through line from the legacy of slavery (with its concomitant issues of anti-Black bias, white supremacy, exploitation, etc.) to EDOW’s own racial history, to EDOW’s Black parishes in DC and Maryland. Does the Episcopal Diocese of Washington bear any responsibility for the lasting legacy of slavery? Maybe a better question is: Did EDOW profit at any point—directly or indirectly—from either the Transatlantic slave trade or the American domestic slave trade? Were some parish founders and Vestry members slave owners? Did EDOW’s wealthy parishes intentionally build churches in areas with enforced racial covenants? Is evidence of financial disparity in EDOW’s Black and White churches also evidence of injustice? If EDOW itself is not technically responsible for the still-existing collateral damage of the past, is it accountable? And if accountable, how is any kind of restitution to be made? To whom? This is at the crux of reparations. It is an honest attempt to recognize, repent, and repair–to lead to reconciliation.

The work of our Committee on Diocesan Reparations has been conducting research and gathering information to help answer those very questions. The Rev. Peter Jarrett-Schell’s presentation at Convention in January outlined the differences in EDOW’s majority Black and predominantly White parishes. The Episcopal Diocese of Washington believes it does have a responsibility to repair the breach in ways that are meaningful as it relates to race and justice.

We hope that you’ve answered the call and used this past year to really delve into your parish history and see where those intersections of race and justice occur, for better or worse. As we’ve said before, this isn’t about shaming or humiliating anyone or trying to make anyone feel bad. For too long, we’ve swept too much of the true history of our parishes (and by extension our diocese) under the rug because it didn’t fit the neat and happy narrative we wanted to portray. It is time out for that.

Let’s not be afraid to be honest about our history. It doesn’t make you, your parish, or past parish elders bad people. I think God would be less pleased if we try to hide / sanitize / whitewash things when we are in this current era of complete truth-telling. Let’s use this as a true opportunity to form real relationships with each other. To acknowledge where we may have fallen short and pledge to do better. No one expects it to be easy, but what we do hope is that you can draw the through line for yourself and recognize that while none of us may be personally responsible, we are all accountable. And for EDOW, accountability means reparations.

This brings us to Juneteenth, this newest American Federal holiday. What is it about exactly? For a little historical context, the origins of Juneteenth date back to June 19, 1865, when the U.S. Army spread the message to 250,000 enslaved people in Texas (the state that had become the last bastion for slavery during the final days of the Civil War), that they were free. Slaves in the other parts of the Confederacy had been freed by the Emancipation Proclamation.1 Very soon afterwards, African American communities organized local festivities to celebrate and remember the significance of that day. The celebrations continued year after year and spread across the country. That celebration brings us back full circle to the word “Jubilee”. And of course, that conjures up family (a la Leviticus). I like to think those early Juneteenth celebrations were all about family and reconnecting with loved ones.

In 1980, Texas became the first to make Juneteenth a state holiday. Shortly after, other states followed suit, along with organizations and businesses across the nation hosting events and educational opportunities dedicated to commemorating the significance of this day.

In 2021, President Biden proclaimed Juneteenth a Federal holiday.2

So how is a holiday that is very specific to one group celebrated by everyone, regardless of ethnicity? That’s actually pretty easy.

Everyone can celebrate Juneteenth by:

  • Updating the family tree.
  • Taking photos and/or videos of elderly relatives.
  • Recording the stories of the elders.
  • Compiling those stories into a family movie.
  • Digging through attics and basements of the older members of your family.
  • Uploading your finds (things like wills, bills of sale, inventories, diary entries, etc.) to free sites like WikiTree, Ten Million Names Project, etc. Those documents may be “embarrassing” to you, but to Black genealogists looking to make family connections, they could be an absolute goldmine. Genealogy is social justice on a very personal level.

Next year, 2025, will be the 160th anniversary of the end of the Civil War. It is essentially a Year of Jubilee and EDOW has elected to celebrate with a meaningful reparations initiative.

Gigi Nelson is the chair of the Education Working Group of the Diocesan Committee on Reparations and attends the Episcopal Church of the Atonement in DC. She is also the author of For The Culture: A Genealogy Handbook For The Cool Kids.

1Slavery ended in Washington DC on 16 April 1862, when President Lincoln signed an act abolishing it. He issued the Emancipation Proclamation on 1 January 1863. It did not end slavery in border states loyal to the Union. (Note: By 1804, all the Northern states abolished slavery, but emancipation itself was not always immediate.)
2This was the first new Federal holiday since Martin Luther King Jr. Day in 1983.