Parish History Spotlight: St. Columba’s Explores Its Racial History

Parish History Spotlight: St. Columba’s Explores Its Racial History

All parishes in the Diocese of Washington are encouraged to examine their histories from the perspective of race and racism. Over the next few months, we will spotlight parishes that are engaging in this work of truth telling through a racial lens.

In 2022, St. Columba’s Episcopal Church embarked on a quest to understand how pervasive racial segregation shaped the parish, located in northwest Washington’s Tenleytown neighborhood.
Parishioners have been researching St. Columba’s ties to the former African American community known as Reno City, which developed on Fort Reno near Tenleytown after the Civil War. Formerly enslaved persons settled on the land formerly occupied by the Union Army and built homes, community organizations, and churches, including St. George’s Episcopal Chapel.

St. Columba's Explores It Racial History: St. George's Episcopal Church in Reno City, Northwest, Washington DC
St. Columba's Explores Its Racial History: Parishiors of St. George's Episcopal Church in Reno City In Northwest Washington, DC

Initially established as a mission church for African Americans by St. Alban’s Parish, St. George’s later became a mission of St. Columba’s when it became a separate parish. St. George’s flourished under the leadership of its vicar, the Rev. Edward Douse, a Black Jamaican priest, who also served as vicar of the mission chapel for African Americans established by St. John’s parish in Georgetown. St. George’s Mission offered regular church services, baptisms, confirmations, adult education, and childcare for working mothers.

As the white population grew in Northwest Washington, however, real estate developers and government officials sought to clear the Reno community to build a school for white students, a park, and an all-white neighborhood on the surrounding land. In the late 1920’s, the city condemned the land where homes and St. George’s Chapel stood and built the Alice Deal Junior High for white students. In the years that followed, the rest of Reno City was demolished to create the Fort Reno National Park.

St. Columba’s research found that the parish did not join the African Americans who sought to prevent the condemnation of the Reno community and St. George’s Chapel there. In fact, St. Columba’s membership grew as the white population in Tenleytown increased. The research also revealed that St. Columba’s benefited greatly from gifts of land and money acquired by generations of the Murdock family, who relied on the labor of enslaved persons from the 1700’s until the Civil War. The research project motivated St. Columba’s to become more involved in public advocacy, including for affordable housing in Northwest Washington and throughout the city.

This research was made possible by gracious assistance from parishioners at St. Alban’s Parish, who provided records from their parish’s extensive archives, and from archivists at the Diocese of Washington. Parishioners gathered additional materials from public sources such as census and land records as well as research conducted by historians into Tenleytown and the Reno community. These materials enabled parishioners to understand St. Columba’s past within the broader context of racial segregation in Washington, including within The Episcopal Church.

For more information on parish history projects in the Diocese of Washington, visit Parish History Projects: Telling the Truth About Race and Racism.

Parish History: The Stories That We Tell

Parish History: The Stories That We Tell

Upon arriving at St. Paul’s, Waldorf in 2014, I quickly learned that the fastest way to stoke a fire was to ask about the former balcony. Like most parishes established in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, St. Paul’s balcony was in fact a gallery for the enslaved. After slavery, Jim Crow segregation continued the dehumanizing pattern of relegating black parishioners to second-tier seating. The story of its demise in the 1950s is one for the ages–and one for which I don’t have space to recount. Suffice to say that it involved multiple congregational votes, an intrepid group of young parishioners arriving in the dark to tear it down against the will of parish leaders, and finally the loss of a small, but significant group of parishioners and pledges (and even the parish rectory).

However, to have heard some long-time parishioners retell it, the balcony had nothing to do with racism and everything to do with “church growth.” Its demise, they told me, had everything to do with its disrepair alone. To suggest otherwise, was to slander the memory and good will of beloved parishioners. Between the time of my arrival and now, oral histories and the contextualization of the balcony’s existence in the larger narrative of America’s history and Episcopal Church culture have helped the congregation to counter the narrative of “church growth.” We’ve uncovered a thread of holy resistance connecting the resistance of the 1950s to the resistance of the church’s Civil War-era rector, who did what was otherwise unthinkable in Maryland’s tobacco-producing region at the time: preach abolition (only after freeing those he himself had enslaved a few years prior) and pray for President Lincoln (an act of resistance that forced him to flee for his own safety). While some still balk at the mention of the “balcony,” our continued discussions are slowly rendering it from “that-which-we-won’t-name” to simply one of St. Paul’s many complicated yet ever-surprising, and–increasingly on occasion–inspiring chapters. To be sure, we still have much more work to do.

The stories that we all tell (or don’t tell about the past) determine how we live the Gospel in the present and future. Parish history projects aren’t an exercise in shaming or disremembering. They are an act of holy “re-membering” that which is so deeply a part of all of us. They situate us in God’s larger narrative of sin… and repair and redemption.

The Rev. Dr. Maria A. Kane serves as rector at St. Paul’s, Waldorf. She earned a Ph.D. in American history from the College of William & Mary.

The following is adapted from Leading Racial and Public History Projects: Lessons from Faith, Race, and the Lost Cause, a workshop led by Dr. Christopher Graham, The Rev. Maria A. Kane, Ph.D., and The Rev. Melanie Mullen at It’s All About Love: A Festival for the Jesus Movement.

WHAT A PARISH HISTORY PROJECT IS NOT
    • An ode and exaltation of the past
    • Biographies of selected leaders
    • Timeline of special events or a summarization of records.
WHAT IS A GOOD PARISH HISTORY PROJECT?
    • Must be willing to tell the truth even at the expense of cherished traditions and ideals
    • Looks at how beliefs were lived in daily life
    • Integrates social, cultural, economic, and political context
    • Addresses issues of power
    • Asks questions of what is being said and NOT being said
    • Interrogates leading voices and asks who and what is missing
    • Investigates how mission and vision statements were embodied in daily life
El Grupo de Trabajo de Políticas del Comité de Reparaciones Diocesanas

El Grupo de Trabajo de Políticas del Comité de Reparaciones Diocesanas

Este verano compartimos sobre cómo la diócesis está tomando el siguiente paso fiel hacia las reparaciones en la diócesis y las metas del Grupo de Trabajo de Educación del Comité de Reparaciones Diocesanas. Como co-presidenta del Grupo de Trabajo de Políticas, esta semana presentaré el trabajo que vamos a realizar.

Aunque nuestra función, especificada en la resolución (la traducción al español sigue después del inglés) aprobada en la Convención Diocesana del 2023, no incluye escribir las políticas, el grupo de trabajo ofrecerá información sobre qué políticas pueden ser creadas para proveer ayuda apropiada en respuesta a los daños ocasionados por el racismo anti-negro en la diócesis. También identificaremos y ofreceremos recomendaciones para acciones administrativas y legislativas que pueden ser implementadas.

Si reflexionamos sobre algunas políticas que seguimos actualmente, podemos reconocer que son políticas creadas por una narrativa relacionada con cómo entendemos la iglesia. Por ejemplo, en la Iglesia Episcopal hay políticas y procedimientos que son usados con relación a las prácticas de ordenación, y que todos seguimos. Aunque muchas de esas políticas son canónicas y necesarias, frecuentemente ellas no toman en cuenta los obstáculos que los candidatos de comunidades tradicionalmente poco representadas deben enfrentar para participar ser parte de la iglesia. Los resultados de estas políticas encubiertas han provocado que las iglesias con liderazgo clerical no puedan cumplir las necesidades espirituales culturales específicas ni hablar el idioma original de sus miembros.

Una parte esencial de nuestro grupo de política será proveer maneras en que la diócesis puede cambiar esta narrativa y mirar más de cerca las historias que nos hemos contado a nosotros mismos sobre la Diócesis Episcopal de Washington y las parroquias que son parte de ella.

El trabajo de reparaciones no tiene que ver solo con dar recursos financieros, sino también con reconocer que la narrativa bajo la cual hemos estado funcionando, está incompleta. Y esa falta de plenitud necesita examen, confesión, reconciliación y restauración.

Un colega de la diócesis y miembro del Comité de Reparaciones Diocesanas, la Rev. Melanie Mullen, ofreció algunas ideas en el evento “Todo sobre el Amor”, el mes pasado en Baltimore: “La confesión y la reconciliación racial en las iglesias comienza como un proceso de descubrimiento liderado por la comunidad. Las necesidades de crear políticas relacionadas con la raza implica contar las historias del trabajo mientras construimos un nuevo camino hacia la Comunidad Amada”.

Esto nos recuerda que hay una puerta de entrada para todos los miembros de la diócesis que quieren participar en este trabajo de reparaciones. Esta acción de contar la verdad sobre nuestras parroquias, cómo fueron fundadas, quiénes eran bienvenidos a adorar y dónde podían ser bautizados, casados y enterrados, nos hace pensar en las historias que contamos y las formas en que esas historias han dado forma a las políticas en esta diócesis.

Nuestra esperanza, mientras caminamos juntos hacia la justicia restaurativa y las reparaciones, es que tengamos valentía para decir la verdad sobre el mal hecho en nuestro nombre, reconocer las formas en que hemos sido cómplices, y luego cambiar la narrativa para que podamos con integridad integrar las políticas diocesanas y facilitar una reconciliación racial amplia hasta llegar a ser la Comunidad Amada.

La Rev. Glenna Huber
Co-presidenta, Grupo de Trabajo de Políticas, Comité de Reparaciones Diocesanas
Rectora, Epiphany, DC

The Policy Working Group of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations

The Policy Working Group of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations

This summer, we have shared about how the diocese is taking our next faithful step toward diocesan reparations and the goals of the Education Working Group of the Committee on Diocesean Reparations. As a co-chair of the Policy Working Group, this week I will outline the scope of our work.

While our role, specified by the resolution passed at the 2023 Diocesan Convention, does not include crafting policy, the working group will offer insight into what policies could be created to provide appropriate redress for the harms done by anti-Black racism within the diocese. We will also identify and offer recommendations for administrative or legislative actions that make sense to implement.

If we were to reflect on some policies that we currently function under, we might recognize that these are policies shaped by a narrative that we have constructed about our church. For example, in the larger Episcopal Church, there are policies and procedures in place regarding ordination practices that we abide by. While many of those policies are canonical and necessary, they often do not take into account the landmines that candidates from historically underrepresented communities must overcome to get to the table. The results of these overt and covert policies have led to churches with clerical leadership that sometimes cannot meet culturally specific spiritual needs or even speak the native language of the gathered.

An essential part of our policy work will be about providing ways that the diocese can shift the narrative.To look closely at the stories we have told ourselves about the Episcopal Diocese of Washington and the parishes that are a part of it.

The work of reparations is not just about disbursing financial resources, but also recognizing that the narrative we have collectively been functioning under is incomplete. And that lack of wholeness deserves examination, confession, reconciliation and then restoration.

A diocesan colleague and ad hoc member of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations, the Rev. Melanie Mullen offered these thoughts at the It’s All About Love event in Baltimore last month: “Racial reckoning and reconciliation in churches begins as a community-led process of discovery. Racially just policy-making needs this story telling work as we build a new path towards Beloved Community.”

This reminds us that there is an entry point for all diocesan members to participate in this reparation work. This truth telling about our parishes, how they came to be, who was welcome to worship in them, and where they could be baptized, married, and buried may cause us to think about the stories we have told and the ways in which those stories have shaped the policies of this diocese.

Our hope, as we journey together towards restorative justice and reparations, is that we have the courage to tell the truth about the evil done on our behalf, acknowledge the ways in which we are complicit, and then shift the narrative so that we may with integrity integrate diocesan policies that allow for substantive racial reconciliation and Beloved Community.

The Rev. Glenna Huber
Co-chair, Policy Working Group, Committee on Diocesan Reparations
Rector, Epiphany, DC

The Education Working Group of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations

The Education Working Group of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations

In our last article we noted that at the Convention last January, the Reparations Task Force transitioned to the Committee on Diocesan Reparations with two working groups—Education and Policy. In this post, we’ll discuss the goals of the Education Working Group in a bit more detail.

Reparations is a subject that demands discourse. And rightly so, because even just the word itself engenders a multitude of feelings for a multitude of reasons—in both Black and White parishioners. And that’s okay. We all have reasons to feel the way we feel. The concept itself is not new, and as a nation, we are finally attempting to reckon with the ramifications of centuries of systemic and institutional anti-Black racism. On a local level, our diocese has committed to exploring that impact in our particular context.

We recognize that racism based on ethnicity has negatively affected many other ethnic groups in the diocese. Our Asian, Latino, Native American, Caribbean, and African parishioners, and others, have experienced EDOW in ways that were not always welcoming or positive. But there is a specific reason that the work of this committee focuses primarily on the descendants of those Africans who were enslaved and brought to the colony of Maryland (and later the District of Columbia) against their will and who interacted in some capacity with the Episcopal diocese of the area. Until recently, the diocese’s relationship with its past was for the most part, a one-sided, sanitized, and whitewashed version. Few cared to dig deeper to piece together a complete truth that also encompassed the stories of enslaved Blacks who helped build it–and, later, the freed men and women who sustained it. In the quest for greater equity and justice, the diocese recognized the importance of looking backward in order to move forward, and committed to action as well as talk.

As a historian, the first thing you learn in history school (okay, that’s not really a thing), but the first lesson is that objectivity is fundamental and non-negotiable. That means presenting information without opinion, bias, exaggeration, etc. But it also means telling the whole truth and not leaving out the embarrassing, uncomfortable, or downright horrific parts. The parts where maybe some of the people we revere the most didn’t always do the right thing. Or, God forbid, they did really terrible things. That can be really hard—acknowledging that the people or the institutions we look up to made mistakes.
It is an indisputable fact that few people alive today are responsible for anything that happened in the Episcopal Diocese of Washington before the 1950s. It is equally true that since its founding in 1895 (1608 technically, if you count the years when parishes were part of the Diocese of Maryland), our diocese has benefited tremendously from systemic and institutional racist norms that allowed White parishes to thrive while their Black counterparts languished.

We now have an opportunity to redress some of the policies, practices, and procedures, written and unwritten, spoken and unspoken, that have carried on for generations, and make our diocese a little more equitable for all of its members, a little more genuinely just, a little more compassionate. So we owe it to ourselves and future generations to look the past squarely in the face, listen to those who have been hurt, harmed, excluded, or otherwise marginalized, and make meaningful change.

The goal of the Committee on Diocesan Reparations’ Education Working Group is to present to the parishes of EDOW historical information about the diocese, where and how it intersected with the lives of Black people within its jurisdiction, and the impact of those interactions, for good or bad. Maybe it was during slavery, maybe it was during Jim Crow. Maybe some churches benefited from local legislation that harmed nearby Black communities. Perhaps some parishes may find that they only paid lip-service to the idea of diversity or multiculturalism—or only embraced it when the diverse and multicultural populations didn’t really include Black people. Some parishes have already begun that work of looking into their historical records with an unflinching eye and telling the whole story. And no, it’s not always flattering, but it is honest.

Maybe none of this will change your stance on reparations—wherever you may find yourself in this debate. And that’s okay too. We just want to present you with information as to why the diocese chose this path, and why it matters. We are in the process of developing resources for you which will be shared as they are completed. In the coming months, you’ll have a chance to review what we’ve found, and we hope you’ll come away with a more informed understanding of EDOW’s commitment.

We want to present this information in a variety of formats—there will be handouts that you can download and print, or read online, videos you can watch, and eventually, real-time in-person conversations to talk through this. We want to provide a safe space for that honesty I mentioned earlier, because sometimes honesty is scary. Maybe we’re afraid we’re going to lose a little of our shine. Or maybe we’re afraid we won’t be sincerely heard. But without delving into our past and acknowledging it fully (the good, the bad, and the ugly), we can’t hope to truly begin to heal—repair the breach as it were—and further become Beloved Community.

I’ll close by saying that when I was invited to be part of this work, one of the scriptures that immediately came to mind was 2 Corinthians 5:18: “All this is from God who reconciled us to himself through Christ, and gave us the ministry of reconciliation.” This is the only place in the Bible where each of us, as followers of Christ, are given the exact same task: the ministry of reconciliation.

As the Episcopal Diocese of Washington and its parishes commit to learning (sometimes hard) truths about the past, our prayer is that reconciliation, equity, and justice inform the decisions of our future.

Gigi Nelson
Chair, Education Working Group
Committee on Diocesan Reparations
St. Luke’s Episcopal Church, Washington DC